CAPS-5 — Hughes Administration (Heard, Dec. 27, 2021)
Hughes's December 27, 2021 CAPS-5 scoring form for Heard, introduced as Plaintiff's 1247. The defense's offer of the same material as Defendant's 1435 was excluded as hearsay.
About
Central methodological battleground between the two forensic psychologists. Dennison used the form page by page to identify blank frequency fields, a sparse three-word anchoring event description, and margin-note childhood trauma testing, challenging whether Hughes's administration met standardization requirements. Hughes responded in rebuttal that Heard's scores were mild to moderate and that blank fields reflected a deliberate clinical choice documented in supplemental notes. Curry testified that the non-standard administration invalidated Hughes's PTSD diagnosis resting on it.
The CAPS-5 structured clinical interview was administered by Hughes to Heard on December 27, 2021, producing an approximately 59-page handwritten scoring form. The plaintiff introduced the form as Plaintiff's 1247; the defense sought to admit the same materials as Defendant's 1435, which was excluded on hearsay grounds.