Skip to content
evidenceevidencedocumentary2022 Defamation TrialCAPS-5 — Hughes Administration (Heard, Dec. 27, 2021)Hughes's December 27, 2021 CAPS-5 scoring form for Heard, introduced as Plaintiff's 1247. The defense's offer of the same material as Defendant's 1435 was excluded as hearsay.
← All Evidence
Documentary Evidence

CAPS-5 — Hughes Administration (Heard, Dec. 27, 2021)

Hughes's December 27, 2021 CAPS-5 scoring form for Heard, introduced as Plaintiff's 1247. The defense's offer of the same material as Defendant's 1435 was excluded as hearsay.

5 proceedings5 mentions1 trial

About

Central methodological battleground between the two forensic psychologists. Dennison used the form page by page to identify blank frequency fields, a sparse three-word anchoring event description, and margin-note childhood trauma testing, challenging whether Hughes's administration met standardization requirements. Hughes responded in rebuttal that Heard's scores were mild to moderate and that blank fields reflected a deliberate clinical choice documented in supplemental notes. Curry testified that the non-standard administration invalidated Hughes's PTSD diagnosis resting on it.

The CAPS-5 structured clinical interview was administered by Hughes to Heard on December 27, 2021, producing an approximately 59-page handwritten scoring form. The plaintiff introduced the form as Plaintiff's 1247; the defense sought to admit the same materials as Defendant's 1435, which was excluded on hearsay grounds.

Trial Record (5)