Evidence

Photographs of the downstairs bar area in the Gold Coast, Australia rental house, showing blood, glass, tissue on the floor, and a possible wall-mounted telephone. Multiple witnesses across multiple trial days used these photos to illustrate the scene where Depp's fingertip injury occurred and where Heard alleged a bottle was used in a sexual assault.

Photographs of bathroom mirrors in the Gold Coast, Australia rental house bearing messages written in black oil paint and red lipstick, including "Starring Billy Bob and Easy Amber" and the inscription "Call Carly Simon. She said it better, babe." Depp attributed the black oil-paint writing to himself and the red lipstick line to Heard; house manager Ben King confirmed he personally cleaned the mirrors that night and identified the materials, though he could not determine the layering order.

Photograph of Depp passed out with ice cream spilled on him, taken during the Black Mass filming period. Heard sent the photo to Raquel Pennington on August 7, 2014 with the message 'This is what I've been dealing with.'

Multiple photographs of Heard's face from May 21, 2016 showing facial redness, including two photos sharing an identical timestamp of 9:25:12 PM but differing in brightness and redness, and two photos described as having identical filenames but differing redness. Shown to witnesses Saenz and Hadden, who respectively attributed the redness to crying rather than injury and saw no injuries.

Graphic emergency room photograph of Johnny Depp's severed right middle finger sustained during the Australia incident. The photograph provides a clear profile of the injured fingertip, including detail of the fingernail and surrounding tissue, and was shown to multiple witnesses across several days of testimony.

Self-portrait photograph taken by Heard on March 23, 2013, depicting a bruise on her upper arm, which she sent to her mother. The photograph was introduced at trial to corroborate Heard's account of a March 2013 physical altercation with Depp, and was also shown to Bruce Witkin to compare to a bruise he testified observing.

Defendant's Exhibits 710, 712, 713, and 714, consisting of May 21, 2016 face photographs of Heard. Exhibits 712 and 713 appear visually different but share identical timestamps (hour, minute, second) and identical filenames. Admitted in unredacted 712A/713A form, those versions contain metadata indicating a capture date of December 21, 2016.

Photograph depicting a clump of hair on the floor, associated with the December 15–16, 2015 incident at Depp's penthouse. iO Tillett Wright identified this as the clump of hair he was shown at penthouse 3 on December 16, 2015; during cross-examination, Depp's counsel challenged the timing between the alleged incident and when Wright claims to have observed the hair.

Photographs of Heard's facial bruising, including bruising around the eyes, shown to couples therapist Laurel Anderson by Heard around the time of the December 15, 2015 incident. Anderson also personally observed small bruises approximately one inch in size in more than one location on Heard's face when Heard came to her office on December 17, 2015.

Photographs depicting Heard's scalp injuries and hair loss associated with the December 15–16, 2015 incident. iO Tillett Wright identified them as consistent with scalp injuries he personally observed at penthouse 3 on December 16, 2015; Raquel Pennington authenticated Pennington Exhibit 6 as depicting the scalp wound she observed on December 15, 2015.

Photograph taken by Heard showing Depp passed out on Depp's Bahamian island in July 2013, described by Heard as showing him 'on the nod.'

Photograph taken by Heard showing Depp passed out on the floor in Tokyo in July 2013.

The plaster splint applied to Johnny Depp's third and fourth fingers following surgery on March 20, 2015, described during David Kulber's testimony. On redirect, Kulber clarified that the splint was a partial plaster, non-circumferential, soft-sided construction.

A photograph of the carpeting or flooring in the hallway area near the penthouse elevator, showing a reddish stain or discoloration. The same image was introduced during the examinations of both Officer Saenz and Officer Hadden.

Photographs depicting long, uniform cuts on Heard's arm and wrist area, documented after the Australia incident. Ben King identified the cuts as consistent with what he observed on Heard during the flight back to Los Angeles; iO Tillett Wright separately identified cuts consistent with injuries he saw after Heard returned from Australia.

Photographic evidence of Heard's purported injuries admitted as screenshots and screen grabs through lay witnesses during Heard's defense case, with EXIF metadata excluded by prior court ruling. These photographs were central to the dispute over the proper scope of Neumeister's testimony as a rebuttal expert.

Opening statement previews of Heard injury photographs, with the plaintiff's preview challenging forensic authenticity by noting non-original files in an editing program, and the defendant's preview citing the photos as corroboration of abuse allegations including bruises, cuts, black eyes, and hair loss with metadata.

Photograph taken by Heard at her Orange apartment circa March 22, 2013, showing four lines of cocaine arranged on a breakfast table alongside a drug box labeled 'Property of JD' and brown liquor, with a cigarette in an ashtray.

Photographs of Heard's injured face taken at the penthouse on the night of May 21, 2016, designated as Exhibit 42 and taken by Raquel Pennington. Pennington identified a swollen and red right cheek and eye in the images.

A demonstrative exhibit, designated PX1303, showing three versions of the same injury photograph with mismatched file sizes that would not hash or digitally fingerprint consistently. Ackert later used the same demonstrative to explain why hash mismatches are expected and benign in Apple ecosystem photo handling, where emailing or resizing alters hash values without altering visual appearance.

Emergency room photograph showing a cigarette burn wound on Johnny Depp's cheek, taken during the Australia incident. The photograph is among the images associated with Depp's hospital visit and documents an injury Depp attributed to Heard during the altercation.

Photograph showing whiskey and cocaine alongside a 'Property of JD' skull-and-crossbones box at Heard's apartment.

A summary chart, designated Defendant's Exhibit 1675, listing IDS evidence numbers, source types distinguishing physical devices from iTunes or iCloud backups, and device details for all Heard evidence collected. Published as a demonstrative exhibit.

A chart, designated Defendant's Exhibit 1671, mapping each item in Neumeister's report to the corresponding original photograph found on Heard's devices, with columns for date captured and evidence ID. Published as a demonstrative exhibit.

Photograph of Depp in an incapacitated state presented during expert psychiatric testimony.

A series of photographs of the Gold Coast, Australia rental house interior and grounds, spanning exhibit numbers DX-1804 through DX-1842, introduced by Heard's team.

Multi-page floor plan of the Gold Coast, Australia rental house introduced by Depp's team.

Photograph of a lampshade from the main-level art studio of the Gold Coast, Australia rental house, showing a painting applied to its surface.

Photograph taken at the Gold Coast, Australia rental house showing canvases of Heard that had been completely painted over.

Photograph from the Gold Coast, Australia rental house depicting destruction of property.

An audio clip, approximately at the 33–34 minute mark, capturing Johnny Depp's voice at the Australia rental house on or around March 8, 2015.

An audio recording captured during the cleanup of the Gold Coast, Australia rental house, featuring the voice of Jerry Judge, Depp's former head of security, who has since died.

Photographs of Johnny Depp's facial injuries taken by security guard Sean Bett on multiple occasions, referenced as the basis for Bett's stated safety concern for Depp. The specific exhibits are authenticated in Bett's direct examination but are not individually identified in this reference.

Defendant's Exhibit 509, a photograph of a broken bed frame that Heard testified documented damage from the December 15, 2015 incident. Cross-examination noted an unidentified object visible on the bed and the absence of pillow-blood photographs.

A set of photographs depicting Heard's facial injuries from December 15, 2015, attached as exhibit 13 to Heard's deposition declaration. Josh Drew confirmed he was present during the photography and that the images were consistent with injuries he personally observed on Heard's face that day.

Two photographs of Amber Heard introduced during her direct examination as depicting injuries sustained in the December 15, 2015 incident. The photographs were displayed again during cross-examination in connection with James Corden footage.

Four photographs of Amber Heard depicting injuries on December 16, 2015, authenticated by makeup artist Melanie Inglessis, including one specifically depicting a lip injury. Inglessis noted that three of the photographs showed the injuries under varying lighting conditions but confirmed each accurately depicted Heard's condition on that date.

Photograph of Heard's swollen lip from around December 2015, authenticated by iO Tillett Wright as accurately depicting what he observed during his visit to penthouse 3 in December 2015.

A set of photographs authenticated by Raquel Pennington depicting Heard's bruising, scalp abrasions, hair loss, and property destruction in the penthouse following the December 2015 incident.

Photograph of the bar area at the Australia rental property where Ben King testified he discovered Depp's severed fingertip. The image shows a broken vodka bottle in the corner and blood drops on the floor.

Red-carpet photographs of Amber Heard from April 2015 showing visible scars, introduced as evidence tied to the alleged March 2015 Australia countertop incident.

A photograph of a penthouse floor that Heard, during her Day 16 testimony, attributed to the December 15, 2015 incident. The image was later placed side-by-side with Defendant's Exhibit 725 during impeachment.

A redacted photograph of a penthouse floor that Heard, during her Day 17 testimony, testified depicted spilled wine in Penthouse 5 on May 21, 2016. The image was displayed alongside Defendant's Exhibit 512 during cross-examination.

A photograph of a damaged bed in the penthouse bedroom, introduced through Melanie Inglessis's deposition in connection with her account of damage observed during her December 2015 penthouse visit.

Photographs of Johnny Depp showing alleged bruises, introduced by Depp's team and including at least one attributed to Sean Bett, referenced by Rottenborn in a procedural argument about prior admission practice.

Photograph of Depp appearing to nod off in a chair with a cigarette in his hand.

A photograph of the kitchen counter in Penthouse 3 showing handwriting attributed to Depp reading 'Why be a fraud. All is such bullshit.' Josh Drew identified the handwriting as Depp's and confirmed the photograph accurately reflected the scene.

Photographs depicting damage inside Penthouse 5 from the May 21, 2016 incident, including Heard's closet area and a stairwell landing.

X-rays of Depp's injured right middle finger showing a comminuted fracture of the distal phalanx, introduced as a demonstrative during Richard Moore's testimony.

Photograph of Johnny Depp's hand showing a plaster splint applied after the Australia finger injury, introduced during Richard Moore's testimony.

Clinical photograph of Depp's injured finger showing palmar tissue loss on the underside of the fingertip with an intact nail, introduced during Richard Moore's testimony.

A photograph of Heard's face accompanied by a handwritten note from Depp, which Heard's team sought to introduce during her direct examination. The item was excluded after a sidebar on the grounds that it was produced after the discovery cutoff from devices in Heard's possession.

A photograph of the nightstand area in the Penthouse 3 bedroom showing a fallen lamp, broken glass, and scattered items.

A photograph or document shown to Officer Saenz during cross-examination in connection with questions about whether she observed any disarray during her protective sweep of the penthouses.

A photograph of writing on the kitchen wall of Depp's penthouse, introduced through Melanie Inglessis in connection with her account of damage she observed during a December 2015 visit.

A set of ten photographs documenting property damage across Penthouses 3, 4, and 5 following the May 21, 2016 incident, including broken glass on staircases, overturned furniture, and scattered jewelry materials.

Photographs of Amber Heard's alleged injuries, designated as Exhibits 14 through 20, shown to Inglessis during direct examination. Vasquez established on cross that Inglessis did not take any of these photographs and did not recall personally taking photos with Heard's or Pennington's phone.

Photographs apparently of Heard, designated as Defendant's Exhibits 7, 8, and 9, shown to witness Gatlin during a video review. Bredehoft asked Gatlin to connect the person depicted in the photos to the person visible on the sofa, but Gatlin was unable to make that connection.

A photograph of Heard's injuries authenticated by Raquel Pennington as a photograph she recognized. No specific date for this exhibit is identified in the available record.

Photographs published in People magazine in June 2016 depicting Heard with injuries, designated as Plaintiff's Exhibit 409. Vasquez established these photos were given to People during the contentious divorce, while Heard testified she gave them only to lawyers and representatives.

Defendant's Exhibits 700 through 726, photographs with associated metadata, subject to a Nadelhaft proffer in which the metadata was excluded as hearsay without foundation. The proffer was made to preserve the appellate record on the metadata ruling.

A photograph of Amber Heard's scalp showing a missing chunk of hair, designated as Exhibit 11. The image constitutes physical evidence of a scalp injury.

iTunes backup extractions of Heard's injury photographs, characterized by Neumeister as third-generation backups lacking system-level data. Neumeister relied on this characterization to conclude that no forensic validation of any analyzed photograph was possible.

A set of photographs taken on the night of May 21, 2016, including images of marks on Heard's face, a broken bed frame, red wine staining in the hallway, and broken picture frames on a wall.

Elizabeth Marz's eyewitness account of wine spilled in the hallway of the Eastern Columbia Building, observed during her visit on the night of May 21, 2016. No specific photographic exhibit was introduced for this observation.

A list of items allegedly destroyed in Penthouse 3, including candelabra sticks, food, kitchen utensils, and a lamp, discussed during Elizabeth Marz's examination without a specific exhibit being admitted.

Photographs of Heard's injuries from May 2016, shown to Alejandra Romero, a building front desk employee. Used to prompt Romero's concession that the swelling depicted was significant enough that she probably would have remembered it.

May 21 photographs and a wine bottle photograph that were the subject of a ruling excluding them from cross-examination. Vasquez argued the photos showed a discrepancy between Heard's deposition testimony and her redirect testimony about which incident they depict.

Four photographs of Heard's face, designated as part of Exhibit 11 (Falati 114–119), sent to nurse Erin Falati at 12:36 a.m. around May 21, 2016. The photos show Heard's appearance in the hours immediately after the May 21 incident.

A series of photographs taken on the night of May 21, 2016, designated as Drew Exhibit 13, depicting Heard's facial injuries, apartment damage including broken glass and pictures off walls, spilled wine in the hallway, and a wine bottle in PH5. Drew confirmed the photos were taken by him or Pennington and were shown to the first responding police officers.

A set of twenty-one photographs (Defendant's Exhibits 706–726) documenting Heard's face and penthouse damage following the May 21, 2016 incident. These are the same exhibits previously shown to Officers Saenz and Hadden during their depositions.

Photographs of Heard's face taken on May 22, 2016, the day after the May 21 incident, designated as Drew Exhibit 14. Drew confirmed they were taken by him or Pennington and were consistent with his recollection of Heard's appearance that day.

Defendant's Exhibits 800 and 801, photographs of Heard inside the courthouse on the day she obtained her domestic violence restraining order. Vasquez framed the images as a staged photo shoot.

A photograph, designated Defendant's Exhibit 799, showing Heard with her publicist Jody Gottlieb at the courthouse on May 27, 2016, the day she obtained the domestic violence TRO against Depp.

Courthouse photographs of Heard taken on the day of her domestic violence restraining order application, designated as Exhibit 46 and identified by numbers CourtPennington 1292 and 1295. The images show bruising on Heard's right cheekbone days after May 21, and Pennington confirmed she took them and that Heard wore no makeup.

Two photographs of Amber Heard and Raquel Pennington, designated as Plaintiff's Exhibits 1316 and 1317, taken on a May 28, 2016 outing and published in a May 30, 2016 article; one photograph also includes Josh Drew. Admitted during cross-examination.

A demonstrative exhibit, designated PX1304, showing EXIF data excerpts from multiple injury photographs, each bearing the notation "Photos 3.0" in the software field. It served as the primary visual evidence of the editing-software marker across the photo set.

A video demonstrative exhibit, designated PX1305, showing a side-by-side comparison of a Photos 3.0 edited version and an iOS version of the same injury photograph. It illustrated the visible difference between edited and unedited versions for the jury.

A video demonstrative exhibit, designated PX1306, comparing Defendant's Exhibits 712 and 713, which Neumeister argued were the same photograph with colors modified in an editing program. It extended the editing-marker findings to a second photo pair on Heard's exhibit list.

Photographs previously flagged by Bryan Neumeister for EXIF metadata concerns, revisited during Ackert's redirect examination. Ackert reaffirmed that he found no forensic inauthenticity in any of the photographs he analyzed.

A compilation of photographs from alleged abuse incidents including events in Russia, at the Met Gala, in Tokyo, in December 2015, and in May 2016, assembled by Depp's team to show no visible injuries on Heard.

Photographs from Raquel Pennington's deposition, some of which had been previously admitted and others agreed upon during the designation process. The central question addressed in the ruling was whether iPhone timestamp display information would be shown to the jury alongside these photos.

A photograph taken by Raquel Pennington of a clump of blonde hair on the floor of Penthouse 4, left undisturbed before being photographed.

A photograph of a broken platform bed frame in the Penthouse 4 bedroom, authenticated by Raquel Pennington as depicting the broken bed she found on the evening of the incident.

A photograph, designated Defendant's Exhibit 170A, discussed during Neumeister's direct examination and then introduced during cross-examination for his opinion on it. Murphy used it to establish that Neumeister offered specific testimony about a photograph he had not identified by exhibit number in his expert disclosure.

A photograph, designated Defendant's Exhibit 517, shown to Neumeister during cross-examination. Neumeister conceded he was not offering any opinion about it.

Photograph of Johnny Depp's swollen upper left cheekbone, taken by security guard Sean Bett around March 2015. Bett authenticated the photograph and explained the protective purpose behind documenting Depp's injuries.

Two X-rays of Johnny Depp's right middle finger taken after the Australia injury, showing the comminuted fracture at the distal phalanx, published to the jury as a demonstrative during Richard Gilbert's testimony.

Series of photographs of Depp's healing right middle finger taken at a surgeon's office, showing the finger wrapped in kiddie bandages during recovery following the Australia injury.

Three-page set of photographs documenting Johnny Depp's facial scratch marks and bruising, taken by security guard Sean Bett in mid-December 2015. Bett authenticated each photograph and described each injury in detail for the jury.

A video filmed by Heard on February 10, 2016, showing Johnny Depp slamming kitchen cabinets, pouring wine, and smashing glasses while yelling. The version TMZ received via a Dropbox link on August 12, 2016 — posted as a TMZ exclusive — was shorter than the trial version, missing opening setup footage and a closing segment in which Heard appeared to snicker at the camera. The footage was released online the night before Heard's August 2016 divorce deposition.

Eastern Columbia Building security footage showing Whitney Henriquez appearing to throw a fake punch toward Amber Heard in the elevator mezzanine area during the week of May 21, 2016; both women are visibly laughing in the clip.

Elevator surveillance footage and still photographs from the Eastern Columbia Building bearing timestamps 21:04:43 and 21:19:49 on May 21, 2016, showing Officers Saenz and Hadden on the penthouse floor.

Approximately 87 Eastern Columbia Building security camera clips from May 2016, authenticated by building general manager Brandon Patterson as true and accurate copies preserved since 2016, covering the mezzanine vestibule, lobby, elevator, call box, front desk, service corridor, penthouse elevator, and parking garage. Footage depicts Depp, Heard, Raquel Pennington, Whitney Henriquez, police officers, and building staff across May 21–25, 2016. One specific clip (Exhibit 3) shows Depp in the mezzanine vestibule; Patterson described him as 'animated' without audio and 'upset about something' once audio was available.

Eastern Columbia Building elevator security video from the night of May 21, 2016, authenticated through front desk employee Alejandra Romero, showing Johnny Depp and his bodyguard in the elevator.

Eastern Columbia Building elevator surveillance video showing James Franco on May 22, 2016 at approximately 11:00 p.m.

Surveillance video from the Eastern Columbia Building lobby showing Sean Bett, Johnny Depp, and a person identified as Judge entering the building at 19:02 (7:02 p.m.) on May 21, 2016.

Still frame from Eastern Columbia Building security footage dated May 21, 2016 at 22:28:15, showing both William Gatlin and Officer Diener together in the frame.

Still frame extracted from Eastern Columbia Building security footage dated May 21, 2016 at 22:28:14, showing Officer Diener.

Eastern Columbia Building surveillance video clips from May 24, 2016, shown to Alejandra Romero during cross-examination by Presiado.

Surveillance video from the Eastern Columbia Building showing Sean Bett, Johnny Depp, and a person identified as Judge departing the building at 20:29 (8:29 p.m.) on May 21, 2016.

TMZ video footage of Amber Heard arriving at a parking lot adjacent to a law office for her deposition on August 6 and August 13, 2016. Tremaine confirmed that TMZ would not normally cover a law office parking lot and that the tips came through a news producer and were not independently verified by him.

TMZ video footage of Amber Heard leaving the Los Angeles courthouse on May 27, 2016, captured by paparazzi dispatched after a tip.

The broader topic of Morgan Tremaine's testimony regarding TMZ tip-offs and publicist presence at the courthouse, raised as a rebuttal-case subject on cross-examination.

Extended audio recording played in multiple proceedings across several segments, covering discussions of the Australia fight, bathroom retreat disputes, and Heard's acknowledgments that she started physical fights. Additional segments included Depp's 'crime scene waiting to happen' statement and his acknowledgment of recent physical fights, as well as the 'five bathrooms and two bedrooms' exchange used to argue Heard was pursuing, not fleeing.

Audio recording (portion 18:43–21:46) in which Heard tells Depp to 'tell the world' he is also a domestic violence victim and Depp responds 'Yes'; also includes Depp referencing losing a finger and mineral spirits thrown at his nose. Played in multiple proceedings and referenced at closing.

Audio recording from the Boston-LA flight in which Depp is heard moaning and making indiscernible sounds, and Jerry Judge audibly calls Depp a 'fucking idiot.'

Audio recording from September 27, 2015 in which Heard admits to hitting Depp, using language distinguishing a 'punch' from a 'hit' and saying 'I can't promise' about future physical behavior; also includes statements attributed to Heard such as 'I meant to hit you' and 'you're not punched, you got hit.'

Audio recording in which Depp calls Heard 'a fucking cunt' during an argument.

Audio recording of a Depp-Heard argument in which Heard made derogatory remarks about Depp's son Jack and his parenting, and Depp used profane and demeaning language toward Heard including 'suck my dick' and 'washed-up piece of shit.'

Audio recording from a July 2016 San Francisco hotel meeting between Depp and Heard in which Depp refuses Heard's request for a hug and tells her she will not see his eyes again; also includes Depp's recorded allegation that Heard physically attacked him ('you fuckin' haymakered me, man').

Excerpted audio recording (seconds 1–20 and 1:30:02–1:31:45) in which Depp describes the couple's arguments as a 'bloodbath' and references violent escalation on 'the island.'

Audio recording from March 26, 2015 in which Heard describes Depp's substance-linked personality shifts.

Excerpted audio in which Heard says 'Get off me' and Depp responds 'I'll talk to you later,' followed by Depp later denying he had heard her say it.

Audio recording of a Depp-Heard argument in which Heard references Depp beating her and Depp says 'I made a huge mistake.'

Audio recording from October 5, 2015 in which Heard characterizes what Depp's staff witnessed as a fraction of the fights between them.

Audio recordings reviewed by defense expert David Spiegel as part of his case materials, not attributed to a specific exhibit.

Second audio recording from the Australia cleanup period, featuring Jerry Judge, offered during Ben King's testimony.

Pre-trial or opening reference to audio recordings from the Australia incident, specifically the five-hour tape and associated recordings; Australia tape described as including handlers discussing cleanup after the incident.

Defendant's Exhibit 598C, a recording made in a car outside a studio in which Heard says 'let me go' and requests space.

Approximately 45-second audio recording of an exchange involving Heard's cigarette allegation in the context of a trivial furniture dispute.

Audio recording, without a specified exhibit number, in which Depp uses the phrase 'borderline personality disorder' in reference to Heard; played during Shannon Curry's testimony.

Audio recording in which Depp makes a statement admitting 'the day that I chopped my finger off,' played at closing.

Audio recording in which Heard tells Depp to put his cigarette out on someone else and Depp responds 'Shut up, fat ass.'

Audio recording in which Depp states 'I become irrational when you're doing movies. I become jealous and fucking crazy and weird,' played at closing.

Audio recording with two played portions (31:14–33:04 and 56:xx–59:54) in which Depp explains his strategy of leaving arguments to de-escalate, and Heard calls him a 'bully' and says his leaving causes her immense stress.

Audio/video recording capturing Depp speaking aggressively and Heard questioning whether he had been drinking; confirmed by iO Tillett Wright as the recording Heard sent him on February 10, 2016.

Excerpt (7:35–8:20) of an audio recording in which Heard accuses Depp of hitting her 'when she was on the floor.'

Set of audio recordings from June 2016 (Plaintiff's Exhibits 357B through 357F), in which Heard articulates arguments about a smear campaign and cross-corroboration of her account.

Audio recording from July 2015 in which Depp makes remarks including 'You don't exist' and 'schoolteacher' during a conversation with Heard.

Set of redacted audio clip exhibits (approximately Exhibits 700–717) with associated photo metadata, offered through Heard's testimony.

Audio recording (portion 19:40–25:25) of a heated Depp-Heard argument in which Depp throws his ring, Heard pleads for him to stay, and Depp says 'borderline personality disorder' in reference to Heard.

Audio recording from September 15, 2015 in which Depp and Heard discuss a vomiting episode and a substance bender.

A February 3, 2014 text exchange between Christi Dembrowski and Amber Heard in which Heard wrote 'JD is on a bender' and Dembrowski responded with messages including 'I worry about everything,' 'where are the kids,' and 'I don't love any of it.' The exhibit was produced in both unredacted and redacted forms across proceedings.

Text message(s) from Depp to his physician Dr. David Kipper, sent around March 7–8, 2015, in which Depp states 'I cut the top of my middle finger off' and comments on Heard's ambition, contemporaneous with the Australia finger injury.

Text messages from Johnny Depp to actor Paul Bettany concerning drug and alcohol use in connection with the Boston plane flight incident, including language characterized as admitting to a blackout and aggression. The exhibit was offered by Heard's team through audio technician Keenan Wyatt on Day 5 and later addressed when Depp testified directly.

Text message from August 15, 2016 in which Johnny Depp wrote to talent agent Christian Carino, 'She will hit the wall hard!!!!' and expressed a wish that 'Karma kicks in and takes the gift of breath from her,' along with other degrading and threatening language about Heard. The exhibit was admitted in redacted form.

Text messages sent by Depp to Heard on May 22, 2016, expressing 'profound apologies' and stating 'I am clear, I am me,' introduced as Defendant's Exhibits 771, 772, and 773.

A text message from June 4, 2016 in which Johnny Depp wrote to his sister Christi Dembrowski, 'I want her replaced on that WB film,' referring to Amber Heard and her Warner Brothers role, with additional references to Warner Brothers franchise concerns.

Text message(s) from Depp to Heard's mother Paige, sent August 19, 2014, in which Depp calls himself 'this poor old junkie,' praises Heard's 'heroism,' and credits her caregiving during his Roxicodone detox.

A text exchange between Johnny Depp and Bruce Witkin dated February 4, 2014, in which Depp referenced his relationship with Heard.

A social media post authored by Gina Deuters, described as a 'long letter' commenting on court proceedings and Depp's wins; a screenshot was passed to Heard's counsel by Eve Barlow from the front row during trial. The post was later identified as approximately two years old rather than from the current trial week.

An email chain dated December 20, 2018, with the subject 'Johnny Depp's Jack Sparrow Won't Return,' in which Depp's publicist Robin Braun forwarded a movieweb.com article about Depp's removal from the Pirates franchise; agent Jack Whigham replied that Disney had not officially notified them, and the chain also included a message from Christian Carino.

A redacted page from a text exchange between agent Tracey Jacobs and business manager Edward White, in which Jacobs reported Disney's complaint that Depp had arrived five hours late for Pirates 5 ADR in London.

An email from Jennifer Howell to Whitney Henriquez dated July 28, 2020, forwarded to Marcel Pariseau, in which Howell expressed belief that Whitney was being dishonest about the abuse allegations and urged her to tell the truth.

A text chain involving Stephen Deuters introduced as Defendant's Exhibit 229A-M, including a message reading 'When I told him he kicked you, he cried.' The court excluded the texts on the grounds that Deuters was not acting as Depp's speaking agent when he sent them.

Two text messages referencing 'Molly' sent from Depp's phone, introduced as Defendant's Exhibit DX883. Depp disavowed authorship during cross-examination.

Text messages between Isaac Baruch and Johnny Depp, admitted with agreed redactions of personally identifying information.

A text exchange between Sean Bett and Depp dated June 12, 2019, referencing 'not-drugs' in connection with visitors at Depp's house.

A September 1, 2017 text exchange between Depp and his security guard Sean Bett in which Depp describes drinking wine and pounding an entire bottle of tequila, and Bett mentions preventing others from calling police.

Text messages between Christian Carino and Johnny Depp regarding logistics of a San Francisco reconciliation meeting that Heard had requested.

Text messages between Christian Carino and Amber Heard from 2017.

Text messages between Christian Carino and Amber Heard from 2017.

Text messages between Christian Carino and Amber Heard from 2018.

A text exchange or package of exchanges between Christian Carino and Amber Heard, covering post-divorce communications including Heard's reconciliation requests and TRO-related discussions.

Text messages between Christian Carino and Amber Heard scheduling post-TRO meetings with Depp.

A text exchange between Christian Carino and Amber Heard dated August 7–16, 2017, in which Carino wrote that Heard 'wasn't in love with' Elon Musk and had told him 'a thousand times you were just filling space.'

Text messages sent by Depp's sister Christi Dembrowski to Depp on February 5, 2014, instructing him to 'Stop drinking,' 'Stop coke,' and 'Stop pills.'

An email from Christi Dembrowski to agent Tracey Jacobs dated February 27, 2015, referencing Depp arriving two and a half hours and seven hours late to set during Pirates 5 filming.

A March 22, 2013 text exchange between Christi Dembrowski and Amber Heard in which Dembrowski wrote 'I don't love what it is' and advised Heard against having confrontational conversations with Depp.

A multi-page text chain between Christi Dembrowski and Amber Heard dated May 25, 2014, containing messages from Dembrowski including 'he needs help' and 'I don't have all the information to help alone.'

An excerpted audio recording (Defendant's Exhibit 587B, segments at 19:40–19:53 and 23:04–23:29) in which Depp states 'I'm never getting clean and sober' while Heard contemporaneously documents his cocaine and alcohol use that day.

A text exchange including a message from Depp reading 'I'm good. Just got a fucked finger,' with a follow-up from Stephen Deuters, contemporaneously documenting the Australia finger injury.

Text messages from January 2013 in which Johnny Depp referred to Amber Heard as 'idiot cow,' 'ugly cunt,' and 'worthless hooker.'

A set of Depp text messages and emails introduced as Defendant's Exhibits 272, 310, 321, and 325, including phrases such as 'I'm a fucking savage' and 'I love you more than life.'

A text message from around February 10, 2016 from Johnny Depp to security guard Malcolm Connolly containing graphic language about physically 'mangling' an abuser.

Text from Depp to Heard's father David Heard, sent approximately two weeks after a December 2015 incident, stating 'I fucked up and went too far in our fight,' introduced as Defendant's Exhibit DX580.

A text from Johnny Depp to Stephen Deuters containing vulgar descriptions of women.

A redacted text message from September 9, 2013 from Johnny Depp to Amber Heard containing the phrase 'don't test me, please' and characterized as containing 'aggravated ultimatum' language.

A text message from April 2015 in which Johnny Depp called Amber Heard a 'filthy whore' in a message addressed to Heard's sister Whitney Henriquez.

A text message from August 13, 2016 in which Johnny Depp wrote to Kate James, 'Come over for a spot of purple and we'll fix her flabby ass nice and good,' referring disparagingly to Amber Heard.

Text from Depp to his estate manager Kevin Murphy, dated January 21, 2014, in which Depp acknowledges his daughter Lily-Rose suspected he was drinking, writing 'she's right. But I can't admit it or I fucking die in her eyes.'

Email from Depp to Dr. David Kipper, dated March 19, 2015, in which Depp states 'I've chopped off my left middle finger,' introduced in redacted form as Defendant's Exhibit 398.

Text from Depp to Nathan Holmes, sent after the Australia finger injury, requesting 'whitey stuff' and 'the E business,' introduced as Plaintiff's Exhibit PX393.

On Day 5, Johnny Depp proactively addressed text messages he had sent containing dark or violent language, before being cross-examined about them.

Text messages between Johnny Depp and Isaac Baruch from October 2016, containing Depp's derogatory messages about Heard including the 'rotting corpse' text.

Text messages from June 11, 2013 in which Johnny Depp wrote to actor Paul Bettany, 'Let's burn Amber,' 'Let's drown her before we burn her,' and made an additional corpse threat directed at Heard.

Text exchange from May 30, 2014 between Depp and Bettany describing drinking and drug use on a Boston-to-Los Angeles flight that ended in a blackout, introduced as Defendant's Exhibit D-245.

Text messages from February 22, 2017 from Johnny Depp to Stephen Deuters, including the phrase 'I NEED, I WANT, I TAKE.'

An email from Johnny Depp to agent Tracey Jacobs dated August 29, 2015, concerning the London Fields film and a nudity-related dispute involving producers Jacobs identified as Hanley (misspelled by Depp as 'Harley').

Text messages between Johnny Depp and Vanessa Paradis, labeled 'Merino' in the exhibit.

A text dated September 23, 2017, in which Heard wrote to Carino 'God, I miss him,' confirmed by Carino to refer to Depp.

A text dated June 9, 2018, in which Heard told Carino she had sent Depp a happy birthday message.

A text dated August 16, 2017, in which Heard asked Carino to deliver a handwritten letter to Depp, stating she was 'finally single' and wanted Depp to know she loved him and was sorry.

An email exchange with Bates reference CC00070, dated January 11, 2018, subject 'WME,' in which Heard discussed with Carino her decision to leave CAA for William Morris Endeavor.

A text exchange between Amber Heard and her deceased mother.

Text messages between Amber Heard and Dr. Cowan dated March 8, 2015.

A text exchange between Amber Heard and Kate James (Heard's former personal assistant) containing affectionate messages including 'I love you' and 'Love you too, hon.'

An email purportedly from Amber Heard to Kate James dated on or about February 12, 2015.

An email chain between Amber Heard and Kate James from early February 2015, including a message in which Heard wrote in all caps.

An email exchange between Amber Heard and Kate James regarding James's termination of employment, referencing six weeks' severance, financial difficulties, and James's request for alternative accommodation.

A text message from Amber Heard to Raquel Pennington containing the message 'I'm not good,' partially admitted; the broader message that also referenced Depp's drinking was excluded.

A redacted text message exchange between Amber Heard and Raquel Pennington dated August 7, 2014, including Heard's message 'This is what I've been dealing with' attached to the ice cream photograph.

An email from Amber Heard to Raquel Pennington dated March 22, 2013, enclosing the cocaine breakfast table photograph, admitted with redactions of the message text.

A text message from Amber Heard to Raquel Pennington timestamped 8:06 p.m. on May 21, 2016.

A text message from Aquaman director James Wan to Amber Heard dated August 25, 2018, stating she 'rated really high with the audience' at a test screening.

A text exchange (Bates LLOYD 140–145) including Depp's farewell message referencing being 'fired by their physician.'

Text messages between nurse Debbie Lloyd and Amber Heard from the Bahamas island stay in August 2014.

Text messages sent by Whitney Henriquez to Johnny Depp dated October 2, 2015, in which she wrote that she would stay out of their relationship if she thought it was past the point of no return.

A text message exchange between Whitney Henriquez and Kevin Murphy (Depp's estate manager) dated March 23, 2015, containing Whitney's photographs of the destroyed closet and kitchen.

A continuation of the February 2014 exchange showing Witkin reaching out to assistants to help locate Depp.

A text exchange between Bruce Witkin and Amber Heard dated February 3, 2014, in which Heard reached out to Witkin with concern about Depp during a bender with Marilyn Manson; a continuation shows Witkin attempting to locate Depp at Manson's at Heard's urging.

A text message exchange between iO Tillett Wright and Amber Heard dated December 16, 2015, beginning with Heard writing 'I need you.'

A text message exchange between iO Tillett Wright and Amber Heard dated February 10, 2016, referencing a video Heard sent to Wright.

Amber Heard's opinion piece titled 'I spoke up against sexual violence and faced our culture's wrath. This has to change.' published in the Washington Post on December 18, 2018, describing herself as a public figure representing domestic abuse. The article did not name Depp by name; three specific statements within it were identified by Depp as defamatory. It was displayed in full on courtroom screens and introduced in both print and online forms.

Treatment notes of psychologist Dr. Bonnie Jacobs documenting Heard's sessions over approximately five years beginning October 2011, including Heard's reports of physical and sexual violence by Depp across multiple sessions and notes predating the Depp relationship. Characterized by Hughes and Spiegel as documenting physical and sexual abuse from 2012.

The Computer-Aided Dispatch (CAD) summary and incident recall for the May 21, 2016 call to 849 S. Broadway, coded 242D (battery/DV), recording the call timeline (initiation 8:35 p.m., arrival 8:57 p.m., close 9:22 p.m.) and the notation that the victim advised a verbal dispute and refused to provide further information. Introduced through the Saenz, Hadden, and Sadanaga depositions as the only documentation Saenz and Hadden created from their visit.

The CAPS-5 structured clinical interview was administered by Hughes to Heard on December 27, 2021, producing an approximately 59-page handwritten scoring form. The plaintiff introduced the form as Plaintiff's 1247; the defense sought to admit the same materials as Defendant's 1435, which was excluded on hearsay grounds.

Amber Heard's test option agreement with Warner Brothers for the role of Mera in the Aquaman franchise, establishing a tiered salary structure across multiple pictures, identified by Hamada as a standard actor-studio agreement.

The TSI-2, a clinical instrument assessing trauma-related symptoms including an Atypical Response Scale measuring exaggeration, was administered by Hughes to Heard. The plaintiff introduced a critical items list as Plaintiff's 1248; the defense's motion to admit the full test as Defendant's 1859 was denied on hearsay grounds.

Text messages from March and October 2015 in which Depp wrote to Dr. Kipper and others that he had cut or chopped off his own finger. Depp later characterized the 'I cut my finger off' language as dark humor, referring to the injured finger as 'Little Richard.'

Erin Falati (née Boerum), Heard's personal nurse, maintained clinical notes documenting Heard's physical condition, emotional state, and medication regimen from August 2014 through May 2016. The notes recorded observations across key incident dates—including a restaurant incident reflecting emotional reactivity and Heard's report that only Provigil was effective—and were admitted under multiple exhibit labels during different witness examinations. Heard testified and denied multiple entries during her own examination.

Amber Heard's December 19, 2018 tweet sharing a link to the Washington Post op-ed with the statement 'Today I published this op-ed in The Washington Post,' simultaneously announcing her ACLU ambassadorship. The tweet repeated the op-ed title, including the phrase 'sexual violence.'

The LAPD Domestic Violence Supplemental Report form containing victim observation checklists, victim emotional state assessments, crime scene indicators, and approximately 70 yes-or-no risk assessment questions. Introduced as Exhibit 9 across the Saenz, Hadden, and Sadanaga depositions.

The PAI, a broadband personality inventory with built-in validity scales, was administered by Hughes to Heard. The plaintiff introduced critical item endorsements as Plaintiff's 1244; the defense sought to admit the full scoring profile as Defendant's 1858, which was excluded on hearsay grounds.

A June 21, 2018 Rolling Stone article by Stephen Rodrick offering an in-depth account of Depp's behavior, spending, and personal issues. Disney executives including Alan Horn forwarded it internally. Waldman described contacting the magazine regarding Depp's situation, while the article states Waldman initiated that contact.

Ron Schnell's social media analysis and underlying Twitter API dataset tracking negative hashtag tweets against Heard from April 2020 through January 2021 and into 2022, tracking approximately 1.2 million negative tracers, challenged under voir dire as the underlying work product.

A joint statement signed by both parties in connection with their 2016 divorce settlement, affirming that their relationship was at times volatile but always bound by love, and that neither party made false accusations for financial gain. Depp signed on August 15, 2016, and the statement was released publicly.

Dr. Alan Blaustein's handwritten session notes for Johnny Depp, beginning with an initial telephone consultation on October 2, 2014, and spanning through January 8, 2015. Notes include entries on Depp's anger toward Heard, self-destructive behavior, sobriety goals, substance history including MDMA and cocaine, mental status observations linking THC to cognitive impairment, absence of observed mania or hypomania, self-described paranoia, jealousy triggers, and the Mini-Mental Status Examination result showing Depp unable to recall any of three test words.

Clinical treatment notes and deposition of Dr. Connell Cowan, who treated Heard for approximately two years; reviewed by both Shannon Curry and Dawn Hughes as part of their expert record reviews.

The stipulated final judgment for the dissolution of marriage between Amber Heard and Johnny Depp, approximately fifty pages in length, including a provision dismissing the restraining order allegations.

An August 18, 2014 email from Dr. Kipper to Christi Dembrowski (Depp's sister and manager) summarizing Depp's post-Bahamas condition, including pessimism about stopping drugs, lack of accountability, and anger issues. Kipper had known Depp approximately four months and spent roughly 20 hours with him before writing the email.

Dr. David Kipper's deposition transcript and associated email describing Depp's 'fundamental issues with anger' and romanticization of drug culture, as well as Kipper's clinical notes and urine drug screen records reviewed by defense experts. The deposition also contained Kipper's account that Depp told him at the scene that Heard threw a vodka bottle during the Australia incident.

A November 24, 2014 memo from the Office of the Chief of Police announcing the revision of the LAPD Domestic Violence Supplemental Report Form to provide a more concise picture of victim history and needs for DV investigations. Introduced as Exhibit 8 across the Saenz, Hadden, and Sadanaga depositions.

Debbie Lloyd's contemporaneous nursing notes for Johnny Depp's care spanning June 2014 through July 2015, covering the detox period, Australia, post-Australia recovery, and behavioral incidents including polysubstance abuse references and March 2015 entries on finger assessment, anger, and alcohol cravings.

An April 27, 2018 article by Dan Wootton in The Sun, headlined 'How can JK Rowling be genuinely happy casting wife beater Johnny Depp in the new Fantastic Beasts film?' Introduced at trial as Defendant's Exhibit 99 and also as Carino Deposition Exhibit 10.

A cover letter from Edward White to the ACLU, dated August 24, 2016, enclosing Depp's $100,000 check and characterizing the payment as the first of multiple scheduled installments on Heard's $3.5 million pledged gift.

Romero's September 9, 2016 ACLU acknowledgment letter to Amber Heard, enclosing an unsigned pledge form and payment schedule. The document was admitted subject to redaction of a phone number.

Seventeen-page redacted session notes (Bates 1–17) prepared contemporaneously by couples therapist Laurel Anderson during sessions with Depp and Heard, color-coded and authenticated as business records. Page 13 includes a notation attributed to Depp describing the relationship as 'chaotic, violent.'

Kathryn Arnold's expert damages testimony and report, including her $45 million projection, comparable actors analysis, and renegotiation opinions, as well as actor salary and budget figures cited during examination.

Records from the hospital that treated Depp's finger injury in Australia, including documentation that Depp told the treating ER doctor he had sliced his finger with a knife, with no documentation of glass retrieved from the wound or elsewhere on the patient.

Bania deposition transcript, including March 21, 2022 pages 74, 83, and 113, and page 177 lines 6–10 on Momoa Q score timing.

The CAPS-5, a structured clinical interview for PTSD developed by the National Center for PTSD and the VA, was administered by Curry to Heard.

A Daily Mail Online article dated July 3, 2020, quoting Waldman's statement characterizing the May 2016 penthouse incident as an 'ambush' and a 'hoax,' and alleging Heard staged the incident and placed a second 911 call. Read during Kovacevic's testimony to confirm WME's awareness of the statements.

A Daily Mail article dated October 25, 2018, headlined 'Hide the Rum: Johnny Depp is Out as Jack Sparrow in Disney's Pirates of the Caribbean,' reporting that Disney executive Sean Bailey announced Depp's departure from the franchise. Introduced as Defendant's Exhibit 115.

The Danger Assessment Scale, a validated instrument identifying risk factors for serious or lethal domestic violence, was administered by Hughes to Heard.

Text messages from April through June 2015 in which Depp used the word 'monster' to describe himself in communications to Jerry Judge, Elton John, Dr. Kipper, and Stephen Deuters, with Heard absent from the threads.

Text messages between Johnny Depp and Erin Falati dated October 31, 2015, produced from Depp's own records, in which Depp references the Australia finger injury with the phrase 'The first time I had just chopped my finger off.'

Text messages from Depp to Dr. Kipper in July–August 2015 showing Depp's hostility toward Heard's psychiatrist Dr. Cowan and requests for Xanax and Adderall as PRNs.

Text messages exchanged between Erin Falati (then Boerum) and Whitney Heard on March 23, 2015, following the loft incident during the Australia aftermath. The exchange was introduced under multiple exhibit labels across different witness examinations, with Falati identifying the messages on screen during her testimony.

A February 2021 expert witness designation signed by Depp's counsel listing three opinions attributed to Curry before she had evaluated Heard or formed any views, introduced as Plaintiff's Exhibit 884.

ACLU and Fidelity Charitable records documenting a $350,000 donation received on December 11, 2018, designated as anonymous but recorded as a donation from Amber Heard, sourced from a donor-advised fund with no independent ACLU verification of the underlying source.

A PowerPoint presentation titled 'Expert Witness Testimony in Cases Involving Domestic Violence,' given by Hughes and Mary Ann Dutton to the National Clearinghouse for the Defense of Battered Women, introduced as Plaintiff's 1241.

A PowerPoint presentation titled 'The Use of Psychological Experts in Cases of Domestic Violence,' given by Hughes to the Kings County Bar Association, covering myths and misconceptions about IPV, introduced as Plaintiff's 1242.

Kipper consultation notes from June 2014 documenting treatment encounters around the Bahamas detox arrangement, including Amber Heard's presence and her family history of drug and alcohol abuse, and no documented concern about Depp being violent.

A March 2015 email from Dr. Kipper, referenced in connection with Depp's sleep issues in Australia and directing Erin Falati to give Heard an excuse to keep her separated from Depp after the Australia incident; Bates No. Falati 0134.

A combined set of Kipper and nurse Lloyd patient progress notes for Depp spanning June 2014 through April 2015, including Bahamas detox notes, the bloody knuckles episode, Australia observations, and treatment noncompliance entries.

The front and back of the LAPD business card left for Amber Heard on the night of May 21, 2016, bearing handwritten notes including 'refused report' and 'advised can call at later time if changes mind,' dated 9:16 p.m. Introduced through both Saenz (Exhibits 19–20) and Hadden (Hadden Exhibit 19).

An LAPD field notebook divider (LAPD 18.30.02, dated January 31, 2010) setting out domestic violence laws and case preparation guidelines, including obligations to note complainant condition, preserve evidence, and photograph injuries. Introduced as Exhibit 10 in both the Saenz and Hadden depositions.

The MMPI-2, a 567-item objective personality and psychopathology inventory, was administered by Curry to Heard on an iPad. Curry produced a 25-page scoring outline summarizing the results in discovery.

A news item dated November 5, 2020, headlined 'Disney reportedly scratch plans for Depp's POTC6 return,' introduced as Deposition Exhibit 60 during Tina Newman's testimony and separately referenced during Michael Spindler's cross-examination.

The PCL-5, a face-value self-report checklist of DSM-5 PTSD symptoms, was administered by Hughes to Heard as part of her evaluation protocol.

Plaintiff's Trial Exhibit 1296 — a demonstrative Q score comparison chart using winter 2019 data, showing Amber Heard alongside Jason Momoa, Gal Gadot, Zendaya, Ana de Armas, and Chris Pine, comparing Q score timing across the group.

Plaintiff's Exhibit 936 — Depp's tax returns for Depp and his companies for 2009–2019, prepared by Ed White's firm, including page 69 showing 2015 earnings of $43 million.

A March 8, 2015 email from Raja Sawhney to Dr. Kipper containing notes on Depp's condition (under alias Robert Wells), including hand contamination observations and information about Depp's coherence at the Australia hospital.

The pre-trial deposition of Shannon Curry taken March 21, 2022, including pages 199, 200, 207–208, 240, 254–255, 270, 305–306, and 337.

One of the three Waldman defamatory statements admitted and shown to the jury, entered as Defendant's Exhibit 1245. Introduced during both Kathryn Arnold's testimony and Johnny Depp's testimony; Depp testified he first encountered this statement in August 2020 when it appeared in Heard's counterclaim filing.

One of the three Waldman defamatory statements admitted and shown to the jury, entered as Defendant's Exhibit 1246 / 1246A. Introduced during both Kathryn Arnold's testimony and Johnny Depp's testimony; Depp testified he first saw it with the counterclaim filing in August 2020.

The third of three Waldman defamatory statements admitted and shown to the jury, entered as Defendant's Exhibit 1247. Introduced during both Kathryn Arnold's testimony and Johnny Depp's testimony; Depp testified he first saw it with the counterclaim filing in August 2020.

Photographs described as 'PLANE pictures,' shown to Dr. Kulber during cross-examination.

Exhibits 1–2: Barnes v. Commonwealth and McMahon v. Rounds

Floor plan / schematic of Eastern Columbia Building penthouses

Plaintiff's Exhibit 120D — confirmed not admitted into evidence despite appearing on a party's exhibit list

Exhibit admitted from a prior day's proceedings

Exhibit admitted the prior day

Exhibits 3–4: Rocky Brooks civil assault claim documents

Plaintiff's Exhibit 348 — video of Depp's island house and closet area

Exhibit played during Tracey Jacobs deposition, admitted by agreement

Plaintiff's Exhibit 49 — video of Depp's island house

Exhibit played during iO Tillett Wright deposition, admitted by agreement

A 911 call summary report documenting two separate calls placed approximately eight minutes apart on the night of May 21, 2016.

The Abusive Behaviors Observation Checklist, a brief therapeutic checklist with no published validation research, was administered by Hughes to Heard.

An ACLU business record pulled from their internal system reflecting Heard's donation status, admitted as a business record with the relevant portion already redacted.

ACLU communications regarding the accuracy of statements about whether Heard's donation was completed. Excluded as cumulative.

An ACLU document admitted without objection, with identifier redactions, for use in connection with the Terence Dougherty deposition.

A bundle of ACLU donation records including a JPMorgan wire record, a Vanguard grant letter, Fidelity records, and Salesforce screenshots, providing a comprehensive accounting of payments received against the pledge.

An email describing Heard's plan to donate $3.5 million to the ACLU over the next ten years.

An email chain among ACLU personnel Romero, Villagra, and Wier regarding Depp's $100,000 check and Elon Musk's role in first introducing Heard as a prospective donor to Romero.

An email chain between ACLU personnel Romero and Maresco requesting Heard's next pledge payment, referencing a remaining balance of $2.55 million on a ten-year pledge.

ACLU internal email chain concerning placement of Heard's op-ed, including a pitch from ACLU staffer Stacy Sullivan to Washington Post editors describing Heard as having been 'beaten up' by Depp.

Internal ACLU emails from July 2020 responding to a Reuters fact-check inquiry, including a statement by Weitz that Heard had donated her full settlement to charity.

An email from ACLU's Romero to Amber Heard dated November 27, 2018, asking her to facilitate a $350,000 pledge payment.

Exhibit introduced by AV technician as Exhibit 24; associated with the RTL statement exchange

American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law (AAPL) forensic psychiatry practice guidelines (2015)

American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs 2017 Honolulu resolution

Deposition transcript of Dr. Amy Banks, including her opinion that Heard was a victim of domestic abuse.

Laurel Anderson's billing ledger tracking therapy sessions under the pseudonyms Ann Henry (Heard) and Joey Davis (Depp).

Proffer of Dr. Laurel Anderson's deposition transcript, therapy session records, and treatment summary, collectively submitted as Exhibits A, B, and C.

Treatment summary that Laurel Anderson prepared when first subpoenaed, synthesizing her clinical notes and conceptual impressions of the Depp–Heard relationship.

Email chain among therapist Laurel Anderson, Christian Carino, and Amber Heard arranging the initial and subsequent couples therapy consultations in March and September 2015.

APA Goldwater Rule (Section 7.3) and its 2017 revision reasserting prohibition on psychiatric opinions without personal evaluation

APA Goldwater Rule text — the 2017 amendment stating it is unethical to offer a professional opinion about an individual without conducting an examination — read aloud by Dennison.

April 2018 article by Dan Wootton in The Sun calling Depp a 'wife beater,' published approximately eight months before the Washington Post op-ed.

The Aquaman 2 script received by Amber Heard prior to April 8, 2020, the date of the first Waldman statement.

Two articles about Heard's alleged 2009 assault of Tasya van Ree, marked as Exhibits 5 and 6 during Day 16 proceedings.

Audio recordings, text messages, emails, and kitchen video reviewed as part of evaluation

A deal point memorandum signed on August 16, 2016, bearing signatures of both parties and both lead counsel, identified by Wasser as the controlling memorandum for the final divorce settlement.

An August 5, 2016 letter from Samantha Spector to Laura Wasser, protected under Evidence Code section 1152 as a settlement communication.

Google Trends chart spanning 2004 to 2020, with seventeen labeled spikes of public interest in Johnny Depp and redlines marking May 2016 and December 18, 2018.

A demonstrative chart derived from Schnell's own demonstrative, showing the six largest negative hashtag volume spikes with Waldman statement dates marked alongside them.

A demonstrative summary chart prepared by Doug Bania showing Schnell's Twitter hashtag data by month from January 2018 to June 2021, displaying percentage distribution across pre-Waldman, Waldman-period, and post-Waldman timeframes.

Q score data overlaid on the Google Trends chart, showing positive and negative Q scores at three time points: pre-2016, post-2016, and post-op-ed.

A demonstrative social media follower comparison chart using pre-Waldman data retrieved via the Wayback Machine, covering Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook counts for Heard and Arnold's five alleged comparable actresses.

A demonstrative showing Bania's content analysis of 1.2 million post-April-2020 tweets searched for key Waldman statement phrases, yielding 95 unique tweets and ultimately five tweets directly referencing the statements.

Dr. Amy Banks's notes and transcript together with Dr. Laurel Anderson's clinical notes as couples therapist, reviewed by Shannon Curry.

A medical record within Bates range Depp 1628–1927 that identifies Dr. David Kulber, produced early in litigation.

Bercovici's initial expert disclosure and a subsequent supplemental disclosure referencing LAPD officer conduct in connection with the May 2016 incident.

Beverly Leonard/Seattle-Tacoma Airport testimony (2009 incident)

A billing invoice from Dr. Alan Blaustein's files documenting 18 sessions with Johnny Depp from October 2014 through January 2015.

The deposition transcript of Dr. Alan Blaustein, Depp's psychiatrist, reviewed by plaintiff's expert Dr. Richard Shaw in forming his opinion.

Boles v. United States (M.D.N.C.) — federal case restricting rebuttal experts to attacking adversary expert theories

A text exchange in which Bruce Witkin wrote that he was 'really worried about him and this Dr. Kipper,' expressing skepticism toward Kipper's treatment of Depp.

Bryan Neumeister's expert disclosure report on photograph authenticity and EXIF data

Carino Deposition Exhibit 14 — Depp's lawsuit against Heard

Carino Deposition Exhibit 4 — referenced in connection with Mandel lawsuit distraction question

Carino Deposition Exhibit 7 — Bloom Hergott lawsuit filed October 17, 2017

Carino's March 2016 request for a house call from Dr. Anderson, along with Anderson's reply noting she wanted Depp to understand something she believed he did not.

Document showing Christian Carino's initial contact with therapist Laurel Anderson and Heard's message requesting how to reach her.

Text exchange dated July 14, 2016, between Christian Carino and Amber Heard discussing couples therapist Laurel Anderson and paparazzi avoidance, produced by Heard (Bates ALH).

Change.org petition to remove Amber Heard from Aquaman 2

Check for $250,000 anonymous donation to Art of Elysium on behalf of Amber Heard

A letter from Candie Davidson-Goldbronn of Children's Hospital Los Angeles sent directly to Amber Heard, care of Jody Gottlieb, inquiring about additional gift installments.

A June 14, 2019 letter from Candie Davidson-Goldbronn of Children's Hospital Los Angeles to Edward White inquiring about further installments on Heard's pledge.

A corporate designee subpoena directed to Wasser, Cooperman & Handles compelling the firm's testimony through its designated representative.

Court opinion letter dated March 27, 2020, overruling Heard's demurrer on three defamatory statements

The Conflict Tactic Scale 2 (Revised, 2nd edition), a research instrument developed for studying family violence prevalence in anonymous survey populations, was administered by Hughes to Heard.

The published CTS-2 instructions bearing Dennison's redline annotations, introduced as Plaintiff's 1309 as a demonstrative exhibit.

Email exchange not involving Laura Wasser

Defendant's Exhibit 500 — a February 11, 2015 cast insurance form signed by Depp, in which he denied illegal substance use in the prior 12 months.

Exhibit agreed upon by both parties for the Wasser deposition

A Daily Mail Online article dated July 3, 2020, quoting Waldman's statement that labeled Heard's allegations 'the end of Ms. Beard's abuse hoax against Johnny Depp.' Waldman confirmed making the statement during his trial testimony.

A Daily Mail Online article dated July 3, 2020, quoting Waldman's statement characterizing Heard's allegations as a 'sword and shield' tactic and labeling them fake sexual violence allegations. Waldman confirmed making the statement during his trial testimony.

Evidence or argument describing a coordinated effort involving approximately 20 statements planted in the Daily Mail in spring 2020, before the UK trial.

A blank Danger Assessment Scale test form, published as a demonstrative exhibit and introduced as Plaintiff's 1310.

David Spiegel's deposition transcript — specifically the line 'So, I mean, he's an idiot' and earlier statements about comparing Depp's Pirates performances to deposition testimony.

Hughes's 88-page supplemental clinical notes prepared in connection with her evaluation of Heard.

The curriculum vitae of Dawn Hughes, Ph.D., submitted as Defendant's 1434.

The pre-trial deposition of Dawn Hughes taken March 28, 2022.

Day 16 trial transcript, pages 4585–4604, containing Heard's testimony identifying Defendant's Exhibit 512 as depicting December 15, 2015 penthouse damage.

Day 17 trial transcript, pages 4750–4805, containing Heard's testimony identifying Defendant's Exhibit 725 as depicting spilled wine on May 21, 2016.

A medical record from Amber Heard's December 17, 2015 visit to Dr. Kipper's office, two days after the alleged December 15 incident, documenting no physical injuries and containing a reference to a 'malnourished male' suggesting possible composite or misfiling.

Text exchange between Heard and Depp dated 3/12/2013 referencing 'a hideous moment' and the book Disco Bloodbath

Email Heard sent to herself in June 2013, described as a letter to Depp about the relationship

Text messages from Depp to Heard sent during the July 2013 Bahamas yacht incident

Twitter exchange between That Umbrella Guy and Morgan Night on April 21, 2022, in which Night replied that the Hicksville incident 'never happened' and characterized Heard as 'acting all jealous and crazy'

Defendant's Exhibit 633 — Depp's Pirates of the Caribbean contract from August 2002, naming Wyatt under Location Assistance alongside Sam Sarkar.

Defendant's Exhibit 855 — Paramount Pictures Rango contract from December 2008, naming Wyatt as sound technician at $3,500 per week.

ENT (ears, nose, and throat) medical records from Heard's specialist consultation in 2016 or 2017.

Multi-page document recognized by Saenz and reviewed in deposition preparation

Color version of Depp's handwritten note or coaster, produced in color through Mr. Young's review; previously produced by Depp in black-and-white in this case.

Defendant's Exhibit 1904 — APA ethics committee opinions on principles of medical ethics, containing language that psychiatrists have argued the Goldwater Rule is unsound for expert witnesses who render opinions without examination

Text exchange with Heard on October 29, 2013, in which Depp wrote 'Holy crap horse, r no goddamn meetings. No movies.'

Exhibit admitted into evidence and published to jury without objection from Depp's counsel

Demonstrative 1900 — a monthly bar chart of negative hashtag volume against Heard and Depp from April 2020 through January 2021, derived from Twitter search API data.

Demonstrative 1901 — a line graph of the same hashtag data extended through January 2022, with the dominant 'Justice for Johnny Depp' hashtag removed for scaling clarity.

Deposition Exhibit 52 — an internal Disney email from Angela Shaw to co-chairmen Horn and Bergman, president Bailey, and head of communications Roeder, dated May 10, 2017, subject: 'HR. Johnny Depp: A star in crisis and insane story of his missing moments.'

Deposition Exhibit 53 — an internal Disney email chain (Disney 114–137) involving Alan Horn and Sean Bailey, dated June 21, 2018, with Bailey's reply reading 'Sad.'

Deposition Exhibit 54 — an email exchange between Newman and Scott Sellers dated July 14, 2018, concerning the Rolling Stone article 'Trouble with Johnny Depp,' with Newman's reply 'Depressing.'

Deposition Exhibit 56 — a Disney document (Disney 167–177) forwarded to Alan Bergman, containing a THR item about Depp's legal team preparing for the UK court hearing on Amber Heard's abuse claims, dated October 2018.

Deposition transcript of Richard Moore taken March 22, 2022, specifically pages 163–164.

Deposition video clips (multiple witnesses including Falati, Brandon Patterson) subject to de-designation

Exhibit 116 — floor diagram of Eastern Columbia Building penthouse corridor

Depp Exhibit 5 — a financial document containing Jacobs's notation 'this is good news,' relating to a Bank of America loan secured for Depp.