Depp v. Heard Transcript Ben King
Depp v. Heard / Day 8 / April 25, 2022
2 pages · 2 witnesses · 2,825 lines
Rottenborn closes his cross of Depp with damaging recordings and texts; redirect reframes key exhibits; Ben King testifies about the Australia house destruction and fingertip discovery, with no injuries observed on Heard.
1

[SECTION HEADER]: BY MR. MONIZ:

2 5:33:46

MR. MONIZ: Good afternoon, Mr. king

3 5:33:48

BEN KING: Good afternoon

4 5:33:49

MR. MONIZ: Would you, please, state your full name fur the record.

5 5:33:52

BEN KING: Ben King.

6 5:33:53

MR. MONIZ: And, Mr. King, can you briefly tell us where you're from?

7 5:33:57

BEN KING: London, Central London

8 5:34:00

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And can you tell us a little bit about your background? What's your occupation?

9 5:34:04

BEN KING: I'm a house manager, personal I assistant, presently, with an individual who also lives in Central London.

10 5:34:11

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Can you lean into the microphone a little bit?

11 5:34:14

BEN KING: Yeah, certainly. There we go.

12 5:34:17

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Did you say you're a house manager?

13 5:34:19

BEN KING: That's right. Personal assistant, house manager.

14 5:34:22

MR. MONIZ: And can you just tell those of us in the courtroom who aren't familiar, what does that mean?

15 5:34:27

BEN KING: I work presently for a gentleman who's in the entertainment industry, who - and I manage I 1 s his property, large apartment in Central London, ! 16 take care of the daily needs and running of the oversight of that stuff, and traveling with him, when needed, and things like that.

16 5:34:45

MR. MONIZ: And how long have you been in this occupation?

17 5:34:51

BEN KING: Ooh, since about 1991. I started in private services, if you'd like, in-house private services, if you d like, in house I management and butlering, all that stuff.

18 5:35:03

MR. MONIZ: Typically based around London?

19 5:35:05

BEN KING: Correct. I started work in London, was my first big job at Buckingham Palace, oddly Is enough, for four years. And then I continued in different positions full-time and self-employed, freelance capacity for many years as well.

20 5:35:24

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Just generally, can you tell us, without getting into any specifics, but what type of people would you say you typically provide these services for?

21 5:35:33

BEN KING: Generally, high net worth people. Individuals or families, residences.

22 5:35:40

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Are you familiar with the plaintiff in this case, Johnny Depp?

23 5:35:44

BEN KING: Yes, I am.

24 5:35:46

MR. MONIZ: And how are you familiar with Mr. Depp?

25 5:35:50

BEN KING: I met and worked for Mr. Depp in 2014, and, subsequently, a couple of times after that

26 5:36:01

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Can you briefly just explain to the jury how it came to be that you were working for Mr. Depp?

27 5:36:08

BEN KING: Sure. Yes, I -- at that point, I was working in the freelance, self-employed capacity. I was -- a lot of my jobs came through friends of friends, you know, personal recommendations, et cetera. And I was asked, by a friend of a friend, on this occasion, would I be available, A, to go and manage a property where Mr. Depp was going to be staying for about a month in Central London. Was I available, would I be willing to do it. And I was available at that point, and so I said, yes -- yeah, absolutely.

28 5:36:48

MR. MONIZ: And just to make sure we're on the same page. What time frame are we talking about here?

29 5:36:53

BEN KING: That was August 2014.

30 5:36:57

MR. MONIZ: And did you, in fact, end up working for Mr. Depp in that time frame?

31 5:37:02

BEN KING: I did, yes.

32 5:37:04

MR. MONIZ: Now, just to clarify, were you employed

33

[SECTION HEADER]: By Mr. Depp?

34 5:37:06

BEN KING: No.

35 5:37:08

MR. MONIZ: So who was your employer?

36 5:37:10

BEN KING: I was paid through a large hotel which p g g was close by to the house, who also -- they provided the housekeeper who was working with us for that month as well, so I was paid through them.

37 5:37:25

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Can you just generally explain to us what kind of work you were doing for Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard in this time frame?

38 5:37:31

BEN KING: Sure. Yeah. It was the setup of the house, basically. Sorry. Setting up the house initially, which meant ahead of the principals arriving, which meant making sure all the linens were in place for the bedrooms. It was a sizeable property. Just organizing everything ahead of their arrival. Once they arrived, it was the management of that property, the oversight of it, and the day-to-day running, some service, you know, like butler service, and managing the housekeeper day-to-day, through that whole month.

39 5:38:11

MR. MONIZ: And when you refer to "the principals," who are you referring to?

40 5:38:15

BEN KING: Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard.

41 5:38:18

MR. MONIZ: Where, exactly, were you working in London at this point? Just kind of describe, for us, the house.

42 5:38:24

BEN KING: This house?

43 5:38:24

MR. MONIZ: Yeah.

44 5:38:24

BEN KING: This was in Mayfair, a large townhouse in an old building but it was very contemporary inside, modern. Furnished very modern sort of Is way. Quite spacious, maybe four, five bedrooms, I think, a small indoor pool, a small gym. Quite an open plan layout throughout the house.

45 5:38:52

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And how long were they there?

46 5:38:55

BEN KING: For the month, essentially, yes.

47 5:38:58

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Can you tell us, just generally, 1! 14 what hours you would typically work in a day while you were working for them in London in this time frame?

48 5:39:05

BEN KING: Yeah, approximately, it depended on what was going on, but I mean, generally, 7 or 8 in the morning until 7 or 8 in the evening, typically. There was a chef employed as well, Russell, brilliant chef. He tended to stay after I left in the evenings. He would cook dinner, serve dinner, and thankfully cleaned up after dinner so I could leave sort of early to mid evening, usually, most days.

49 5:39:21

MR. MONIZ: Okay.

50 5:39:36

BEN KING: Unless we had guests. Sorry, unless we had guests or other things going on.

51 5:39:43

MR. MONIZ: All right. During your time managing the house for Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard in 2014, did you have occasion to observe the interactions between Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard?

52 5:39:50

BEN KING: Yes, absolutely.

53 5:39:57

MR. MONIZ: How often?

54 5:39:58

BEN KING: Most daily, I would say. Pretty much most days through that period.

55 5:40:03

MR. MONIZ: And did you, yourself, interact with Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard?

56 5:40:06

BEN KING: Yes. Also daily, I would say.

57 5:40:09

MR. MONIZ: Which of them would you say -- or did you see one of them more often than the other?

58 5:40:14

BEN KING: Ms. Heard was there. Mr. Depp was the reason, I think, they rented the house, because Mr. Depp was working at a studio. I think it was Mortdecai, the movie. So Ms. Heard was there at the house most of the days. Mr. Depp often went to work and came back later on in that evening, that day.

59 5:40:34

MR. MONIZ: Okay. How would you generally describe the interactions that you observed between Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard?

60 5:40:43

BEN KING: Initially, very loving towards each other. Nice couple. Mr. Depp was always a gentleman and keen to make sure Ms. Heard was taken care of, anything she needed. Often poured a glass of wine for her, just nice, you know, pleasant.

61 5:41:07

MR. MONIZ: How about your own interactions with the couple? How did you get along with them both?

62 5:41:11

BEN KING: I think very well. Yeah, they were very open to me. And, I mean, my background is quite formal, so it was quite an informal setting. It was - I was able to ask questions to either of them. Ms. Heard, especially, was really helpful to get information about what time they wanted dinner, you know, basic stuff like that, or dinner, you know, basic stuff like that, or anything. It was good interaction all the time with the both of them.

63 5:41:41

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Now, you mentioned wine. Could you tell us, to what approximate extent did you cow-se of these four weeks?

64 5:41:46

BEN KING: Sure. When I started that job or when observe either of them consume alcohol over the I was taking that job on, I was told, I think, by Mr. Depp's assistant that he was -

65 5:41:54

MR. ROTTENBORN: Objection, Your Honor. Hearsay. Mr. Depp's assistant.

66 5:42:02

BEN KING: Oh, sorry.

67

[SECTION HEADER]: BY MR. MONIZ:

68 5:42:04

MR. MONIZ: Can you answer without telling what you were told?

69 5:42:08

BEN KING: I was made aware.

70 5:42:11

MR. ROTTENBORN: Same objection.

71 5:42:14

THE COURT: Can you put your microphone on?

72 5:42:16

MR. NADELHAFT: Same objection. He's explaining what he was told; now he is saying I was informed.

73

MR. MONIZ: I don't think it's offered for the truth, Your Honor. I think it's just offered to explain his own behavior towards the couple.

74

MR. NADELHAFT: Can we approach?

75 5:42:17

THE COURT: Okay.

76

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Sidebar.)

77 5:42:19

THE COURT: I 18 I don't know what he's going to say, so I'm not sure.

78 5:42:33

THE COURT: He was told that?

79

MR. NADELHAFT: He was told by Depp's agent, Depp's assistant that (indiscernible). If it's not offered for the truth, what else would it be for?

80

MR. MONIZ: Yeah, it's just being offered for the fact -- and that is what he is going to say, I think, is that he was informed -- he told her on that basis, he was bringing wine -- he understood he that wasn't bringing wine to Mr. Depp. It was just to explain his own understanding of the context.

81

MR. NADELHAFT: I think he's going to say (indiscernible).

82 5:42:47

MR. NADELHAFT: You Honor, it's hearsay.

83 5:43:01

THE COURT: Still hearsay. Thank you.

84

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Open court.)

85

[Section Header]: BY MR. MONIZ:

86 5:43:15

MR. MONIZ: All right. So, Mr. King, moving past Is the conversation, let's not touch on that.

87 5:43:18

BEN KING: Yes.

88 5:43:21

MR. MONIZ: In general, can you describe the alcohol consumption that you personally observed and what you personally witnessed?

89 5:43:28

BEN KING: Sure. I didn't see Mr. Heard- Mr. Depp, excuse me, consume any alcohol during that time in London. There was a large confinement of wine that had been delivered to the house at the start of the visit, many cases, I had to store, I had to find a place to store. And generally speaking, on a day-to-day, about one or two boxes of red wine were consumed per day. I think that's fair to say.

90 5:43:57

MR. MONIZ: Did you ever observe Mr. Depp drink any of the wine?

91 5:44:01

BEN KING: No, I didn't.

92 5:44:02

MR. MONIZ: Did you ever observe Ms. Heard drink any of the wine?

93 5:44:04

BEN KING: Yes, I did

94 5:44:07

MR. MONIZ: Regularly?

95 5:44:10

BEN KING: Daily.

96 5:44:13

MR. MONIZ: Now, I think you ah"early testified that you observed interactions with Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard and you generally found them to be friendly; is that fair?

97 5:44:23

BEN KING: Very much so, yes.

98 5:44:25

MR. MONIZ: Were there any exceptions to that?

99 5:44:28

BEN KING: Towards me?

100 5:44:29

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

101 5:44:30

MR. MONIZ: I'll rephrase.

102 5:44:30

THE COURT: Okay.

103 5:44:31

MR. MONIZ: Did you ever observe any arguments between the two?

104 5:44:33

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection, Your Honor.

105 5:44:35

THE COURT: I'll allow it. Go ahead.

106 5:44:38

BEN KING: Oh, yes I did.

107 5:44:40

MR. MONIZ: Can you describe, for us, the arguments that you observed?

108 5:44:43

BEN KING: I can describe two of them, certainly. There were a few arguments during that month.

109 5:44:51

MR. MONIZ: Let's start with those two.

110 5:44:53

BEN KING: Okay. The first one I remember was an evening, actually both the ones I recall were - I was close to were evenings. The first particular evening, the couple had agreed to go out for dinner, I guess. I know the car was waiting and- in the little courtyard there, ready for them to go, and security was waiting to take them. I was waiting to see them out into the cars on the foot of the - on the ground level, ground floor level to wait to see them out, essentially.

111 5:45:32

BEN KING: And I heard - the first thing I heard was Ms. Heard shouting upstairs in the master suite, where they were getting ready to leave. I heard her shout something, I don't recall what, you know. I was in the vicinity, I wasn't really there to listen. And I heard footsteps, loud footsteps sort of going across, there's, like, a corridor, if you like, to the top of those stairs that went around the master suite. Loud footsteps and then more footsteps following, more shouting. And that sort of went on for some time. I mean, I knew what time they needed to leave. I don't recall what time that was, but they- I knew they were supposed to have left already, and it went on for a bit.

112 5:46:21

MR. MONIZ: Do you recall how that first fight or argument resolved?

113 5:46:27

BEN KING: Not necessarily. I mean, I know that they left eventually, albeit late. I don't know how it really resolved, as I made myself busy but not going too far away from the door, make sure I saw them out.

114 5:46:42

MR. MONIZ: All right. And then what about the second argument that you mentioned?

115 5:46:45

BEN KING: Second one, I was pretty much in the same vicinity, the same room, on the ground floor. Again, the couple were in the TV room, I think, which was off the main sitting room, early evening, and I was going about my early evening duties, replenishing drinks close by, lighting the fire, lighting candles, whatever it might have been. I was close enough to hear Ms. Heard say "Why did you take your hand away from me, Johnny? Do you love me anymore?" Like, not in a playful way I might add. And I think he replied "Of course I do. Don't be silly. Of course I do."

116 5:47:30

BEN KING: And it kind of launched from that point. And at one point, Mr. Depp got up and went to the bathroom or went upstairs and I was sort of scuttling around out of the way because, you know, I wasn't there listening, I was just there doing my stuff in and around them. Yeah, it was a strange, sort of bizarre way to start an argument, but ...

117 5:47:55

MR. MONIZ: How would you describe Ms. Heard's tone I when she said 'Why did you take your hand away, Johnny?"

118 5:48:03

BEN KING: Accusatory. Spoiled teenage child, maybe. Is that fair? Not playfully, let's put it that way. More angrily.

119 5:48:17

MR. MONIZ: Over the course of the four weeks in August and September of 2014, when you were working with Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard in the London --

120 5:48:24

BEN KING: Yes.

121 5:48:25

MR. MONIZ: Did you ever observe any physical violence, of any kind, between the two of them?

122 5:48:28

BEN KING: No, I didn't

123 5:48:30

MR. MONIZ: Did you ever observe any injuries on O either one?

124 5:48:33

BEN KING: No, neither of them

125 5:48:34

MR. MONIZ: Okay. After those four weeks, did you ever work for Mr. Depp or Ms. Heard again?

126 5:48:40

BEN KING: I did. A couple of occasions. The following year was the first one, the following spring.

127 5:48:48

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And where was that?

128 5:48:50

BEN KING: In Australia.

129 5:48:53

MR. MONIZ: And was it unusual for you to be in Australia?

130 5:48:57

BEN KING: In Australia maybe, but not unusual for me to travel with - for clients for my me to travel with for clients for my assignments, to wherever it was needed.

131 5:49:05

MR. MONIZ: Okay. How exactly did it come about that you were in Australia with Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard?

132 5:49:11

BEN KING: Towards the end of the London visit, Mr. Depp had kindly said, thanks so much for looking after us, we really like you. Maybe if you're free next year and we can arrange it, we can make it happen. Perhaps you'll be able to come to Australia with us, I've got a film, Pirates 5. So I said, great, I'd love to, obviously. I was freelance at the time so it was going to be about four months work. I think it was billed up, so, I thought, yes, I wouldn't mind some of that. Thank you very much.

133 5:49:45

MR. MONIZ: And where in Australia were you staying?

134 5:49:50

BEN KING: Gold Coast. It's an area - Brisbane was the main airport. So, about an hour's drive south of Brisbane.

135 5:49:57

MR. MONIZ: And do you recall when you arrived?

136 5:50:00

BEN KING: I arrived on February the 4th. I know April 25, 2022 ,1 I flew in on that day.

137 5:50:06

MR. MONIZ: Okay. How did your job responsibilities in Australia compare to your job responsibilities in London?

138 5:50:13

BEN KING: Much the same. Just on a bigger scale. The house was larger. There was a bit more setup to do. But, essentially, the same oversight of Is the house, responsible for it during the whole gig.

139 5:50:28

MR. MONIZ: And were you employed by Mr. Depp or Ms. Heard?

140 5:50:31

BEN KING: No.

141 5:50:32

MR. MONIZ: Who were you employed by?

142 5:50:34

BEN KING: Essentially, by Disney, the production company affiliated with Disney who were making the movie. I think their name was Herschel (phonetic), was the production company.

143 5:50:46

MR. MONIZ: Now, I think you said you arrived in Australia on February 4th, 2015, correct?

144 5:50:48

BEN KING: Yes.

145 5:50:49

MR. MONIZ: Do I have that right?

146 5:50:51

BEN KING: Yes.

147 5:50:51

BEN KING: Yes.

148 5:50:52

MR. MONIZ: How about Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard, when b did they arrive?

149 5:50:56

BEN KING: The setup for me, for us was about a few weeks. I think they arrived towards the end lS of February, 2015.

150 5:51:07

MR. MONIZ: And between your arrival and their arrival what had you been doing?

151 5:51:13

BEN KING: Just setting up the house. I lived on site. There was a guesthouse on site, two-bedroom, single-story guesthouse that I stayed in for those first couple weeks, setting up the house and just getting everything ready during that time. Then I moved out to apartments, which we all had - we, I mean a lot of the crew, the chef had an apartment. We all had apartments about a 30-minute drive south of the house.

152 5:51:42

MR. MONIZ: Okay. So we're talking about this . house in Australia.

153 5:51:44

BEN KING: Yes.

154 5:51:45

MR. MONIZ: So can you kind of describe that property to us?

155 5:51:49

BEN KING: Yes. It was a large house on a few acres of land, three-story house, five bedrooms with two or three buildings on - within the grounds as well. A good size house, beautiful house. Beautiful location.

156 5:52:13

MR. MONIZ: How many entrances would you say it had?

157 5:52:16

BEN KING: Entrances? Many. I mean, many on - on the lower ground level, out to the garden; on the first or on the main floor level, there was many entrances. I mean, every room in that house had a balcony, at least. Every room on the lower ground floor had a sliding door, a door out. The utility room, the garage, the gym, the - everything. Obviously, the front door. Many. On the main level, large glass sliding doors out to the pool area, which had a gazebo and steps down to the ground.

158 5:53:02

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Once Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard arrived to stay at this house, was anybody else staying in the house?

159 5:53:09

BEN KING: Staying in the house? No.

160 5:53:12

MR. MONIZ: Was anybody else staying on the grounds?

161 5:53:14

BEN KING: On the property, yes. I mean, there was a couple there -- caretaking couple, Sean and his wife, Saundra, who worked for the owner of the house. They lived on site, essentially, all the time. They were there pretty much throughout, and their house was whatever, couple hundred yards away from the main house. And, yes, security was there also.

162 5:53:42

MR. MONIZ: All right. Sticking with the caretaker, just briefly, about how long would it take, would you estimate it would take to walk from the main house to the caretaker's house?

163 5:53:51

BEN KING: Under five minutes. Yeah, no more than five minutes.

164 5:53:57

MR. MONIZ: And then you mentioned security. What was the security setup?

165 5:54:00

BEN KING: Security was set up by Jerry Judge. They reported -- they stayed in the grounds for the duration. They didn't come in the house. They had a little sort of shack, right by the perimeter wall, where they would do their -- start their patrols from, walk around the grounds, around the exterior of the house at certain times of the day, write their reports and go back and stand there, their shack.

166 5:54:28

MR. MONIZ: And how many security guards would be :. on site at any particular time?

167 5:54:31

BEN KING: I think one in the day, one in the Is night. So, 12 hours about, as I remember it.

168 5:54:37

MR. MONIZ: Oh, it was 24/7?

169 5:54:39

BEN KING: Yes, definitely.

170 5:54:40

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Do you know whether those were local employees or were they regularly employed by Mr. Depp?

171 5:54:45

BEN KING: They were Australian, yes.

172 5:54:50

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Now, I think you said you were not on the property 24/7, right? You had an apartment elsewhere?

173 5:54:58

BEN KING: Correct. I kept the same hours as I did in London, essentially, Monday to Friday, 9 to 5, not quite, but 7:00 a.m. to evening, until everything was set up and I could leave.

174 5:55:14

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And did you have an opportunity, when you were in Australia, to observe Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard's interactions with each other?

175 5:55:22

BEN KING: Yes. Of course.

176 5:55:23

MR. MONIZ: And how would you describe them?

177 5:55:27

BEN KING: Initially, very good Like in London, seemed very pleasant towards each other. ,7

178 5:55:33

MR. MONIZ: Did you observe any arguments?

179 5:55:36

BEN KING: Yes. Several.

180 5:55:38

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Can you tell us a little bit about those?

181 5:55:46

BEN KING: Yes. Similar pattern, it seemed, to London arguments. One in particular was very similar to the second one in London. Started in the TV room, funny enough, loud, loud voices and Mr. Depp leaving the room, shutting the door, going to another room to play his guitar or, you know, to a bathroom, whatever, and Ms. Heard closely following and opening the door or certainly rapping on the door, it seemed to continue.

182 5:56:26

MR. MONIZ: Can you give us an estimate about how many arguments you think you observed in this time frame, approximately?

183 5:56:31

BEN KING: Several. I was there for several months, so certainly many more than in London.

184 5:56:38

MR. MONIZ: Did you observe any alcohol consumption in Australia, by either of them?

185 5:56:43

BEN KING: Yes. Again, Ms. Heard, again, my responsible -- part of the responsibility was to provision the house and have everything set up for that, so I regularly brought red wine for Ms. Heard. What she consumed, you know, the same amount as in London, I think.

186 5:57:06

MR. MONIZ: And what amount is that?

187 5:57:07

BEN KING: Generally speaking. One or two bottles a day.

188 5:57:12

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Did you ever observe Mr. Depp start any arguments with Ms. Heard?

189 5:57:15

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection.

190 5:57:17

THE COURT: Hold on. Objection.

191 5:57:20

BEN KING: Sorry.

192 5:57:22

THE COURT: Would you put your microphone -- there you go.

193

MR. NADELHAFT: Leading. Objection

194 5:57:24

MR. NADELHAFT: Leading. Objection. Leading.

195 5:57:25

THE COURT: I'll sustain as to leading.

196 5:57:26

THE COURT: If you want to rephrase.

197 5:57:27

MR. MONIZ: I'll move on.

198 5:57:28

THE COURT: New question, okay.

199 5:57:32

MR. MONIZ: Do you remember anything about Friday, March 6th, 2015?

200 5:57:38

BEN KING: It was essentially a normal Friday, if you'd like, end of the week, yay. Nothing extraordinary about that day.

201 5:57:49

MR. MONIZ: Did you come into work that day?

202 5:57:52

BEN KING: Yeah. Yeah, I was there.

203 5:57:53

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Do you recall about what time you would have left the house on that date?

204 5:57:59

BEN KING: I remember taking a photo of the beautiful sunset over the pool, the sun was set over the pool and the creek, and I took a photo of that early evening, so 6:30, 7, I would think. I wouldn't have left much later than that.

205 5:58:14

MR. MONIZ: Was Mr. Depp there when you left?

206 5:58:17

BEN KING: I don't think so. I think Mr. Depp was at the studio still on that day. I can't remember sort of seeing him to say good-bye, you know, have a good weekend.

207 5:58:26

MR. MONIZ: How about Ms. Heard? Do you recall if she was there when you left?

208 5:58:30

BEN KING: Yes, she was.

209 5:58:32

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Did anything unusual happen that weekend?

210 5:58:37

BEN KING: Yeah. I would say something pretty unusual happened.

211 5:58:42

MR. MONIZ: Can you tell us about that?

212 5:58:46

BEN KING: Yeah, I can.

213 5:58:48

MR. NADELHAFT: Foundation.

214 5:58:48

THE COURT: All right. Foundation.

215 5:58:50

THE COURT: Do you want to Jay a foundation?

216 5:58:51

MR. MONIZ: At some point, did you become aware that something had happened?

217 5:58:53

BEN KING: Yes.

218 5:58:55

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. It calls for hearsay.

219 5:58:57

THE COURT: All right. I'll sustain that objection. ---

220 5:59:01

MR. MONIZ: All right. Turning to the following All right. Turning to the following I Sunday.

221 5:59:03

THE COURT: Mr. Moniz, how much more do you have, because it's time for an afternoon break?

222 5:59:08

MR. MONIZ: Think we can -- I have a little bit more, Your Honor, so maybe this would be a good time for a break.

223 5:59:12

THE COURT: Okay. Let's go ahead and take our afternoon break, ladies and gentlemen. IO Again, don't talk to anybody and don't do any I outside research, okay? You're excused. Thank i you. l 13

224 6:02:16

THE COURT: All right. Mr. King, since you're in the middle of your testimony, you can't discuss your testimony with anybody, to include the attorneys, okay?

225

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Whereupon, the jury exited the ! 14 courtroom and the following proceedings took ! s place.)

226 6:05:21

BEN KING: All right.

227 6:08:25

THE COURT: Okay. Let's take a break until 4:05, okay? Let's come back at 4:05.

228 6:11:29

COURT BAILIFF: All rise.

229

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Recess taken from 3:47 p.m. to 4:05 p.m.)

230 6:14:33

COURT BAILIFF: All rise. Please be seated and come to order.

231 6:17:38

THE COURT: All right. Are we ready for the jury?

232 6:18:12

MR. MONIZ: Yes, Your Honor.

233

MR. NADELHAFT: Yes, Your Honor.

234

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Whereupon, the jury entered the courtroom and the following proceedings took place.)

235 6:18:47

THE COURT: All right. Have a seat.

236 6:18:48

THE COURT: Your next question, sir.

237

MR. MONIZ: Thank you, Your Honor.

238

[Section Header]: BY MR. MONIZ:

239 6:18:51

MR. MONIZ: Mr. King.

240 6:18:54

BEN KING: Yes.

241 6:18:57

MR. MONIZ: Before we went on break, we were discussing Friday, March 6th, 2015.

242 6:19:06

BEN KING: Right.

243 6:19:07

MR. MONIZ: After you left the house that evening, te you e t t e ouse t at eve g, when did you next see Ms. Heard?

244 6:19:16

BEN KING: Sunday, the 8th.

245 6:19:18

MR. MONIZ: And where did you see Ms. Heard?

246 6:19:22

BEN KING: At the house.

247 6:19:25

MR. MONIZ: What were your typically hours?

248 6:19:29

BEN KING: Monday through Friday from 7:00 or 8:00 a.m until the end of the day each evening, late evening, usually.

249 6:19:36

MR. MONIZ: Why were you at the house that Sunday?

250 6:19:39

BEN KING: I was called to the house by one of Mr. Depp's assistants.

251 6:19:44

MR. MONIZ: And about what time did you arrive at the house?

252 6:19:49

BEN KING: Around 2:00, 2:30.

253 6:19:53

MR. MONIZ: Who was there when you arrived?

254 6:19:57

BEN KING: Debbie Lloyd was there, Dave Kipper was there, Amber Heard was there, Jerry Judge was there.

255 6:20:09

MR. MONIZ: And I think by now, probably, everybody's familiar, but can you just, very quickly, say who those people are?

256 6:20:17

BEN KING: Sure Debbie Lloyd was a nurse David Kipper was Dr David Kipper Ms Heard was Ms Heard and Jerry Judge was head of security

257 6:20:31

MR. MONIZ: And when you arrived at the house on Sunday, March 8th, 2015, what did you do?

258 6:20:38

BEN KING: I just parked up and went into the house.

259 6:20:42

MR. MONIZ: And did you observe anything when you went into the house?

260 6:20:46

BEN KING: Yeah. I mean, initially, I walked into the front door. Initially, I heard, rather than saw anything. I could hear pretty hysterical sobbing, crying, which sounded like Ms. Heard to me. I heard Jerry Judge's voice. There's a few steps as you go up into the house, so you can't immediately see what's going on. So I went up the steps. I could see them, Ms. Heard, over on the right-hand side, toward the TV room, with Jerry Judge, David Kipper was in the kitchen area, which was pretty much directly ahead as you walk up those steps.

261 6:21:10

MR. MONIZ: 122 Ms Heard !

262 6:21:34

BEN KING: Yes.

263 6:21:35

MR. MONIZ: And you were able to hear her, as well?

264 6:21:38

BEN KING: Absolutely.

265 6:21:39

MR. MONIZ: How would you describe her demeanor?

266 6:21:43

BEN KING: Hysterical. Probably the best way to describe it. Crying a lot and, you know, just crying uncontrollably, I think it's fair to say.

267 6:21:57

MR. MONIZ: And how would you describe Jerry Judge's demeanor when he was speaking with her?

268 6:22:02

BEN KING: He was keeping her calm, saying it's I all right, love, it will be all right. Jerry was good. Big heart, Jerry. Good guy. He was calm, Jerry was always calm - well, mostly.

269 6:22:19

MR. MONIZ: And what did you do next?

270 6:22:25

BEN KING: I saw them engaged across the way there, so I went into the main kitchen area, 1117 which, as I said, was just directly ahead of those main steps, and spoke to David Kipper.

271 6:22:38

MR. MONIZ: And following that conversation, what did you do?

272 6:22:42

BEN KING: Well, he told me that Mr. Depp -

273 6:22:45

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Hearsay.

274 6:22:49

THE COURT: All right.

275 6:22:52

MR. MONIZ: Your Honor -- well, may we approach?

276 6:22:55

THE COURT: Okay.

277

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Sidebar.)

278 6:22:58

THE COURT: One, the question was, what did you do after you spoke with Dr. Kipper? Let's get that straight.

279 6:23:01

MR. MONIZ: Understood. Your Honor, O Mr. King just searched the house for the finger, so he's just going to say he was told he needed to look for the finger. It's not being offered for the truth, it's just being offered to explain why he was going around looking for the finger. He's not going to testify he was told, at this point, how it was lost. So it's not being offered for the truth. It's purely the effect on the listener.

280 6:23:05

MR. NADELHAFT: (Indiscernible.)

281 6:23:08

MR. MONIZ: Definitionally not hearsay Your Honor Its simply being offered to explain why he is going

282 6:23:11

THE COURT: If he starts saying something about Johnny, we know what he's going to say.

283 6:23:14

MR. MONIZ: He's going to say he was informed that he needed to go find Mr. Depp's finger.

284 6:23:18

THE COURT: Okay. Not the reason for it?

285 6:23:21

MR. MONIZ: He was not informed of how he lost his finger.

286 6:23:24

THE COURT: I think that's fine. Okay.

287

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Open court.)

288

[SECTION HEADER]: BY MR. MONIZ:

289 6:23:58

MR. MONIZ: So, you can answer the question. What did you do next?

290 6:24:02

BEN KING: I spoke to David Kipper, who was in the kitchen area, seemingly rummaging through a bin. He said Mr. Depp had sustained an injury to his finger, one of his fingers, and he was looking for the fingertip. He said it had been severed.

291 6:24:13

MR. MONIZ: And --

292 6:24:24

BEN KING: So, I said, well, shall I help you?

293 6:24:26

BEN KING: You know, as one would. And he said, yeah, that would be a good idea. I left him in the kitchen. He said there was a lot more damage downstairs. So I went to -- you know, we split up. I left him Is in the kitchen, I went downstairs to search.

294 6:24:43

MR. MONIZ: At some point, was Mr. Depp's fingertip found?

295 6:24:47

BEN KING: Yes.

296 6:24:47

MR. MONIZ: Who found it?

297 6:24:50

BEN KING: I did.

298 6:24:52

MR. MONIZ: And where did you find it?

299 6:24:54

BEN KING: Downstairs in the bar area, the games room, bar area.

300 6:25:03

MR. MONIZ: So, can you walk us through how you ! s found it?

301 6:25:10

BEN KING: Yes. So I walked down the stairs, there's a bit of damage down the steps, a big chunk had been taken out of the marble staircase. On my way down, remnants of what looked like a plant pot or something around it smashed. Walking down into the bar, I could see the damage that Dr. Kipper had told me about, a broken ping-pong table had collapsed on to the floor, lots of grass, broken glass and cans strewn around the bar area.

302 6:25:44

MR. MONIZ: And where, exactly, was the finger in I ! 5 the bar area? I 16.

303 6:25:49

BEN KING: Directly below the bar. I mean, the bar -- the setup like a conventional bar, that is stuck out from a wall, and with a marble top, there was a big chunk out of that as well, like on the staircase. Directly at the end of the bar, there was a scrunched up piece of kitchen paper, if you'd like, tissue, with lots of blood around it, on it. So I thought that's probably a pretty good place to look. And it was within that scrunched up piece of paper on the tiled floor at the end of the bar, the base of the bar, by one of the barstools.

304 6:26:32

MR. MONIZ: Was there any property damage around the finger?

305 6:26:36

BEN KING: Yes, a fair bit. On the floor, around the area, there were puddles of what smelled like alcohol to me. There seemed like several drinking glasses, a couple of bottles, one was Stolichnaya, a vodka bottle. And at the end of the bar, as I said, there's a big chunk out of the bar itself, the bar marble top. At the end of the bar, there was plaster damage right at the end of the bar, on the wall behind the bar, it was smashed and cracked. There's a blue mirror that stretched that whole span of behind the bar. Lots of cans, again, behind the bar on the floor, broken window at the end of the bar, and more plaster work damage on the wall above the sink; it's sort of a kitchenette, bar, if you'd like, as well.

306 6:27:31

MR. MONIZ: You mentioned a bottle of vodka. Was the vodka bottle intact?

307 6:27:37

BEN KING: No. No. Nothing was really intact. The top of it, you know, the top of the bottle has, like, the label on it, which is how I knew it was a Stolichnaya bottle, had that sort of squiggly S, sort of yellow top. There was a large chunk of the bottle, where, I guess, was the rest of that, and several other - I mean, lots of other broken glass around the area.

308 6:28:05

MR. MONIZ: After you found the fingertip in the bar area, what did you do next?

309 6:28:11

BEN KING: Well, I covered it up in that kitchen paper, took it upstairs, I might have shouted up to David Kipper I found it, I'm not sure, but I walked back upstairs to the kitchen. And put it - got a bag, you know, little plastic bag, put the fingertip in there, set it on top of some ice in this plastic kitchen container, and pretty much handed it over to David Kipper and Jerry Judge, I think, at the time, who were keen to get it to the hospital quickly to see if it could be reattached.

310 6:28:48

MR. MONIZ: Do you recall about what time you found Mr. Depp's finger in the bar area?

311 6:28:53

BEN KING: It was about an hour after I got there, so it would have been around 3:30, I would think, 3:20, 3:30.

312 6:29:05

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Now, you've told us a little bit about the state the house was in when you arrived.

313 6:29:11

BEN KING: Yes.

314 6:29:13

MR. MONIZ: Can you generally describe for us, and maybe go level by level through the house, what damage you observed?

315 6:29:22

BEN KING: Sure. Do you want me to start at the lower ground floor in that bar area? I mean, I described it a lot.

316 6:29:25

MR. MONIZ: Sure, that's fine.

317 6:29:28

BEN KING: It was pretty extensive down there, all that broken glass, the blood. There were a lot of blood drips across that floor, as it was a kind of cream-colored tile floor in that whole game area. As I said, the ping-pong table was collapsed. Blood drips across the floor and around the bar, and the damage on the walls, as I said, the plaster work at the end of the bar, behind the bar, and the chunk out of the marble top. So, on the ground, that was the predominant damage in that area, on that level.

318 6:30:05

BEN KING: The next floor, the main floor, where David Kipper was, be it in the kitchen itself, again, a few broken glasses and cans on the floor, soda cans behind the kitchen island, chefs kitchen island, liquid, puddles. There was a sitting room with a cream-colored couch, which had a fair amount of blood drops on the cushions, and that was obvious. The TV, which I was directly in front of that, wall-mounted TV, it was cracked with seemed like remnants of a coffee cup embedded in some of it, and the rest, below, looked like coffee splattered behind and underneath the TV, and on the floor as well. Through there, it's an art studio, so a lot of the art materials from that, you know, paintbrushes, paint, various art materials were on the floor.

319 6:31:08

BEN KING: A lot of paint on the floor, blood drips throughout that area as well, especially over the, it was a vast sort of wooden pocket door, so there was a lot of oil paint and blood drips up to the staircase.

320 6:31:25

BEN KING: In one of the bedrooms, there were two bedrooms off of the main kitchen area, one of those bedrooms had blood drips on the duvet and the lamp had seemingly been broken, the shade was removed. There were a couple of lamp shades in that -- in the art studio area on the floor. That was about the extent of the damage. Going up the stairs to the next level, there was a few blood smears on the wall and on the - drips up the stairs going up, again, the cream-colored carpet, which is not ideal. And, so, the top floor was the master bedroom, master suite floor, and two bedrooms also up there.

321 6:32:21

BEN KING: Outside the master bedroom, there was damage to the plaster work on the pillar outside on the wall, blood drips into the master bedroom, across the master bedroom floor. Going into the master bathroom, there was - there was a his-and-her sink and a mirror, large mirror above each of the sinks, that had writing on each of them. Again, one of the bedrooms or both of the bedrooms, I think, had blood on the duvet covers and another lamp was broken. Mr. Depp's guitar was in one of those bedrooms, bloodstained guitar. His iPad was standing up on one of the beds in one of the bedrooms.

322 6:33:18

BEN KING: That's, I mean, that's about the extent of it.

323 6:33:21

MR. MONIZ: That's the damage?

324 6:33:24

BEN KING: On each level, yeah.

325 6:33:26

MR. MONIZ: Whose job was it to clean all that p

326 6:33:34

BEN KING: Well, it was mine. It was my responsibility. The house was, essentially, my responsibility.

327 6:33:39

MR. MONIZ: So you were familiar -- were you familiar with the damage, generally, throughout the house?

328 6:33:43

BEN KING: I had a pretty good idea, as I walked around and saw it all, yes.

329 6:33:49

MR. MONIZ: Did you observe any damaged phones?

330 6:33:53

BEN KING: No.

331 6:33:53

MR. MONIZ: Did you observe any damage to a wall where a phone might have been ripped off the wall?

332 6:33:58

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection, Your Honor. Leading.

333 6:34:02

THE COURT: All right. Maybe the next one.

334 6:34:04
335 6:34:05

MR. MONIZ: Was there any artwork in this house, decorating the house?

336 6:34:10

BEN KING: The owners, they left their art in the house, yes. Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard had done some ,2 artwork themselves, yes. But, yes, there were some that came with the house, if you'd like.

337 6:34:23

BEN KING: AQ Focusing just on the artwork that came with the house.

338 6:34:26

MR. MONIZ: Uh-huh. Did you observe any damage to any of Is that?

339 6:34:29

BEN KING: No. Nothing that I needed to repair or ,10 replace. Certainly not. Thank goodness.

340 6:34:38

MR. MONIZ: Any other damage that comes to mind?

341 6:34:42

BEN KING: Just a little blood, a lot of repairs. Just the floors were quite heavy with blood and paint, yeah.

342 6:34:53

MR. MONIZ: And in terms of bodily fluids, it was just blood that you observed, no urine or anything else?

343 6:34:57

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

344 6:35:00

THE COURT: I'll sustain. Strike the answer from the record.

345 6:35:05

MR. MONIZ: No other damage -- does any other damage come to mind?

346 6:35:09

BEN KING: No.

347 6:35:12

MR. MONIZ: Can you take a look at Defendant's Exhibit 375.

348 6:35:15

MR. MONIZ: Which I believe is already in evidence.

349 6:35:17

THE COURT: Yes.

350 6:35:19

MR. MONIZ: And can we publish this to the jury?

351 6:35:26

THE COURT: Okay.

352 6:35:33

MR. MONIZ: Mr. King, are you familiar with the image that's on the screen in front of you?

353 6:35:38

BEN KING: Yeah, that's one of the mirrors I was telling you about in the master bathroom.

354 6:35:43

MR. MONIZ: And so, were you involved in cleaning I any of this up?

355 6:35:47

BEN KING: I cleaned both of those mirrors at some I point that evening, that night, yes.

356 6:35:53

MR. MONIZ: Were you able to tell what was used, or I what substance the, I guess, what sort of ink it is that's used on the black writing there?

357 6:36:01

BEN KING: That was the same oil paint that was on the floor, the parquet floor downstairs, and various other areas, the same oil paint.

358 6:36:13

MR. MONIZ: All right. How about the red writing that says "call Carly Simon. She said it better, babe"? Were you able to tell what was used to make that writing?

359 6:36:20

BEN KING: Lipstick, I believe.

360 6:36:28

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Foundation. Objection. Foundation.

361 6:36:28

MR. MONIZ: He's testified that he was cleaning it up.

362 6:36:30

THE COURT: I'll allow it. Go ahead.

363 6:36:32

BEN KING: Certainly seemed like lipstick to me. Red lipstick. It was quite waxy. I remember taking that off. It seemed like lipstick.

364 6:36:42

MR. MONIZ: Okay.

365 6:36:43

MR. MONIZ: We can take that down.

366 6:36:47

MR. MONIZ: Mr. King, about how long were you at the house on that Sunday?

367 6:36:54

BEN KING: Quite a long time. It actually went into the early hours of Monday morning, so, at least, I got there around 2 in the afternoon of Sunday. I don't think I left there until 2 or 3:00 the next morning of the night.

368 6:37:12

MR. MONIZ: Over the course of the time that you were there that day, did you have any interactions with Ms. Heard?

369 6:37:17

BEN KING: Yes. I certainly did. Yes.

370 6:37:22

MR. MONIZ: Can you describe those for us, please?

371 6:37:25

BEN KING: Yeah, not too much, initially. She was very, as I said, quite hysterical and crying a lot, and Jerry Judge was taking care of her, keeping her calm. But later in the evening, it was - it was suggested that Ms. Heard go to a local hotel, to leave the house to go to a local hotel, which then became a suggestion that she go back to LA. And that's when, I think, I started interacting in terms of, at some point, I volunteered to travel with her to LA.

372 6:38:04

MR. MONIZ: How did Ms. Heard respond to the suggestion that she leave Los Angeles -- leave for Los Angeles?

373 6:38:10

BEN KING: She was resistant to both of those suggestions, very resistant, really didn't want to go. She said, I can't leave. I can't leave. It will be the end if I leave. Those sorts of I! Is things. And so, it was just - these went over a few hours, those negotiations, if you'd like. And eventually, Ms. Heard agreed that I would fly with her.

374 6:38:41

MR. MONIZ: And did you, in fact, fly with her?

375 6:38:43

BEN KING: I did. On Monday, the 9th. i were interacting with her on that Sunday, were I you -- how close were you to her?

376 6:38:51

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Sticking with Sunday, when you

377 6:39:00

BEN KING: Very close. You know, like, very close. In front of her.

378 6:39:03

MR. MONIZ: And do you recall observing any injuries on Ms. Heard?

379 6:39:07

BEN KING: No. None whatsoever.

380 6:39:09

MR. MONIZ: Did you notice anything unusual about her physically, at all?

381 6:39:14

BEN KING: No. I mean, she was obviously crying a I lot. She had red eyes and - but, no. Otherwise, ' 12000. ;21

382 6:39:23

MR. MONIZ: So what happens the following day, that Monday, March 9th, I guess it would be, 2015? , g , I

383 6:39:30

BEN KING: Right. So, I mean, it was eventually agreed that I would fly with Ms. Heard. So I had to, at some point, go back to my apartment, drive to my apartment to pick up my passport, which, fondly enough, I hadn't brought with me, and some clothes, you know, a bag to take. So I think I left the house early hours, as I said, two or three, may have been a bit later, a.m. I drove back to my apartment, which was a 30 minutes' drive south, picked up those things.

384 6:40:03

BEN KING: I mean, I didn't know what I was - how long I was going to go for, but I knew I was traveling, so passport, quick shower, pick up a bag of clothes. And then I drove back up to the house. I don't recall exactly what time I arrived there, but I know we had to leave. All the arrangements were being made by the travel agent, and Jerry Judge was liaisoning with them to make the flight arrangements, which, I believe, was going mid to late morning. So I think we had to leave the house around 7 or 8:00 a.m. that morning, Monday the 9th.

385 6:40:42

MR. MONIZ: And did you travel to the airport with Ms. Heard?

386 6:40:46

BEN KING: Yes. With-yes, we were driven.

387 6:40:48

MR. MONIZ: How would you describe her demeanor that morning?

388 6:40:53

BEN KING: Calmed down a fair bit. She was mostly on the phone, to be honest, for pretty much the whole of that car journey, to various people, one of which, I believe, was Mr. Depp.

389 6:41:09

MR. MONIZ: Do you recall her saying anything on the ride to the airport about what had happened the night prior?

390 6:41:14

BEN KING: Nothing really mentioned in that - as way of an explanation, no.

391 6:41:22

MR. MONIZ: What happened when you got to the airport, if anything?

392 6:41:25

BEN KING: We were running a bit late, I remember that. Luckily, we were traveling first class so the driver knew to pull up to kind of VIP, for want of a better word, VIP checking point, and, so, the car got pretty close to where the desk was. Ms. Heard was still on the phone and so we was. Ms. Heard was still on the phone and so we sat there for a bit with the driver, and Ms. Heard was talking. I don't know who to, at that point. And I was thinking, oh, we need to make this flight, actually, pretty soon because we were already running a bit late.

393 6:42:05

BEN KING: So I decided to go in, maybe I could go in, check in our bags ahead, and then come back and get Ms. Heard and she should be finished by then. Which is what I did.

394 6:42:18

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And did you eventually get on the plane?

395 6:42:21

BEN KING: Eventually, we did. It was a close call, to be honest.

396 6:42:28

MR. MONIZ: Once you were on the plane, did you have any conversations with Ms. Heard?

397 6:42:35

BEN KING: Yes. I mean, not initially, which took some time in the bathroom. She was on the phone, again, to the point where the cabin crew had to sort of tap on the door and say we need to leave now. Everybody needs to sit down. And she did come to sit down, you know, after 10 or 15 minutes in there. And so, eventually, and luckily, as I said, we were flying first class, which is lovely. She was in the window seat, like, I think, 1A, 1B, window seat. I had aisle seat. And finally, we could both sit down and in way of conversation, it wasn't a great deal, to be honest. I did sort of say, finally, so what happened? And, obviously, referring to the house. And I mean, she didn't give much explanation, if any. She did say, Ben, have you ever been so angry with someone that you just lost it with them? And I sort of said, no, actually. I'm a pretty calm, you know, even-tempered guy. But she did repeat it.

398 6:43:47

BEN KING: She looked pretty incredulous that I hadn't. She repeated it. You mean you've never lost it where somebody-- got so angry with someone that you just lost it with them? I said, not unless you count the time when I was 14 years old and I hit the light switch in my bedroom because I wasn't allowed out that night or something. With a person, no, never. And that was pretty much the end of the conversation. She dropped it then.

399 6:44:17

MR. MONIZ: How would you describe her tone when she asked those questions of you?

400 6:44:21

BEN KING: To me? Incredulous, be fair to say. Surprised that I hadn't lost it with somebody.

401 6:44:34

MR. MONIZ: Does anything else stand out about that flight?

402 6:44:38

BEN KING: It was fairly calm. After that, it was calm. I mean, we were both exhausted. I certainly was, and I think - I can't remember eating either. Just slept most of the flight until, obviously, we landed or close to landing.

403 6:44:58

MR. MONIZ: At any point, did you observe anything about Ms. Heard physically on that flight?

404 6:45:04

BEN KING: Yes, I did. Right. Just before we landed, I noticed some marks on her arm, her left forearm.

405 6:45:13

MR. MONIZ: How would you describe those? , !

406 6:45:19

BEN KING: Long, kind of uniform, evenly spaced, sort of long, thin, marks. Very uniform, in fact.

407 6:45:31

MR. MONIZ: And when did you first notice those?

408 6:45:33

BEN KING: On the plane towards coming into s landing. They were gathering the stuff up. I noticed them then.

409 6:45:41

MR. MONIZ: Okay. What did you do after you landed in Los Angeles?

410 6:45:45

BEN KING: Once I fired up my phone on landing, I saw the arrangements that we would be picked up by one of Mr. Depp's security personnel, who I think was Travis McGivern -- McGovern -- McGivern. So I made contact with him and he met us in the place that had been arranged. We walked through the, you know, the arrivals lounge and met him at the end of that. Got in the car with him and drove to the Eastern Columbia Building.

411 6:46:22

MR. MONIZ: And how did Ms. Heard -- how would you describe Ms. Beard's demeanor in Los Angeles?

412 6:46:29

BEN KING: Yeah, very calm. I mean, she seemed -- I mean, obviously, a lot calmer from the house, but she was pleasant towards Travis, certainly, in the car. Obviously, they knew each other. She was -- when we got to the building, she was kind enough to show me around the apartment. I'd never been before. She showed me around the penthouse, a little tour. She wrote down some restaurant recommendations because she knew I'd be staying a recommendations because she knew I d be staying a few days probably. And I didn't really know LA that well. So she recommended a few restaurants. And then I left, I said, if you need anything, as usual, as I always did, if you need anything, give me a shout. I'll be staying fairly close by. Just give me a call or a text.

413 6:47:24

MR. MONIZ: How long were you in LA?

414 6:47:27

BEN KING: Less than a week. I think I flew back to Australia on the 14th or 15th. So about five days, six days tops.

415 6:47:38

MR. MONIZ: And when you got back to Australia, what were you doing?

416 6:47:43

BEN KING: Pretty much putting the house back together and repairing all the damage with the help of professional contractors, vendors I brought in, and just getting the house back as it was originally.

417 6:48:02

MR. MONIZ: At some point, did Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard return to Australia?

418 6:48:06

BEN KING: Yes, they did.

419 6:48:07

MR. MONIZ: Were you there when they returned?

420 6:48:10

BEN KING: Yes. April 25, 2022

421 6:48:12

MR. MONIZ: Did you observe them interacting with each other after they came back to Australia? ,3

422 6:48:15

BEN KING: Yes, yep.

423 6:48:18

MR. MONIZ: And how would you describe their interactions?

424 6:48:21

BEN KING: Again, initially, the first few days was certainly very pleasant, almost honeymoon like, I would say. They strolled around the grounds a bit and they seemed fine with each other.

425 6:48:35

MR. MONIZ: Did you ever observe any arguments after they returned?

426 6:48:38

BEN KING: Yes. I mean, many. Several more. Yeah.

427 6:48:43

MR. MONIZ: And how would you describe those?

428 6:48:47

BEN KING: Not dissimilar to the London arguments, in terms of the pattern of things. You know, the sort of provocation and the reaction to leave the room, Mr. Depp leaving the room, going to another room, playing his guitar. Seemed to follow the same pattern as that -- as I witnessed those two times in London.

429 6:49:10

MR. MONIZ: All right.

430 6:49:11

MR. MONIZ: Nothing further.

431 6:49:13

THE COURT: All right. Cross-examination.

432

[SECTION HEADER]: EXAMINATION BY COUNSEL FOR THE DEFENDANT AND BY MR. NADELHAFT:

433 6:49:20

MR. NADELHAFT: Good afternoon.

434 6:49:21

BEN KING: Good afternoon.

435 6:49:24

MR. NADELHAFT: So, to understand your testimony, is it your testimony that Amber and Mr. Depp arrived together in Australia in February of 2015?

436 6:49:32

BEN KING: Initially, together, I don't think so. I think Mr. Depp arrived ahead of Ms. Heard, actually.

437 6:49:38

MR. NADELHAFT: Mr. Depp arrived first, correct?

438 6:49:39

BEN KING: I think so, yes.

439 6:49:41

MR. NADELHAFT: Isn't it true that Ms. Heard, Amber didn't arrive until March 5th, 2015, to Australia?

440 6:49:45

BEN KING: I can't remember the date she arrived, I to be honest.

441 6:49:48

MR. NADELHAFT: But she could have arrived March 5th, 2015; isn't that true?

442 6:49:52

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Foundation. Speculation.

443 6:49:52

THE COURT: I'll allow it.

444 6:49:54

THE COURT: You can answer it.

445 6:49:56

BEN KING: Sorry, what was the question?

446 6:49:58

MR. NADELHAFT: Ms. Heard could have arrived on March 5th, 2015, correct?

447 6:50:02

BEN KING: It's possible, I suppose.

448 6:50:04

MR. NADELHAFT: And isn't it hue, then, that you didn't see any arguments between Ms. Heard and Mr. Depp before the injury that occurred to Mr. Depp's finger, in Australia?

449 6:50:13

BEN KING: I saw them argue.

450 6:50:14

MR. NADELHAFT: You saw them argue when they came back. When they came back in April, correct?

451 6:50:20

BEN KING: I saw them argue in April and through most of the months they were there, yes.

452 6:50:25

MR. NADELHAFT: But you can't recall any arguments in February or March of 2015 between Ms. Heard and Mr. Depp, correct?

453 6:50:31

BEN KING: Specific days, not necessarily, no.

454 6:50:33

BEN KING: Specific days, not necessarily, no.

455 6:50:34

MR. NADELHAFT: All right. So you don't know, you can't say that there were any arguments before you came to the house on March 8th, 2015, correct?

456 6:50:40

BEN KING: I think there were. I mean ...

457 6:50:43

MR. NADELHAFT: Excuse me? Say that again.

458 6:50:44

BEN KING: I think there were.

459 6:50:46

MR. NADELHAFT: But you don't even know when she arrived, correct?

460 6:50:49

BEN KING: Specifically, the day? Not necessarily, no.

461 6:50:54

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you said when you arrived at the house on March 8th, when you eventually found the finger, it was wrapped in paper; is that right?

462 6:51:04

BEN KING: Wrapped. I mean, it was loosely wrapped. The paper was open by that point, the blood had dried up and it was sitting in this sort of nest of this paper.

463 6:51:11

MR. NADELHAFT: So like someone had put their finger in a piece of paper?

464 6:51:14

BEN KING: I don't know. I mean, it was in that piece of paper. It was in a piece of paper. But,

465 6:51:19

MR. NADELHAFT: Again, like someone had wrapped it up; is that right?

466 6:51:22

BEN KING: I don't know. It was within that scrunched up piece of paper. Kitchen paper, tissue.

467 6:51:28

MR. NADELHAFT: It was in kitchen paper; is that right?s

468 6:51:30

BEN KING: Tissue paper. It was white with a lot of blood on it.

469 6:51:33

MR. NADELHAFT: So, like a paper towel?

470 6:51:34

BEN KING: Like a piece of kitchen towel.

471 6:51:40

MR. NADELHAFT: When you say "kitchen towel," even though we both speak English, I may say it a little different. Like a paper towel?

472 6:51:45

BEN KING: Like kitchen, paper, towel, like a tissue.

473 6:51:49

MR. NADELHAFT: Was that sort of paper towel in the I kitchen at the house at the time?

474 6:51:53

BEN KING: Yes, in both areas of the kitchen and the bar.

475 6:52:00

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. You said you were in Australia starting in February of 2015, correct?

476 6:52:09

BEN KING: Correct. I arrived on the 4th of February.

477 6:52:11

MR. NADELHAFT: And Mr. Depp arrived sometime after that; is that right?

478 6:52:15

BEN KING: Correct.

479 6:52:16

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you see Marilyn Manson while you were there?

480 6:52:19

BEN KING: No, I didn't.

481 6:52:20

MR. NADELHAFT: You don't know if Mr. Depp was with Marilyn Manson in late February, early March, 2015?

482 6:52:23

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Foundation. Speculation. Relevance.

483 6:52:27

MR. NADELHAFT: I'I'm just asking if he saw him. He said he saw him every day, so I was asking if he saw --

484 6:52:32

THE COURT: I'll allow the question. If you can answer it, that's fine.

485 6:52:36

BEN KING: Marilyn Manson didn't come to the house. I didn't see him at any point.

486 6:52:41

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know if Mr. Depp left to be with ! Marilyn Manson?

487 6:52:44

BEN KING: I don't know. I didn't always know where he was going when he went out. It was either to work or security would go with him I wouldn't generally go. In fact, I don't think I went out with him at all in Australia.

488 6:52:56

MR. NADELHAFT: You didn't go out with Mr. Depp at all when he was in Australia, correct?

489 6:52:58

BEN KING: I don't recall it. I saw him on set once or twice, yeah.

490 6:53:03

MR. NADELHAFT: So, you don't know what Mr. Depp was doing in Australia unless you saw him on set or at the house; is that right?

491 6:53:10

BEN KING: I saw him at the house, yes, every day.

492 6:53:12

MR. NADELHAFT: But you don't know what Mr. Depp was doing when he left the house, correct?

493 6:53:15

BEN KING: Generally, going to work on Pirates of the Caribbean 5, yes.

494 6:53:20

MR. NADELHAFT: Were you with him?

495 6:53:21

BEN KING: No, the security was with him I had to liaison with them for when he would go, when he would come back for the driver, et cetera.

496 6:53:26

MR. NADELHAFT: But you weren't there when Mr. Depp But you weren t there when Mr. Depp left the house, correct?

497 6:53:30

BEN KING: Generally, I didn't go, didn't leave the house with Mr. Depp on those days, no.

498 6:53:35

MR. NADELHAFT: And I just want to make sure -- want to be clear, there were two kind of periods that Mr. Depp was in Australia in 2015, right?

499 6:53:43

BEN KING: Sorry. Say again.

500 6:53:43

MR. NADELHAFT: Mr. Depp was in Australia from sometime in February 2015 until about March 8th, March 9th, when he injured his finger; is that right?

501 6:53:53

BEN KING: Correct, yeah.

502 6:53:54

MR. NADELHAFT: And then Mr. Depp left Australia too, correct?

503 6:53:58

BEN KING: At some point, he flew to LA, yes.

504 6:54:02

MR. NADELHAFT: And Mr. Depp returned to Australia on April 21st, right, 2015?

505 6:54:06

BEN KING: Again, that sounds about that time. I don't know the specific date. I don't recall.

506 6:54:10

MR. NADELHAFT: And the filming of Pirates of the Caribbean 5 continued filming on April 21st, correct?

507 6:54:15

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Foundation. Speculation.

508 6:54:16

BEN KING: I didn't-

509 6:54:18

THE COURT: Sir, there's an objection.

510 6:54:20

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you recall testifying to that in the U.K.?

511 6:54:22

THE COURT: I'll overrule the objection. You can answer it.

512 6:54:24

BEN KING: What, sir?

513 6:54:26

MR. NADELHAFT: That the filming of Pirates of the Caribbean 5 continued filming on April 21st, 2015.

514 6:54:32

BEN KING: I wasn't involved in the filming schedule. I don't know when it resumed, to be honest. I knew Mr. Depp came back to resume filming for sure.

515 6:54:42

MR. NADELHAFT: You didn't live with Mr. Depp in his house in Australia, correct?

516 6:54:46

BEN KING: Live with? No, I wasn't a resident 1119 there. e 20

517 6:54:55

MR. NADELHAFT: Now, when you arrived at the house, you saw a significant amount of damage, correct?

518 6:55:01

BEN KING: Yes. The course of -yeah, after I Yes. The course of yeah, after I arrived, yes.

519 6:55:06

MR. NADELHAFT: And the scene was chaos, correct?

520 6:55:10

BEN KING: Chaos? I mean, there was a fair amount of damage.

521 6:55:13

MR. NADELHAFT: The house was wrecked?

522 6:55:16

BEN KING: There was a lot of damage in the house, yes.

523 6:55:17

MR. NADELHAFT: And the house was not in a good state, correct?

524 6:55:20

MR. MONIZ: Asked and answered.

525 6:55:23

THE COURT: He's got to object first I and then -- you can have your objection, Mr. Moniz. Then it helps.

526 6:55:25

MR. MONIZ: Objection.

527 6:55:28

THE COURT: Okay. I'll overrule the objection. Go ahead. Next question.

528 6:55:34

MR. NADELHAFT: And you said there was glass on the floor, correct?

529 6:55:37

BEN KING: In a few areas, mainly, predominantly in the bar, yeah, down in the lower ground floor, correct.

530 6:55:42

MR. NADELHAFT: And there was blood on the walls, correct?

531 6:55:45

BEN KING: In various places, there was blood on the floor, blood on the walls.

532 6:55:48

MR. NADELHAFT: And there was blood on the walls throughout the three stories of the house; isn't that right?

533 6:55:54

BEN KING: No. I wouldn't say that was the extent of it. There was smears up the staircase going up to the master from the main level. There was smears and drips on the carpet.

534 6:56:02

MR. NADELHAFT: So there were smears from the master level up to the bedroom area -- I mean, from the main level up to the bedroom area; is that right?

535 6:56:10

BEN KING: Up to the third floor, yes.

536 6:56:11

MR. NADELHAFT: Like someone had walked from the main floor up to the bedroom floor, correct?

537 6:56:16

BEN KING: There was blood going up the stairs, up the steps, on the staircase, and some on the wall, you know, smears, where he might have done that, yeah.

538 6:56:24

MR. NADELHAFT: As if someone was walking from the main level up to the master bedroom, correct? what the blood was like?

539 6:56:32

BEN KING: Yeah, maybe. I don't know.

540 6:56:34
541 6:56:35

BEN KING: Or down. Is that

542 6:56:38

MR. NADELHAFT: Up or down. From the main level to the third floor, correct?

543 6:56:41

BEN KING: Correct, yes.

544 6:56:44

MR. NADELHAFT: And you said the sofas were damaged; is that right?

545 6:56:47

BEN KING: One sofa in that sitting room, which was just off the kitchen, it was quite an open plan thing, so you have that. There was a sofa with a large TV on a - a wall-mounted TV in front of that sofa.

546 6:56:58

MR. NADELHAFT: And the sofa was on the main !eve correct?

547 6:57:02

BEN KING: By the main kitchen, correct.

548 6:57:03

MR. NADELHAFT: Where the sofa was damaged, that was with what?

549 6:57:06

BEN KING: Blood.

550 6:57:08

MR. NADELHAFT: And lights were damaged?

551 6:57:10

BEN KING: Some lamps, a couple of lamps, yes.

552 6:57:14

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And there were bottles of alcohol in and out of the fridge, correct?

553 6:57:19

BEN KING: Sorry, what do you mean?

554 6:57:20

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you see bottles of alcohol in and out of the fridge?

555 6:57:25

BEN KING: Yes. I mean, I don't completely understand what you mean.

556 6:57:30

MR. NADELHAFT: You saw that, correct?

557 6:57:34

BEN KING: There were alcohol bottles, yes. In the fridge, I mean, there may have been a bottle of wine. I don't know.

558 6:57:40

MR. NADELHAFT: And the floors were ruined, correct?

559 6:57:43

BEN KING: Ruined? I mean, there was a lot of damage on the floor down in the bar area, and the staircase and on the main floor area, the wooden parquet floor, correct.

560 6:57:54

MR. NADELHAFT: And the floors were going to have to be sanded, correct?

561 6:57:57

BEN KING: I eventually got them sanded, yes.

562 6:58:00

MR. NADELHAFT: And it took -- you were there, I think you testified it took you about 12 to 13 hours in the house cleaning up, correct?

563 6:58:08

BEN KING: Correct.

564 6:58:09

MR. NADELHAFT: And you said that there was -- is it your testimony that you didn't see any of the paintings damaged?

565 6:58:15

BEN KING: The existing paintings from the owners ! from the house, no. None of them were damaged.

566 6:58:20

MR. NADELHAFT: You didn't see any paintings with a painting of a penis drawn on it?

567 6:58:24

BEN KING: I did not. And thankfully that was something I didn't have to replace or anything else.

568 6:58:29

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know if anyone else saw that?

569 6:58:31

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Speculation. ;15

570 6:58:32

BEN KING: I mean, I would have seen it. 1 16

571 6:58:34

THE COURT: Wait, there's an objection. -17 Just stop.

572 6:58:36

BEN KING: I'm sorry.

573 6:58:38

THE COURT: If you stand, we can see you better when you do that.

574 6:58:40

MR. MONIZ: Understood.

575 6:58:42

THE COURT: I'll sustain the objection. Next question.

576 6:58:44
577 6:58:45

MR. NADELHAFT: You said that Jerry Judge was at the house, correct?

578 6:58:47

BEN KING: Correct.

579 6:58:48

MR. NADELHAFT: And he's the head of Mr. Depp's security?

580 6:58:51

BEN KING: Correct.

581 6:58:52

MR. NADELHAFT: And Dr. Kipper was at the house?

582 6:58:54

BEN KING: Yes, he was.

583 6:58:54

MR. NADELHAFT: And Debbie Lloyd was at the house as well, correct?

584 6:58:56

BEN KING: Yes, she was.

585 6:58:58

MR. NADELHAFT: Now, you understood that Mr. Judge saw scratches on Ms. Heard on March 8th, correct?

586 6:59:03

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Hearsay. Speculation. Foundation.

587 6:59:08

THE COURT: I'll sustain the objection.

588 6:59:09

THE COURT: Next question.

589 6:59:11

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you have -- the cleaning lady was going to be coming to the house, correct?

590 6:59:15

BEN KING: The housekeeper?

591 6:59:15

MR. NADELHAFT: Yes, the housekeeper.

592 6:59:17

BEN KING: The resident housekeeper, yes, she was going to be. I mean, yes, she was employed through the week. Again, she wasn't there on weekends.

593 6:59:26

MR. NADELHAFT: There was concern about the cleaning lady coming to the house and seeing everything that was in the house, correct?

594 6:59:31

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Speculation. Foundation. Vague.

595 6:59:33

THE COURT: I'll allow it. He can answer it.

596 6:59:34

THE COURT: You can answer it, sir.

597 6:59:37

BEN KING: Thank you.

598 6:59:40

BEN KING: Sorry.

599 6:59:41

MR. NADELHAFT: There was concern about the cleaning lady coming to the house and seeing all the damage that had been done, correct?

600 6:59:46

BEN KING: I know that when I left to fly to LA with Ms. Heard, I told both the chef and the housekeeper they didn't need to be coming to the house because Ms. Heard, essentially, the principals weren't there, Mr. Depp wasn't there, Ms. Heard was obviously with me at that point, so I said they didn't need to come to the house.

601 7:00:05

MR. NADELHAFT: Isn't it true that you told Mr. Judge that you thought you could get the cleaning lady to swear to silence about what the house looks like?

602 7:00:09

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Hearsay.

603 7:00:13

MR. NADELHAFT: His own statement.

604 7:00:14

THE COURT: His own statement. I'll i allow it.

605 7:00:17

MR. NADELHAFT: Isn't it true that you told Mr. Judge that you thought you could get the cleaning lady I to swear to silence about what the house looked !is like?

606 7:00:25

BEN KING: I think I probably made a comment about, you know, I should just come back and deal with this myself, if that's what you mean, and just kept cleaning up.

607 7:00:36

MR. NADELHAFT: And make sure that she wouldn't say anything, correct?

608 7:00:39

BEN KING: I don't know. We trusted - I trusted Th d I er an t e c e anyway. They were good team members.

609 7:00:47

MR. NADELHAFT: As the house manager, part of your job is to -- you said you work with high profile people, correct? I 6

610 7:00:54

BEN KING: High profile, high net worth, I believe, is what I actually said.

611 7:00:57

MR. NADELHAFT: Would you agree that part of your job I 9 is to keep things discreet for your client?

612 7:01:02

BEN KING: Of course, that's part of my job, ! 11 discretion.

613 7:01:05

MR. NADELHAFT: And Mr. Depp was your client?

614 7:01:08

BEN KING: I worked on an assignment on these occasions, yes. But I was self-employed at the time, yeah.

615 7:01:14

MR. NADELHAFT: But on March 8th, 2015, in Australia, Mr. Depp was your client, correct?

616 7:01:20

BEN KING: Correct, essentially. Yep.

617 7:01:21

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. ;l

618 7:01:23

BEN KING: And Ms. Heard Both of them, the principals.

619 7:01:26

MR. NADELHAFT: Who paid -- and do you know how -- who paid your -- for your services?

620 7:01:31

BEN KING: As I said before, it was paid through Disney, who were making the Pirates of the Caribbean, that production company, which I believe was called Herschel.

621 7:01:35
622 7:01:39

MR. NADELHAFT: Can we put up Defendant's Exhibit 377, which is already in evidence.

623 7:01:53

THE COURT: All right. You can put it on -- that's there.

624 7:02:06

MR. NADELHAFT: Mr. King, do you see Exhibit 377 in front of you?

625 7:02:10

BEN KING: I do, yes.

626 7:02:12

MR. NADELHAFT: And do you recognize this as a lampshade that was in the house in Australia on March 8th, 2015?

627 7:02:19

BEN KING: Yes. It was, I believe, one of the lampshades that was missing from one of the lamps.

628 7:02:23

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you saw -- did you see this painting on the lampshade?

629 7:02:29

BEN KING: I did, yeah. As part of my walk, y p y around.

630 7:02:32

MR. NADELHAFT: And what floor was the lampshade on?

631 7:02:34

BEN KING: This was on - where the art studio was, on that main level.

632 7:02:37

MR. NADELHAFT: So on the main level, okay.

633 7:02:40

BEN KING: Yes. Excuse me.

634 7:02:43

MR. NADELHAFT: And was this -- did you notice it was dark paint that was on the lampshade?

635 7:02:49

BEN KING: Certainly looked like it, yes.

636 7:02:54

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you take this picture?

637 7:02:56

BEN KING: I believe I did. Yeah, without seeing that metadata.

638 7:02:58
639 7:03:00

BEN KING: I believe I did.

640 7:03:02

MR. NADELHAFT: Can we put up Defendant's Exhibit 374, please.

641 7:03:18

MR. NADELHAFT: And you recognize Defendant's Exhibit 374 as a mirror that was in the house in Australia on March 8th, 2015, correct?

642 7:03:27

BEN KING: Yes, I do.

643 7:03:28

MR. NADELHAFT: And this mirror was in the bathroom, correct?

644 7:03:32

BEN KING: Correct. There were two mirrors in the l bathroom, above each sink.

645 7:03:35

MR. NADELHAFT: And this was on the top floor, correct?

646 7:03:37

BEN KING: The master bathroom, essentially.

647 7:03:39

MR. NADELHAFT: The master bathroom, just so I'm clear, was on the top floor, right?

648 7:03:42

BEN KING: Top floor, correct

649 7:03:43

MR. NADELHAFT: And this painting says "Starring Billy Bob"; is that correct, is that what you recall?

650 7:03:50

BEN KING: Yeah, I don't know his writing.

651 7:03:57

MR. NADELHAFT: And was this in -- the writing, was it in paint?

652 7:04:01

BEN KING: I believe it is the same paint, the oil paint that was used on the other mirror that we saw earlier.

653 7:04:08

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And did you take this picture?

654 7:04:11

BEN KING: Again, possible. I haven't seen the metadata, but, yes, probably.

655

MR. NADELHAFT: And let's put back up Defendant's Exhibit 375.

656 7:04:33

MR. NADELHAFT: This writing was also in the master bathroom, correct?

657 7:04:36

BEN KING: Correct, yes.

658 7:04:38

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And can you tell if the black paint was on top of the red or under the red?

659 7:04:45

BEN KING: I didn't really analyze it, to be honest. I just knew I was going to have to clean it up at some point.

660 7:04:49

MR. NADELHAFT: Right. Your whole point was cleaning up the house, correct?

661 7:04:53

BEN KING: Correct.

662 7:04:55

MR. NADELHAFT: And you don't know who wrote what on this, on the mirror, correct?

663 7:04:59

BEN KING: No. I know that one was oil paint and I ! 13 the other red writing was lipstick.

664 7:05:04

MR. NADELHAFT: And lipstick, you're not even sure of that, you just saw it was something sticky; is I that right? AQ I'm pretty sure. Waxy. Waxy?

665 7:05:11

BEN KING: Lipstick-like, same as the oil paint was oil paint-like.

666 7:05:16

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. Did you see paint -- did you see, also, any writing in blood?

667 7:05:24

BEN KING: Writing? No, not necessarily.

668 7:05:26

MR. NADELHAFT: No? Okay.

669 7:05:28

MR. NADELHAFT: Now, did you help -- when Ms. Heard was leaving to go back to LA, you were with her, correct?

670 7:05:39

BEN KING: Correct.

671 7:05:39

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you help her pack?

672 7:05:42

BEN KING: I think I may have done that, at that point. Yeah, I think I did.

673 7:05:45

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you see -- weren't Ms. Beard's clothes ruined?

674 7:05:49

BEN KING: I didn't see any ruined clothes.

675 7:05:50

MR. NADELHAFT: There wasn't paint on her clothes?

676 7:05:53

BEN KING: Not that I could see. Not so much. Yeah, not at that point of packing. I mean ...

677 7:05:59

MR. NADELHAFT: There was paint in the tub, correct?

678 7:06:00

BEN KING: Say it again, sir.

679 7:06:02

MR. NADELHAFT: There was paint in the tub in the bathroom, correct?

680 7:06:04

BEN KING: I don't recall that.

681 7:06:05

MR. NADELHAFT: You don't recall one way or the other?

682 7:06:08

BEN KING: I don't recall it being paint in the

683 7:06:10

MR. NADELHAFT: And it's your testimony there was no paint or blood on Ms. Beard's clothes; is that what you're saying?

684 7:06:13

MR. MONIZ: Asked and answered.

685 7:06:16

BEN KING: It is.

686 7:06:19

THE COURT: I'll allow it.

687 7:06:22

MR. NADELHAFT: Now, you said you were in charge of the cleanup, correct?

688 7:06:25

BEN KING: Yes, it was my responsibility, the house was.

689 7:06:29

MR. NADELHAFT: And you were working with Mr. Judge in cleaning up the house; is that right?

690 7:06:41

BEN KING: The night, the day that I arrived there?

691 7:06:42
692 7:06:42

BEN KING: Mr. Judge did help me at some point, yes, sweeping up glass, et cetera.

693 7:06:49

MR. NADELHAFT: And were there -- was there photos taken of more than the three pictures you've been shown?

694 7:06:56

BEN KING: Photos?

695 7:06:57

MR. NADELHAFT: Photos of the house.

696 7:06:59

BEN KING: By whom?

697 7:07:00

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you take any pictures of the house?

698 7:07:02

MR. NADELHAFT: Yes. And I took a few, yeah. I mean, that - And did you take pictures other than the three that we saw?

699 7:07:08

BEN KING: I think I probably did as I was going around.

700 7:07:10

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know who you gave those pictures to?

701 7:07:14

BEN KING: No.

702 7:07:14

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know what you took the photos with?

703 7:07:18

BEN KING: My phone.

704 7:07:18

MR. NADELHAFT: And who would you have sent those photos to?

705 7:07:21

BEN KING: I didn't send them to anybody at that point.

706 7:07:23

MR. NADELHAFT: You just kept them?

707 7:07:25

BEN KING: Yes.

708 7:07:25

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you show the photos to anyone?

709 7:07:26

BEN KING: No.

710 7:07:28

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you still have the photos?

711 7:07:30

BEN KING: Yes.

712 7:07:31

MR. NADELHAFT: Where are they, on your phone still?

713 7:07:34

BEN KING: They're on one of my devices, yes.

714 7:07:36

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. Did you take a photo of the vodka bottle that you said was broken?

715 7:07:41

BEN KING: Yes.

716 7:07:42

MR. NADELHAFT: And you have that photo?

717 7:07:44

BEN KING: Yes.

718 7:07:44

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you didn't -- you didn't i give that to anybody?

719 7:07:47

BEN KING: There have been a few photos. I can show it to you now, if you want.

720 7:07:51

MR. NADELHAFT: How many photos did you have on your phone?

721 7:07:53

BEN KING: I don't remember the number. Probably more than ten.

722 7:07:58

MR. NADELHAFT: Did anyone ever ask you for the photos?

723 7:08:01

BEN KING: Several of them, yes. I was - yes.

724 7:08:04

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you give them to the people who asked?

725 7:08:07

BEN KING: Some of them, yes.

726 7:08:08

MR. NADELHAFT: Not all of them?

727 7:08:09

BEN KING: I don't recall how many.

728 7:08:11

MR. NADELHAFT: Who asked you for the photos?

729 7:08:14

BEN KING: I was involved in a case in London a couple of years ago.

730 7:08:21

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you give the photo of the vodka bottle to the people that you were involved in the case in London?

731 7:08:26

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Relevance, Your Honor.

732 7:08:28

THE COURT: Overruled. I'll allow it.

733 7:08:30

BEN KING: Say it again, sorry.

734 7:08:31

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you give a photo of the vodka bottle to the people you were working with in London?

735 7:08:34

BEN KING: I don't recall what photos I sent, gave them

736 7:08:44

MR. NADELHAFT: So did you take photos of the walls?

737 7:08:51

BEN KING: The walls, certainly the smears of the blood and the damage, the plaster damage, yes.

738 7:08:57

MR. NADELHAFT: So you took photos of the walls with y p - ---------- ---24_6_0 blood on it; is that right?

739 7:09:02

BEN KING: Yes.

740 7:09:03

MR. NADELHAFT: And you took photos of the plaster, right, that was damaged?

741 7:09:07

BEN KING: At the end of the bar, in the bar, behind the bar, by the sink, yeah.

742 7:09:12

MR. NADELHAFT: And did you take photos of the ping-pong table that you said was broken?

743 7:09:17

BEN KING: Yes, as part of the bar area, I'm sure.

744 7:09:20

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you take photos of -- there was a glass table that was broken too, correct?

745 7:09:24

BEN KING: Glass table? I don't recall a glass table.

746 7:09:27

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. Did you take photos of all the damage that was around the house?

747 7:09:31

BEN KING: Probably most of it, yeah.

748 7:09:34

MR. NADELHAFT: And the only time you gave those photos to anyone, you're saying, was in the U.K. case a couple years back?

749 7:09:40

BEN KING: I've never shared them with anybody else, yes.

750 7:09:48

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And it costs between -- it cost about $75,000 to clean up the damage; isn't that right?

751 7:09:56

BEN KING: The exact cost, I think, what I calculated at the time, you know, after all the vendors been and done there, I think it was about 50,000, I seem to recall.

752 7:10:15

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. Now, you said you flew back to I Australia with Ms. Heard, correct?

753 7:10:21

BEN KING: I didn't fly back with Ms. Heard.'

754 7:10:22

MR. NADELHAFT: You flew back to LA from Australia, thank you, with Ms. Heard, correct?

755 7:10:25

BEN KING: Correct. p3

756 7:10:27

MR. NADELHAFT: And you were asleep for most of the flight, correct?

757 7:10:30

BEN KING: Lot of it. I think it was a 14-hour flight, so I think we both slept for quite a lot I of it.is

758 7:10:36

MR. NADELHAFT: You were exhausted from the 13 hours you were working on the house, right?

759 7:10:39

BEN KING: Correct.

760 7:10:40

MR. NADELHAFT: And your testimony was that Ms. Heard said to you, have you ever been so angry with someone that you just lost it, correct?

761 7:10:46

BEN KING: After I asked sort of what happened.

762 7:10:48

MR. NADELHAFT: But you didn't inquire as to what she was referring to, right?

763 7:10:54

BEN KING: I mean, by what happened, it was pretty clear what I was referring to.

764 7:10:59

MR. NADELHAFT: Let me ask you again. You did not inquire as to what she was referring to, did you?

765 7:11:04

BEN KING: With her answer?

766 7:11:06

MR. NADELHAFT: Correct.

767 7:11:07

BEN KING: She didn't inquire as to my reason for asking, but it was pretty obvious, to both of us, what I was asking and what her reply was regarding.is

768 7:11:41

THE COURT: Yes, that's fine, sir. Thank you.

769 7:11:50

BEN KING: Thank you.

770 7:11:56

MR. NADELHAFT: Uh-huh.

771 7:12:02

MR. NADELHAFT: Mr. King, you testified on behalf of Mr. Depp in the U.K., correct?

772 7:12:08

BEN KING: Correct.

773 7:12:09

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you provided two witness statements, correct?

774 7:12:13

BEN KING: Correct.

775 7:12:13

MR. NADELHAFT: And then you provided testimony in court, correct?

776 7:12:19

BEN KING: Correct.

777 7:12:20

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And if you take a look at page 1103 of your testimony. Do you see how the pages go in fours?

778 7:12:38

BEN KING: Yeah.

779 7:12:48

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you see it's actually on the --

780 7:12:50

BEN KING: Bottom right

781 7:12:51

MR. NADELHAFT: Bottom right.

782 7:12:51

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you see that?

783 7:12:52

BEN KING: Yeah, got it.

784 7:12:55

MR. NADELHAFT: If you actually look at -- you see, starting at the bottom of 1102, there's -- this was a statement when you said you did not -- you say Ms. Heard asked you, have you ever been so angry with anyone that you lost it? Your answer, that's correct. And you specifically remember that, do you? Yes. You said it never happened to you. That is correct.

785 7:13:18

MR. NADELHAFT: "QUESTION: She did not. I mean, it was -- if it was said, nothing was said about who she was talking about, was it?

786 7:13:25

MR. NADELHAFT: "ANSWER: She was asking me a question. "QUESTION: She was asking you a question?

787 7:13:31

MR. NADELHAFT: "ANSWER: Yes.

788 7:13:31

MR. NADELHAFT: "QUESTION: You did not inquire as to O what she was referring to, did you?

789 7:13:34

MR. NADELHAFT: "I do not recall asking. I know she was asking for a question, and I gave her an answer."

790 7:13:37

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you see?

791 7:13:40

BEN KING: Yes.

792 7:13:42

MR. NADELHAFT: That's the testimony you gave in the U.K. two years ago, correct?

793 7:13:48

BEN KING: Yes.

794 7:13:49

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. So you don't know what -- and you don't know what Ms. Heard was talking about when she made that statement, correct? You don't know if she was inquiring -- that she was making l that statement about Mr. Depp, right?

795 7:14:00

BEN KING: Like I said, I asked the question, what happened, referring to the house. And she gave me that answer. So I think we were both - it was Is pretty clear, to both of us, what we were talking about. I mean, at that point

796 7:14:16

MR. NADELHAFT: And then you went to sleep, and then you had the flight the rest of the time?

797 7:14:18

BEN KING: Sometime after that.

798 7:14:20
799 7:14:22

BEN KING: Uh-huh.

800 7:14:24

MR. NADELHAFT: Now, and you said you saw Ms. Heard with cuts on her ann; is that right, on the flight?

801 7:14:31

BEN KING: That's right. Toward the end of the I flight, yeah.

802 7:14:33

MR. NADELHAFT: All right.

803 7:14:35

MR. NADELHAFT: If we could put up 376G.

804 7:14:49

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you recognize this picture?

805 7:14:55

BEN KING: I've not seen this picture before.

806 7:14:57

MR. NADELHAFT: Were these the cuts? Did you see cuts like this on Ms. Heard?

807 7:15:01

BEN KING: Is that Ms. Heard?

808 7:15:05

MR. NADELHAFT: Why don't we put up 376C.

809 7:15:22

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you recognize the person in that picture?

810 7:15:24

BEN KING: That's Ms. Heard.

811 7:15:25

MR. NADELHAFT: All right. And did you see cuts like that, which are on her left arm?

812 7:15:31

BEN KING: Similar to that. Long, like I described earlier, long, thin, cuts. Pretty I uniform cuts.

813 7:15:38

MR. NADELHAFT: These were the cuts -- it was -- the cuts were like this on her kind of wrist, forearm area; is that right?

814 7:15:44

BEN KING: I don't know what the date of this I photograph is, but they looked pretty uniform, I like they do here, yes.

815 7:15:50
816 7:15:50

MR. NADELHAFT: I would like to enter 376C into evidence.

817 7:15:53

THE COURT: Any objection?

818 7:15:56

MR. MONIZ: No objection.

819 7:15:59

THE COURT: Okay. 376C in evidence.

820 7:16:14

MR. NADELHAFT: And can we put back up 3760.

821 7:16:29

MR. NADELHAFT: Seeing 376C, is this consistent with the scratches -- on 3760, are these consistent with the scratches that you saw on Ms. Heard?

822 7:16:38

BEN KING: I didn't see a date. Is that the same time? Is that the same date? I mean -

823 7:16:43

MR. NADELHAFT: My question is, are the scratches similar to what you saw on Ms. Heard?

824 7:16:46

BEN KING: These are uniform, kind of long, thin scratches, yes.

825 7:16:52

MR. NADELHAFT: I would like to enter 3760 into evidence.

826 7:16:53

THE COURT: Any objection?

827 7:16:54

MR. MONIZ: Foundation. He hasn't authenticated the document through this witness.

828 7:16:59

MR. NADELHAFT: I'm just asking if pictures are consistent.

829 7:17:02

THE COURT: I'll allow it. 3760 into evidence. please?

830 7:17:05

MR. NADELHAFT: And can you publish it,

831 7:17:07

THE COURT: It is.

832 7:17:11

MR. NADELHAFT: Thank you.

833 7:17:26

MR. NADELHAFT: Now, you were in the house, you said, for 12 to 13 hours on March 8th, 2015, correct?

834 7:17:38

BEN KING: Correct. Going into March 9th, 2015.

835 7:17:41

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you spoke to Mr. Judge when you were in the house, correct?

836 7:17:47

BEN KING: Yeah, I had interaction with Judge, yes.

837 7:17:50

MR. NADELHAFT: And you had interaction with Dr. Kipper when you were in the house, correct?

838 7:17:54

BEN KING: Correct.

839 7:17:55

MR. NADELHAFT: And you had interaction with Debbie Lloyd when you were in the house, correct?

840 7:18:00

BEN KING: Yes, briefly.

841 7:18:05

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And isn't it true that in the entire time you were there, you were not informed as to what caused damage to Mr. Depp's hand on -- finger on March 8th?

842 7:18:21

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Hearsay.

843 7:18:22

MR. NADELHAFT: I'm asking what he wasn't told.

844 7:18:24

THE COURT: I'll sustain the objection.

845 7:18:27

THE COURT: Next question.

846 7:18:28

MR. NADELHAFT: You didn't know what could cause damage to Mr. Depp's hand while you were there on March 8th, correct? ,8

847 7:18:29

BEN KING: Dr. Kipper told me he sustained an injury on one of his fingers.

848 7:18:30

MR. NADELHAFT: Your Honor, objection. Hearsay.

849 7:18:31

THE COURT: Well, you asked the question.

850 7:18:32
851 7:18:33

MR. NADELHAFT: You said he sustained an injury to his finger?

852 7:18:34

BEN KING: Yes.

853 7:18:35

MR. NADELHAFT: But you don't know what caused the injury to his finger?

854 7:18:36

BEN KING: One of his fingers.

855 7:18:38

MR. NADELHAFT: But you don't know how his finger was injured, correct?

856 7:18:40

BEN KING: I don't think anybody mentioned it to me at that time.

857 7:18:43

MR. NADELHAFT: Right. No one mentioned it to you at that time, right?

858

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Indiscernible.)

859 7:18:45

MR. MONIZ: Same objection, Your Honor.

860 7:18:46

MR. MONIZ: Hearsay.

861 7:18:48

THE COURT: That's okay. I'll allow the question. Next Question. He answered it.

862 7:18:57

MR. NADELHAFT: You understand there was a phone in the house that was recording during the cleanup, correct?

863 7:19:01

BEN KING: Sorry, I didn't hear all of that.

864 7:19:02

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you come to understand that there ! 16 was a phone in the house that was recording as people were cleaning up?

865 7:19:09

BEN KING: At that time, no.

866 7:19:10

MR. NADELHAFT: But you now know that there was a phone that was recording people as they were cleaning up, correct?

867 7:19:17

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Foundation. Hearsay.

868 7:19:20

MR. NADELHAFT: I'm not asking for a particular statement.

869 7:19:22

THE COURT: That's fine. I'll allow it, if he knows.

870 7:19:26

BEN KING: I believe that came up somewhere later on. At that time, I wasn't aware. I believe I became aware of it later, yes.

871 7:19:36
872 7:19:38

MR. NADELHAFT: I would like to put up Defendant's 378. It's a recording. I want to play a couple oftimes, 12:07 through 13:19.

873 7:19:59

THE COURT: Is that the only segment you wish to have?

874 7:20:03

MR. NADELHAFT: And then I would also use, I would also like to play 19:51 through 1721:38.

875 7:20:09

THE COURT: Is this going to be used again or is this --

876 7:20:13

MR. NADELHAFT: I think it would be A.

877 7:20:15

THE COURT: Okay. 378A. Any objection to 378A?

878

MR. MONIZ: Yes, Your Honor, we do have an objection. I believe this is a recording that has the voices of people other than Ms. Heard and Mr. Depp, and on that basis, it's hearsay.

879 7:20:25

THE COURT: Okay.

880 7:20:25

MR. MONIZ: Unless I'm incorrect about which document we're talking about.

881

MR. NADELHAFT: Can we approach?

882

THE COURT: Sure.

883

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Sidebar.)

884

THE COURT: Transcript.

885

MR. NADELHAFT: Correct but it --

886

THE COURT: The highlighted parts are the ones you want to play?

887

MR. NADELHAFT: Yeah, highlighted parts are the ones I want to play. It's on page 5, 19.

888

THE COURT: Sure.

889

MR. MONIZ: Thank you, Your Honor.

890

THE COURT: Who's talking here?

891

MR. NADELHAFT: This is a statement from Mr. Judge. And is evidence from an agent of Mr. Depp.

892

THE COURT: You would have to lay a foundation and Mr. Judge is no longer with us, so ...

893

MR. NADELHAFT: It's been testified to, 5 20 years, Mr. Judge, I think, actually, Mr. King testified that he was --

894

MR. MONIZ: Your Honor, even if we can Is get around hearsay on this --

895

MR. NADELHAFT: And it's also present impression as well.

896

MR. MONIZ: Your Honor, even if he can get around hearsay on this, there's no foundation for Mr. Judge's knowledge. He's not able to testify. What's the foundation for even hearing his voice?

897

MR. NADELHAFT: I can ask if it's his voice.

898

MR. MONIZ: Regardless, there's no foundation for Mr. Judge's knowledge, and it's still hearsay.

899

MR. NADELHAFT: And then on page 9, there's Mr. King-- I

900

THE COURT: I'm sorry.

901

MR. MONIZ: Can I see your --

902

THE COURT: Page 9.

903

MR. MONIZ: Who is J?

904

THE COURT: That's --

905

MR. MONIZ: Oh, Jerry Judge. I mean, Your Honor, this is all --

906

MR. NADELHAFT: There's a question about what's happening at the time. It's not talking about --

907

THE COURT: I'll sustain the objection. It's not coming in.

908

MR. NADELHAFT: Can I ask -- so you're saying this is all hearsay, I just want to make sure?

909

THE COURT: It's hearsay. Mr. Judge is, obviously, deceased, so we can't lay a foundation.

910

MR. NADELHAFT: It's also a statement that has an interest of a party person.

911

THE COURT: That's Mr. Judge's statement.

912
913
914

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. Your Honor, I do want to -- I don't want to make you upset, but I do want to, for the record, I want to ask about another recording. I understand your ruling is going to be with Mr. Judge.

915

THE COURT: Okay. So I'll sustain the same, for the record. I'll sustain the objection.

916

MR. NADELHAFT: So it's clear, it would be exhibit 380.

917

THE COURT: 380?

918
919

THE COURT: Okay.

920

MR. NADELHAFT: So you're going to sustain that as hearsay; is that right?

921

THE COURT: Any other objection other than foundation?

922

MR. MONIZ: Hearsay, foundation, I think that covers it, Your Honor.

923

THE COURT: Okay. Thank you.

924

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Open court.)

925

[SECTION HEADER]: BY MR. NADELHAFT:

926 7:24:02

MR. NADELHAFT: Excuse me, sorry about that.

927 7:24:04

MR. NADELHAFT: Going back to the photos that you took, for a moment, of that damage in the house.

928 7:24:10

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you recall giving that testimony?

929 7:24:13

BEN KING: Yes.

930 7:24:13

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. Did Mr. Depp ask you for the photos?

931 7:24:17

BEN KING: No.

932 7:24:18

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you give the photos to counsel for Mr. Depp?

933 7:24:22

BEN KING: Some of them, yes. Yeah.

934 7:24:24

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you withhold any photos from Mr. Depp or his counsel?

935 7:24:28

BEN KING: I didn't withhold any photos from anybody. I didn't withhold.

936 7:24:33

MR. NADELHAFT: Did you give all the photos you have on your phone to Mr. Depp and his counsel?

937 7:24:38

BEN KING: Not all the photos on my phone.

938 7:24:40

MR. NADELHAFT: All of the photos of the damage that occurred on March 8th, 2015?

939 7:24:44

BEN KING: Probably not all of them. I don't p i think so, no.

940 7:24:48

MR. NADELHAFT: You didn't give them all to Mr. Depp and his counsel?

941 7:24:50

BEN KING: I don't believe I gave them all the photos.

942 7:24:57

MR. NADELHAFT: Why not?

943 7:24:59

BEN KING: Because there are a decent amount of Is them I mean -

944 7:25:04

MR. NADELHAFT: So you picked and chose what photos you were going to give to Mr. Depp and his counsel?

945 7:25:09

BEN KING: I gave an amount of photos to them.

946 7:25:12

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know how many photos you gave to Mr. Depp and his counsel?

947 7:25:14

BEN KING: I don't know precisely, no.

948 7:25:18

MR. NADELHAFT: Could you give an estimate as to how I many photos you gave?

949 7:25:22

BEN KING: I really can't. You know, an amount, I don't recall how many.

950 7:25:27

MR. NADELHAFT: More than three?

951 7:25:30

BEN KING: Yes.

952 7:25:31

MR. NADELHAFT: More than ten?

953 7:25:33

BEN KING: Possibly more than ten, yeah, maybe.

954 7:25:35

MR. NADELHAFT: Between IO and 20?

955 7:25:38

MR. MONIZ: Objection. Speculation.

956 7:25:41

THE COURT: Overruled. I'll allow it.

957 7:25:43

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know?

958 7:25:46

BEN KING: Sorry.

959 7:25:49

MR. NADELHAFT: She overruled.

960 7:25:51

BEN KING: Oh, okay. Possibly more than ten, yeah.

961 7:25:54

MR. NADELHAFT: But somewhere between 10 and 20; is that right?

962 7:25:56

BEN KING: Possibly. I honestly don't know.

963 7:25:58

MR. NADELHAFT: Could it be more than 20?

964 7:26:00

BEN KING: I don't think so.

965 7:26:02

MR. NADELHAFT: Did Mr. Depp's counsel ask for all the photos?

966 7:26:07

BEN KING: I don't recall.

967 7:26:08

MR. NADELHAFT: You don't recall, one way or the other, what they asked for?

968 7:26:12

BEN KING: I gave them some photos. I don't recall how many or how many were asked for, requested.

969 7:26:18

MR. NADELHAFT: And those were requested in 2020?

970 7:26:24

BEN KING: Correct. Prior to -

971 7:26:26

MR. NADELHAFT: Prior to the U.K. trial?

972 7:26:28

BEN KING: That, yeah.

973 7:26:30

MR. NADELHAFT: Did they ask for them in this case?

974 7:26:33

BEN KING: I believe I supplied some for this case also, yeah.

975 7:26:37

MR. NADELHAFT: You supplied photos for this case to Mr. Depp's counsel?

976 7:26:41

BEN KING: I believe I did.

977 7:26:42

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And was that about the -- between 10 and 20 photos that you're talking about?

978 7:26:46

BEN KING: I don't remember how many for this.

979 7:26:50

MR. NADELHAFT: But it was the same amount of photos that you gave to Mr. Depp's counsel in the U.K.?

980 7:26:56

BEN KING: I don't know if it was the same amount. I don't recall.

981 7:26:59

MR. NADELHAFT: Did Mr. Depp's counsel in this case ask for all the photos you had of the damage of March 8th, 2015?

982 7:27:05

BEN KING: All of the photos? I don't think they requested all of the photos.

983 7:27:10

MR. NADELHAFT: They didn't ask for all the photos you had of that damage?

984 7:27:13

BEN KING: I don't know if they requested them all.

985 7:27:19

MR. NADELHAFT: Was it Mr. Waldman who asked you for the photos?

986 7:27:23

BEN KING: Originally, I don't remember who, called Schillings.

987 7:27:28

MR. NADELHAFT: Did Mr. Waldman ever ask you for the photos?

988 7:27:30

BEN KING: I don't know if he asked me specifically. He was part of that team, I assume, so ...

989 7:27:37

MR. NADELHAFT: And you spoke to Mr. Waldman; is that right?

990 7:27:41

BEN KING: I did a couple of years ago, yeah.

991 7:27:44

MR. NADELHAFT: And he was part of the team that was asking for the evidence you had of what occurred in Australia in 2015; is that right?

992 7:27:50

BEN KING: He was part of that team, as I understood it, yep.

993 7:27:53

MR. NADELHAFT: And as part of that team, he and others I were asking for all the -- were asking for photos I from Australia from March 8th, 2015; is that right?

994 7:28:01

BEN KING: They requested them at some point, some of them

995 7:28:04

MR. NADELHAFT: And you provided -- that's when you provided the 10 to 20 photos; is that right?

996 7:28:06

BEN KING: Number of photos, correct.

997 7:28:09

MR. NADELHAFT: And, then, was there separate counsel O that asked you for the photos in this case?

998 7:28:15

BEN KING: Yes.

999 7:28:15

MR. NADELHAFT: There was?

1000 7:28:15

BEN KING: Yeah. It was essentially the same -

1001 7:28:19

MR. NADELHAFT: Who was it that asked you for photos in ' I this case?

1002 7:28:21

BEN KING: I don't recall a name specifically.

1003 7:28:23

MR. NADELHAFT: Was it a man or a woman?

BEN KING: I - just part of the team I don't

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And when did they make that request?

1006 7:28:36

BEN KING: When? I don't know a date. I don't Is ! know specifically.

1007 7:28:39

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know what year?

1008 7:28:44

BEN KING: This year, last year. I mean, prior to this, obviously.

1009 7:28:46

MR. NADELHAFT: So it could have been in 2022 that they asked you for the photos?

1010 7:28:50

BEN KING: I think it was prior to that. I don't !S recall.

1011 7:28:54

MR. NADELHAFT: So maybe late 2021 or early 2022; is that what you're saying?

1012 7:28:59

BEN KING: I honestly don't recall which part of the year.13

1013 7:29:02

MR. NADELHAFT: But either 2021 or 2022; is that right?

1014 7:29:04

BEN KING: I will imagine that's probably correct.

1015 7:29:07

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you gave them some of the photos you had?

1016 7:29:11

BEN KING: As I just said, yes.

1017 7:29:13

MR. NADELHAFT: But not all of them?

1018 7:29:15

BEN KING: Correct.

1019 7:29:15

MR. NADELHAFT: So do you have more than 10 to 20 photos on your phone, of the damage that occurred in Australia?

1020 7:29:20

BEN KING: Again, I don't recall the amount.

1021 7:29:25

MR. NADELHAFT: But you have a larger amount on your phone than what you provided to Mr. Depp's team?

1022 7:29:28

MR. MONIZ: Objection, Your Honor. Asked and answered. Cumulative.

1023 7:29:30

THE COURT: I'll sustain the objection as asked and answered.

1024 7:29:37

MR. NADELHAFT: Going to London for a couple minutes. You didn't live at the house in London, correct?

1025 7:29:42

BEN KING: I didn't live there, correct.

1026 7:29:44

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know if Ms. Heard had friends over to the house in London?

1027 7:29:48

BEN KING: She did. They came to stay, yes.

1028 7:29:52

MR. NADELHAFT: And they stayed for -- they stayed from September 9th through September 22nd, 2014, correct?

1029 7:29:58

BEN KING: I don't know the duration, but that's possible.

1030 7:30:01

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And they were staying, they were literally staying at the house, correct?

1031 7:30:06

BEN KING: They were accommodated at the house, correct.

1032 7:30:09

MR. NADELHAFT: Right. So you don't know who was drinking the bottles of wine that were brought into the house, correct?

1033 7:30:17

BEN KING: At which point? What do you mean?

1034 7:30:19

MR. NADELHAFT: When Ms. Beard's friends were there, you don't know who was drinking the wine?

1035 7:30:22

BEN KING: They were all enjoying the wine.

1036 7:30:24

MR. NADELHAFT: They were all drinking the wine?

1037 7:30:27

BEN KING: I took care of them, as I would take care of any guests that came into any house.

1038 7:30:31

MR. NADELHAFT: Wasn't it five to seven guests that were at the house with Ms. Heard?

1039 7:30:33

BEN KING: I don't remember the number. Sounds about right.

1040 7:30:36

MR. NADELHAFT: And then at the end of the night, there was one or two bottles of wine finished, right?

1041 7:30:40

BEN KING: When Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard were there on their own, there was certainly that amount, yes.

1042 7:30:44

MR. NADELHAFT: But you don't know how many bottles were there when it was Ms. Heard and her friends, correct?

1043 7:30:49

BEN KING: I would say more.

1044 7:30:53

MR. NADELHAFT: But you don't know one way or the other, right?

1045 7:30:55

BEN KING: I don't recall the count, but certainly more than when there was just two of them in the house because seven extra people or five people.

1046 7:31:03

MR. NADELHAFT: You don't know the count?

1047 7:31:05

BEN KING: Precisely, no, I don't.

1048 7:31:06

MR. NADELHAFT: Do you know how much time Ms. Heard was in London with Mr. Depp not with her friends?

1049 7:31:12

BEN KING: Fair amount of that time.

1050 7:31:13

MR. NADELHAFT: Well, what do --

1051 7:31:13

BEN KING: I don't recall days, no. I don't I recall.

1052 7:31:16

MR. NADELHAFT: So they were there for a month, correct.

1053 7:31:18

BEN KING: Thereabouts, yes.

1054 7:31:20

MR. NADELHAFT: When I say "they," Ms. Heard and Mr. Depp were in London for about a month, right?

1055 7:31:25

BEN KING: Correct. Roundabout a month.

1056 7:31:26

MR. NADELHAFT: Wasn't it true that for about two to twelve three weeks, Ms. Beard's friends were also staying I in London?

1057 7:31:32

BEN KING: I don't think two or three weeks. I don't recall, but I don't think it was that long.

1058 7:31:36

MR. NADELHAFT: You don't know one way or the other, right? I don't think it was that long.

1059 7:31:39

MR. NADELHAFT: You don't have anything to base that on, right, just what your memory is saying?

1060 7:31:45

BEN KING: Correct.

1061 7:31:46

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you don't know what happened in London when you weren't there, correct? • 112

1062 7:31:53

BEN KING: You mean after I had left of an evening?

1063 7:31:56

MR. NADELHAFT: Yeah. Its

1064 7:31:56

BEN KING: Usually the chef was there still when I left each evening, Russell, who would take care of e ! 17 dinner, and he'd leave later that - each night.

1065 7:32:04

MR. NADELHAFT: And then after the chef left, you don't know what happened in the house, right?

1066 7:32:09

BEN KING: I wasn't there.

1067 7:32:10

MR. NADELHAFT: Right. And you don't know, for certain, whether Mr. Depp drank wine or not in London, right?

1068 7:32:15

BEN KING: I don't believe so. There's usually - when it was just the two of them in the house, there was usually only one glass in the morning, either on the kitchen sink or on the bedside stand in the master bedroom

1069 7:32:24

MR. NADELHAFT: But you don't know who drank from that glass when you weren't there, right?

1070 7:32:29

BEN KING: When I wasn't there, correct. But when I left the house, I had already poured Ms. Heard a glass of wine before I left, inherently.

1071 7:32:35

MR. NADELHAFT: But once you left, you don't know whether Mr. Depp drank wine or not, correct?

1072 7:32:39

BEN KING: I wasn't there after I left.

1073 7:32:42

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you don't know what started the fights you talked about in London, correct, other than that one you said you heard about her hand?

1074 7:32:52

BEN KING: The second one that I described, I was in the vicinity. I heard the first comment. That was the start of that argument.

1075 7:32:58

MR. NADELHAFT: And you don't actually know if there y y was an argument before what you heard, right?

1076 7:33:04

BEN KING: Of that evening? I didn't hear another one.

1077 7:33:05
1078 7:33:07

BEN KING: Put it that way. It started in that room, as I described earlier.

1079 7:33:11

MR. NADELHAFT: And you don't know what happened in Australia, also, between March 5th and March 8th, correct?

1080 7:33:16

BEN KING: The 6th. I left Friday the 6th, was when I left for the weekend.

1081 7:33:21

MR. NADELHAFT: To between Friday the 6th and when you got to the house on March 8th, you don't know what happened?

1082 7:33:27

BEN KING: I wasn't there.

1083 7:33:29

MR. NADELHAFT: Okay. And you never saw Ms. Heard be violent at any time, right?

1084 7:33:35

BEN KING: Sorry, say again.

1085 7:33:35

MR. NADELHAFT: You never saw Ms. Heard be violent at any time, correct?

1086 7:33:40

BEN KING: Beyond finger prodding and violent, I didn't see either of them be violent towards each other.

MR. NADELHAFT: You never saw Ms. Heard be violent at any time, right?

BEN KING: I didn't see her be violent, depending ,5 on your-

MR. NADELHAFT: Let me show you your witness statement, where you said you never saw Ms. Heard be violent at any time.

BEN KING: Violence? Yes, I didn't see violence, perse.

MR. NADELHAFT: Thank you I have nothing further.

THE COURT: All right. Redirect.

BEN KING: Thank you.

[SECTION HEADER]: EXAMINATION BY COUNSEL FOR THE PLAINTIFF AND

MR. MONIZ: Mr. King, have you ever been employed

BEN KING: By Mr. Depp?

BEN KING: No.

MR. MONIZ: So, in each of these situations where you've been around Mr. Depp, you've always been employed by somebody else?

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

BEN KING: Correct.

THE COURT: All right. I'll sustain as to leading. Strike the answer. Next question.

MR. MONIZ: Are you based anywhere other than the 110U.K.?

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

MR. MONIZ: Where do you live?

BEN KING: I live in Central London.

MR. MONIZ: Have you ever lived anywhere else?

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

THE COURT: Sustain the objection.

THE COURT: Next question.

MR. MONIZ: Okay.

MR. MONIZ: We heard some discussion on cross about 120 photos, which I suspect you remember.

MR. MONIZ: Why did you take the photos of the property damage in Australia?

BEN KING: As I do a lot of my jobs and various assignments and jobs through the years, I take photos as points of reference and for whatever reason. I mean, if I'm packing suitcases up and they're going to be in transit and I'm not with the suitcases, I'll take a picture of contents and when I send stuff so I know what's going and what's gone. I take pictures as points of reference. I sometimes take pictures of table settings that I've done or, which I knew I could use later on as reference.

MR. MONIZ: Were the photos of property damages in Australia the first photos that you had taken in the course of working with Mr. Depp and Ms. Heard?

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

THE COURT: All right. I'll sustain as to leading.

THE COURT: Next question.

MR. MONIZ: Had you ever taken photos before?

BEN KING: Yes.

MR. MONIZ: What kinds of things had you taken photos of?

BEN KING: In London, reference points and dinner table settings. Sometimes Mr. Depp would write notes for Ms. Heard, leave notes on the sort of kitchen table when he left for work. I believe I took pictures of those. They were, you know, there. Things like that. Just setups of - once I've set up houses, it's always good to take photos of rooms so I can cross-reference later on, if I need to.

MR. MONIZ: Did Ms. Heard or her counsel ever ask you for photos of -- any of the photos you took in Australia?

BEN KING: No.

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

THE COURT: I'll sustain as to leading.

THE COURT: Next question.

MR. MONIZ: Can I see Plaintiff's Exhibit 159. And I think this is a multipage document. Can you scroll through, about three pages here.

MR. MONIZ: Mr. King, do you recognize this document?

BEN KING: Yes. That's the floor plan of the house in Australia.

MR. MONIZ: And do you recall, on

[SECTION HEADER]: Cross-examination, you were asked to kind of

BEN KING: Yes.

MR. MONIZ: So, right now, on the screen in front of you --

BEN KING: Yep.

MR. MONIZ: Which floor would you say this is?

BEN KING: This is the top floor with the master suite and two other bedrooms.

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And I believe counsel asked you if there was blood in one of the bathrooms, or one I of the bathtubs. Do you recall that?

BEN KING: Yes, they did ask that.

MR. MONIZ: Would that have been on this floor?

BEN KING: I think that was referring to the master tub. That's what he said.

MR. MONIZ: Okay. So can you mark on the screen where that would have been?

BEN KING: The master tub? It's over here. Can I just dot it out?

MR. MONIZ: You can just dot it, yes.

BEN KING: Okay. So that looks like the master tub to me.

MR. MONIZ: And just to clarify, did you recall seeing any blood or damage there? ,8

BEN KING: In the tub? No.

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Can you mark for us, on the ! IO screen, where you did see the damage that was I discussed on cross?

BEN KING: The mirrors and- can I dab on here again?

MR. MONIZ: Sure.

BEN KING: So these are the sinks. The two mirrors were above the mirrors - above each sink.

MR. MONIZ: Okay.

MR. MONIZ: Can we scroll up to the page prior.

MR. MONIZ: And can you point out for us, on this page -- well, first of all, which floor is this?

BEN KING: This is the main level floor. Essentially, the second floor, if you want.

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And can you point out for us, here on this map, which of the -- where the property damage was?

BEN KING: Yes. How many dabs am I allowed? Around here, kitchen area. This was the TV, the wall-mounted TV.

BEN KING: Oh, I've run out of dabs.

MR. MONIZ: I apologize. Actually, Your Honor. Can we move this into evidence?

THE COURT: Any objection? jury?

MR. NADELHAFT: No objection.

MR. MONIZ: Can we publish it to the

THE COURT: Okay. So, Mr. King, I apologize for interrupting you. You were just pointing out where on -- I think this is the second floor.

BEN KING: Essentially the main level, yes.

MR. MONIZ: So other than these three dots, do you recall any other places where there was damage?

BEN KING: Yes. Where it says "family," family Yes. Where it says family, family room, there was -- where the TV was wall mounted, on that wall in between family and lounge. The sofa was, approximately, where you've got the red square -- red rectangle now, facing towards the TV. The lounge is -- sorry, too quick. The lounge was, essentially, the art studio, and the bedrooms, over to the left there, where the lamp, damaged lamp and shade, blood on the duvet, et cetera, that I described.

MR. MONIZ: Okay.

MR. MONIZ: And then let's go to the first page.

MR. MONIZ: And which floor is this?

MR. MONIZ: This is the lower ground floor. Okay. And can you point out for us -- did you find the finger on this floor?

BEN KING: Correct.

MR. MONIZ: Can you point out to us where you found the finger?

BEN KING: Yes, I can. Right here. Maybe here. It's the end of the bar. It was on the tiled floor below that end of the bar.

MR. MONIZ: Okay. And any other significant property damage that you want to point out on this, on this floor?

BEN KING: Yes. As I said, this was the - can I dab again? Yeah. So, that was the most part of the broken glass, that's where the Stolichnaya bottle was, below that bar, by the barstools. There were three barstools that you could sit at there. On this back wall here, there was plaster damage on - over here, above the sink, or to the side of the sink, was more plaster damage on the walls behind the bar. That mirror was cracked, broken. Ping-pong table was around there, I collapsed on the floor.

BEN KING: And around those three dots there, I'm going to put another one, that was the spillages, as well, that smelled like alcohol to me, the puddles of alcohol.

MR. MONIZ: Is that it?

BEN KING: I mean that was the most part of the damage around that area in front of the bar especially As I said there were blood drips around that white cream colored tile floor in the around that white cream colored tile floor in the games room And this is the staircase down, is this side that the chip was out of the stone step. And, if I can get another dab in there, right about in the center of that bar, the chunk out of the side of the counter, bar top.

MR. MONIZ: Okay. How many exits are there on the ground floor?

BEN KING: Well, exits, all of these were. And all of these. My office was off over here. I think you can just see it says "study," big, glass, sliding door. The gym had an exit up here (indicating). This went into the garage. There was a button you could press for the automatic doors to come up. The laundry area, which was right here, this is actually an exit out into the yard, essentially. The gym, all of those rooms had an exit.

MR. MONIZ: Okay. Other than Mr. Depp's counsel did anybody else ever ask to see your photos?

MR. NADELHAFT: Objection. Leading.

THE COURT: I'll allow it.

BEN KING: No.

MR. MONIZ: All right. Nothing further, Your Honor.

THE COURT: All right. Is this witness subject to recall?

MS. BREDEHOFT: Your Honor, we have an issue we would like to approach on.

MR. MONIZ: Subject to recall.

THE COURT: All right.

THE COURT: So, since you're subject to recall, it's important that you do not discuss your testimony with anybody and do not pay attention to the triaL and don't watch anything about the triaL okay?

BEN KING: Of course. Thank you.

colloquy Post-Testimony Matters

THE COURT: All right. You can step down, sir.

MS. BREDEHOFT: Your Honor, may we approach?

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Sidebar.)

MS. BREDEHOFT: Your Honor there are two court orders requiring them to produce all the photos and they did not produce those I would like to be able to get the Court to order Mr. King to turn them over

THE COURT: Okay.

MS. BREDEHOFT: If not, we're asking for spoliation instruction. I just want to give the Court that.

MR. MONIZ: First of all, Your Honor, this is obviously not somebody who's employed by Mr. Depp.

THE COURT: Understand. The question is, are those photos in your custody?

MR. MONIZ: They're not in our custody, possession, or control, but we have no objection to him turning --

THE COURT: Well, we'll get them before he leaves. Get everything that's on his phone, and we'll turn it all over.

MR. MONIZ: Those are after the close of discovery, obviously. But, yeah, I mean, if he has photos that he hasn't produced, then, yeah, that's fine.

THE COURT: Sure. Why don't you get them tonight, turn them over tonight to Ms. Bredehoft, so she can have them. And he's subject to recall, so if we need call him back at any time, we can call him back. I'll give you leeway to have questions, obviously, you can waive it today.

MR. MONIZ: And just as a point of clarification, Your Honor, this is not a witness to -- it is a U.K. resident not subject to subpoena.

THE COURT: I know, but he said he handed over 10 to 20 photos. It may be prior counsel, I don't know, but still. This resolves the issue. I think we can take care of it from there, okay?

MR. CHEW: Thank you, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Ladies and gentlemen, that comes to end of our day, so we're going to excuse you for the evening. Again, do not do any outside research and do not talk to anybody, and we'll see you tomorrow morning. Have a great evening. Thank you.

THE COURT: All right. I just have one housekeeping matter. We're going through the exhibits you gave me this morning. Thank you, again, for that. One of them was 485, and I had in my notes that it was 485A, just the first page, but you gave me all eight pages.

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Whereupon, the jury exited the courtroom and the following proceedings took place.)

THE COURT: Have you all agreed that all eight pages of this document come in, or should I give 485 back and you can try again to give it back to me tomorrow?

MR. ROTTENBORN: Sure, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Okay. I'll give that back to you, and we'll see what happens tomorrow. And we're going to start with a remote witness tomorrow; is that going to be your first witness?

MR. CHEW: Yes, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Make sure she's signed on by 9:40 so we can have it all set up for 10:00 start, okay?

MR. CHEW: We will, Your Honor. Thank you, Your Honor.

THE COURT: THE bailiff: All rise.

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Whereupon, the trial was recessed at 5:35 p.m to reconvene at 10:00 a.m, Tuesday, April 26, 2022.)

THE COURT: I, JUDITH E. BELLINGER, RPR, CRR, the court reporter before whom the foregoing hearing was taken, do hereby certify that the foregoing excerpt transcript is a true and correct record of the proceedings; that said proceedings were taken by me steno graphically and thereafter reduced to typewriting under my direction; and that I am neither counsel for, related to, nor employed by any of the parties to this case and have no interest, financial or otherwise, in its outcome.

THE COURT: IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed my notarial seal this 26th day of April, 2022. My Commission Expires: September 30, 2024 ° NOTARY PUBLIC IN AND FOR THE COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA PLANE R i I I Okay. All right. Any objection to 598B then?

[STAGE DIRECTION]: (Whereupon, the following recording was played.)