Skip to content
personpersonPenney AzcaratePenney AzcarateFairfax County Circuit Court judge who presided over the Depp v. Heard civil trial.← All People
JudgeFairfax County Circuit Court

Penney Azcarate

Courtroom still of Penney Azcarate.

Fairfax County Circuit Court judge who presided over the Depp v. Heard civil trial.

8,723 lines·241 proceedings

About

Penney Azcarate presided over the 2022 Depp v. Heard trial, managing witness testimony, evidence, courtroom procedure and the time allotted to each side. She struck Gina Deuters’s testimony after Deuters acknowledged watching trial clips, and she resolved disputes over which exhibits and deposition excerpts the jury could consider.

When Heard moved to strike Depp’s claims at the close of his case, Azcarate denied the motion as to two challenged statements and took the first under advisement. After further evidence, she denied the motion as to the first statement as well, finding a question for the jury rather than deciding it herself. During deliberations, she answered a jury question by clarifying that its falsity inquiry concerned the op-ed headline, not the entire article. She returned an incomplete verdict form for the required damages entries and, after the jury’s verdict, reduced Depp’s punitive damages award from $5 million to Virginia’s $350,000 statutory cap.

Trial Record (241)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022

Fairfax County Circuit Court judge who presided over the Depp v. Heard civil trial.

Day 0

jury selectionJury Selection3highlights776lines spoken

Summary

Jury selection before Judge Azcarate: hardship excusals, individual voir dire on pretrial publicity, and attorney questioning of the 21-person panel.

Highlights (3)

Quote“This tainted my jury. There's going to be repercussions.”— Penney AzcarateJudge signals displeasure with Heard's weekend social media post and foreshadows possible sanctions if jurors saw it.Open in transcript →
Quote“I'm going to reserve the issue.”— Penney AzcarateCourt defers ruling on Chew's sanctions motion rather than instructing the jury mid-selection.Open in transcript →
Quote“The name of this case is John C. Depp I versus Amber Heard.”— Penney AzcarateFormal case introduction to the venire.Open in transcript →

Day 1

colloquyPost-Testimony Exhibit Rulings and Juror Contact Issue2highlights30lines spoken

Summary

Judge rules on admissibility of text message exhibits 163, 210, and 214, then addresses a sidebar report of a juror waving at Johnny Depp.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Since they can't have the context, I'm not going to allow them in, so I'm deny-- I'm going the sustain the objection to 163.”— Penney AzcarateThe court's ruling excluding Exhibit 163, citing the jury's inability to understand the texts without surrounding context.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“just the only part that comes in is as far as Ms. Heard's text is the "JD is on a bender," and I don't even know the last part of it -- that's it.”— Penney AzcarateDefines the narrow slice of Exhibit 210 admitted — limiting Heard's texts to a single impeachment phrase about Depp's alleged substance use.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 2

Day 3

colloquyWitness Struck, Front Row Rule Set After Eve Barlow Incident3highlights65lines spoken

Summary

Judge Azcarate strikes Gina Deuters' testimony after she admits watching trial clips, then bars non-legal-team from front row following Eve Barlow's note-passing.

Highlights (3)

Quote“I will instruct the jury they'll have to strike the testimony of Ms. Deuters. There's a rule on witnesses, Mr. Moniz.”— Penney AzcarateJudge's immediate ruling on the witness sequestration violation, delivered on the record before the sidebar.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“From now, on the front row, it's only legal team, okay? No family on front row for either side. I said only legal team in the front row. There's plenty of seats in the courtroom.”— Penney AzcarateCourt's new standing rule on front-row access, prompted by the Eve Barlow incident.Open in transcript →
Quote“Ladies and gentlemen, the Court is striking Ms. Gina Deuters' testimony, in its entirety, from the record; therefore, the Court further instructs you, the jury, to disregard her testimony in its entirety.”— Penney AzcarateFormal jury instruction striking Deuters' testimony — the operative procedural consequence delivered to the fact-finders.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 4

Day 5

CrossCross-Examination of Keenan WyattKeenan WyattElaine Bredehoft1highlight36lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft challenged Wyatt on Depp's film contracts, Australia production delays, the 2014 Boston flight, and impeached his denial of knowing any prior violence allegations against Depp.

Highlights (1)

Quote“No. Then it can't come in. Just because they didn't object to it doesn't mean it automatically comes in at trial.”— Penney AzcarateThe court's ruling on Exhibit 245 blocks Heard's team from using Depp's own words about substance use to contextualize the Boston flight through this witness.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 6

Day 7

Day 8

CrossCross Examination of Ben KingBen KingAdam Nadelhaft1highlight55lines spoken

Summary

Heard's counsel challenged King on timeline gaps in Australia, his selective sharing of damage photos, and admitted photos of cuts on Heard's arm while two audio recordings were excluded as hearsay.

Highlights (1)

Quote“It's hearsay. Mr. Judge is, obviously, deceased, so we can't lay a foundation.”— Penney AzcarateThe court's stated basis for excluding the cleanup-period audio recordings; Jerry Judge's death foreclosed any foundation for his statements on the recordings, shutting out potentially significant contemporaneous evidence.Open in transcript →

Day 9

colloquyExhibit Rulings Before Officer Saenz Deposition2highlights43lines spoken

Summary

Pre-deposition sidebar resolves exhibit admissibility for Officer Saenz testimony; incident report admitted, injury photos excluded for lack of foundation.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Since you're subject to recall, Dr. Curry, please, do not discuss your testimony with anybody and, please, do not watch anything about this trial, okay?”— Penney AzcarateStandard recall instruction to expert witness, establishing Curry's continued role in the proceedings.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“I understand. But I have to sustain your objection at this time.”— Penney AzcarateCourt rules against admitting the photos through Saenz, while implicitly acknowledging they will likely be admitted through another witness.Open in transcript →

Day 10

Day 11

Day 12

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Marks Expert Scope Ruling2highlights28lines spoken

Summary

Court handles expert attendance, witness address redaction, exhibit housekeeping, and rules on the scope of Richard Marks's op-ed impact testimony.

Highlights (2)

Quote“He can't say that. That's a factual issue, okay?”— Penney AzcarateThe court's definitive ruling that direct causation — why Depp lost Pirates 6 — is reserved for the jury, not expert opinion.Open in transcript →
Quote“But he just can't say that was the reason he lost Pirates.”— Penney AzcarateThe judge restates the ruling's bottom line before dismissing the sidebar, setting the scope boundary for Marks's testimony.Open in transcript →

Day 13

colloquyMotion to Strike Argued; Plaintiff Rests, Defense Begins1highlight80lines spoken

Summary

Plaintiff rests; defense moves to strike all three defamatory statements; judge denies as to statements 2 and 3 and takes statement 1 under advisement.

Highlights (1)

Quote“The weight of that evidence is up to the fact-finders, so the motion to strike is denied as to statement 2 and 3.”— Penney AzcarateFormal ruling allowing two of three defamation claims to proceed to the jury.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 14

Day 15

Day 16

colloquyMotion to Admit Heard's Prior Violence Incidents1highlight58lines spoken

Summary

Judge rules at sidebar on Depp's motion to admit Heard's alleged prior violent conduct toward Tasya van Ree and Rocky Pennington for impeachment.

Highlights (1)

Quote“I'm just not going to allow arrests in. I think it's too prejudicial because it lists an arrest, not conviction, so I'm not letting any arrests come in.”— Penney AzcarateThe judge's definitive ruling on the scope of admissible prior-conduct evidence, drawing the line at arrests versus proven conduct.Open in transcript →

Day 17

colloquyPhoto Metadata Ruling; Deposition De-Designation Dispute1highlight24lines spoken

Summary

Judge sustains objection to Heard's photo metadata exhibits and rules Heard's team may continue de-designating deposition clips under the 61-hour time constraint.

Highlights (1)

Quote“I can't -- I can't require her to use the originals that you based on. Just because you're doing this all by depositions, it's just a very strange case. But it's their case, I allow the de-designations, okay?”— Penney AzcarateThe court's ruling permitting Heard's team to continue de-designating deposition testimony, framing it as counsel's right to manage their own case presentation.Open in transcript →

Day 18

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Pennington Photo Timestamp Ruling2highlights41lines spoken

Summary

Court signed a juror order and ruled on admissibility of photo timestamps for Raquel Pennington's deposition, distinguishing iPhone display data from extracted metadata.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Actually, you keep saying metadata. This actually isn't metadata. This is just from an iPhone, which I can go in and I can change my listings for these on my iPhone, and it will show up as a different date and different location. Metadata is something that is extracted from the phone and is with the file, and it would show that I had changed the location. That's metadata, so ...”— Penney AzcarateJudge draws a technical distinction between changeable iPhone display fields and true extracted metadata, framing the foundational issue for her ruling.Open in transcript →
Quote“when they send judges to computer forensic school down in Alabama, these things happen.”— Penney AzcarateJudge references her forensics training as the basis for her technical position on what constitutes metadata.Open in transcript →

Day 19

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Alpaca Photo, TikTok Incident, Rebuttal Ruling2highlights44lines spoken

Summary

Judge reprimands Chew for violating her photography order near the courthouse, discloses a TikTok balcony incident involving courthouse staff's children, and limits Bercovici to rebuttal.

Highlights (2)

Quote“There will be sanctions if it happens again.”— Penney AzcarateFormal warning placing counsel on notice that further violations will carry consequences.Open in transcript →
Quote“One of the kids posted it on TikTok, I found out this morning. It's been removed from TikTok and nobody can go on that balcony again for the duration of this trial.”— Penney AzcarateJudge discloses a second, independent social media exposure incident and announces her corrective action.Open in transcript →
colloquySidebar: Bercovici Rebuttal-Expert Designation3highlights25lines spoken

Summary

Post-lunch sidebar in which Heard's team argued Bercovici should testify beyond rebutting Frost; Judge Azcarate upheld her prior ruling that he is a rebuttal expert only.

Highlights (3)

Quote“I have to go by designation.”— Penney AzcarateThe court's bottom-line rationale for limiting Bercovici to rebuttal: the designation document is controlling, regardless of subsequent supplementation arguments.Open in transcript →
Quote“Definition of rebuttal expert is that they rebut an expert from the other side, correct?”— Penney AzcarateJudge Azcarate signals she is applying the standard legal definition of rebuttal expert and invites counsel to confirm — forecasting her ruling.Open in transcript →
Quote“It still says rebuttal expert, okay.”— Penney AzcarateFinal statement closing the sidebar argument — the judge's ruling in three words.Open in transcript →
Voir DireVoir Dire Examination of Ron SchnellRon SchnellWayne Dennison1highlight2lines spoken

Summary

Dennison's opening voir dire question about Schnell's tweet analysis is cut off when the court sustains an objection limiting voir dire to qualifications only.

Highlights (1)

Quote“The voir dire is just for his qualifications as an expert.”— Penney AzcarateThe court's ruling narrows the permitted scope of voir dire, preventing Dennison from using it as an early vehicle to attack Schnell's methodology or conclusions.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
colloquyExpert Qualification — Social Media Forensic Analysis3highlights10lines spoken

Summary

At sidebar, Judge Azcarate clarified that voir dire is for expert qualification only; Dennison conceded no objection, and the court admitted Heard's social media expert in open court.

Highlights (3)

Quote“That doesn't have to do with his qualification, whether he's qualified as an expert or not.”— Penney AzcarateThe judge draws a clear line between the purpose of voir dire and the damages-scope dispute Dennison was pursuing.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“That's not what voir dire is for, though.”— Penney AzcarateDirect statement of the procedural rule limiting voir dire to expert qualification, not substantive damages inquiry.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Then I'll move him in as an expert in the statistical and forensic analysis of social media.”— Penney AzcarateFormal admission establishing the expert's recognized field for the jury.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 20

Voir DireVoir Dire Examination of David SpiegelDavid SpiegelWayne Dennison1highlight1line spoken

Summary

Dennison challenges Spiegel's IPV credentials during voir dire, establishing no IPV-titled publications or CV entries; court admits him as expert over objection.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Over objection, he's entered as an expert as stated on the record. All right. You may continue.”— Penney AzcarateCourt's ruling admitting Spiegel over Depp's team's partial objection, allowing Heard's IPV expert testimony to proceed.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 21

colloquyDefense Rests; Motion to Strike Counterclaims Denied2highlights115lines spoken

Summary

Defense rests; judge denies Depp's motion to strike Heard's counterclaims; sidebar resolves disputes over six late-identified rebuttal witnesses before jury enters.

Highlights (2)

Quote“It is not my role to measure the veracity or weight of the evidence. The force record in the Virginia Supreme Court have made it crystal clear that actual malice is a question for the fact-finder; so therefore, the plaintiff's motion to strike is denied.”— Penney AzcarateDefinitive ruling preserving Heard's counterclaims and sending the actual malice question to the jury.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“all of a sudden, I heard Kate -- I thought of Kate Moss on the stairs. That gave a negative connotation, and even to me, I'm like, Oh, does that mean that something happened with Kate Moss on the stairs?”— Penney AzcarateJudge explains on the record why Heard's staircase testimony created an inference entitling Depp to call Kate Moss as a rebuttal witness.Open in transcript →
colloquySidebar — Dr. Kulber Admissibility and Scope2highlights67lines spoken

Summary

Sidebar resolves Dr. Kulber's admissibility as a rebuttal witness; court limits his testimony to the state of Depp's hand after the March 2015 finger surgery.

Highlights (2)

Quote“the only thing they can talk about is the pin -- they did the surgery, pin, and soft cast. That's all I should hear.”— Penney AzcarateThe court's definitive scope limitation on Kulber's testimony, drawing a hard line against any opinion on causation.Open in transcript →
Quote“She was an expert witness. How would she not have anything to rebut? So no. The answer's no.”— Penney AzcarateCourt summarily rejects the defense bid to block Dr. Curry's rebuttal, preserving Depp's ability to counter Dr. Hughes's forensic psychology testimony.Open in transcript →
colloquyRuling: Morgan Night Rebuttal Testimony Allowed2highlights18lines spoken

Summary

The court heard defense objections to Morgan Night as a rebuttal witness and ruled to allow his limited testimony, finding probative value outweighed any prejudice.

Highlights (2)

Quote“That's what rebuttal witnesses are.”— Penney AzcarateThe court dismisses the defense's prejudice argument by noting that surprise is the inherent nature of rebuttal witnesses.Open in transcript →
Quote“the probative value outweighs the prejudice”— Penney AzcarateThe court's stated legal basis for admitting Night's testimony over the defense's late-disclosure objection.Open in transcript →
RedirectRedirect Examination of Richard ShawRichard ShawStephanie Calnan1highlight2lines spoken

Summary

Calnan's redirect of psychiatrist Richard Shaw lasted moments: one confirmatory question, a single affirmative answer, and "nothing further."

Highlights (1)

Quote“Allright. Thank you, sir. You can either have a seat or you can leave. Thank you. Your next witness.”— Penney AzcarateFormal dismissal of Shaw, closing his testimony and transitioning to the next witness.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
colloquyDefense Evidence Proffers for the Record2highlights22lines spoken

Summary

Defense counsel Nadelhaft proffers excluded testimony and exhibits from nine witnesses and the UK judgment for the appellate record, with distinct grounds including hearsay, improper expert opinion, speculation, and the finding that the door to the U.K. judgment had not been opened.

Highlights (2)

Quote“You just scared me with the size of that.”— Penney AzcarateJudge's aside on the length of the Bercovici written brief, after Nadelhaft offered to submit it rather than read it aloud.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“by the end of the day tomorrow, if I could get clean jury instructions without the cites on them, for the ones that have been admitted”— Penney AzcarateCourt's directive to both sides to produce finalized jury instructions, signaling the case is approaching closing arguments.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 22

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Rebuttal Witness Rulings3highlights80lines spoken

Summary

Sidebar rulings admit Beverly Leonard for limited impeachment, restrict Kate Moss to staircase testimony, and exclude Dr. Collins and Bryan Neumeister as rebuttal experts.

Highlights (3)

Quote“I don't find that it's a collateral matter in this matter because Ms. Heard testified that she always does self-defense, she only hits in self-defense”— Penney AzcarateThe judge's rationale for admitting Leonard: Heard's own pattern-of-self-defense testimony made a prior non-self-defense assault directly relevant, not collateral.Open in transcript →
Quote“I'm going to limit it just to the stairs, okay?”— Penney AzcarateThe operative ruling on Kate Moss's scope — her testimony confined to whether Depp harmed her on the stairs, mirroring the precise doorway Heard opened.Open in transcript →
Quote“An expert in rebuttal can only rebut experts.”— Penney AzcarateThe controlling principle applied to exclude both Collins and Neumeister, as Heard's defense presented no expert witnesses for either to rebut.Open in transcript →
colloquyRebuttal Expert Exclusion; Depp Returns to Testify3highlights66lines spoken

Summary

Post-recess sidebar excludes Dr. Collins as rebuttal expert; Neumeister ruling deferred to noon; defense discloses Hughes and Heard as rebuttal witnesses; Depp recalled.

Highlights (3)

Quote“Reversible error is what I'm trying to avoid in this case.”— Penney AzcarateRepeated rationale for the court's strict adherence to expert designation rules throughout this sidebar.Open in transcript →
Quote“All the case law I've ever read says you can't use an expert to rebut lay witness testimony.”— Penney AzcarateThe court's core holding on rebuttal expert limitations, applied to exclude both Collins and (pending case law) Neumeister.Open in transcript →
Quote“That's what rebuttal experts are. In Virginia.”— Penney AzcarateDirect statement of Virginia's rule limiting rebuttal experts to rebutting opposing expert testimony only.Open in transcript →
colloquyNeumeister Scope Ruling; TMZ Intervention Denied3highlights108lines spoken

Summary

The court limited Neumeister's rebuttal testimony to photographs in evidence and their EXIF metadata, denied use of the UK trial judgment, and rejected TMZ's intervention motion.

Highlights (3)

Quote“it's going to be extremely limited, as far as only photographs that are in evidence that he can opine on”— Penney AzcarateDefines the narrow scope of Neumeister's permitted rebuttal testimony.Open in transcript →
Quote“The central issues in this case are whether defendant defamed plaintiff and whether plaintiff defamed defendant through a theory of vicarious liability.”— Penney AzcarateCourt's framing of case scope used to reject TMZ's intervention as non-germane.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Whether that breaches a nondisclosure agreement between Mr. Tremaine and EHM is not germane to this matter and can be litigated in a separate matter, if EHM so chooses.”— Penney AzcarateCore rationale for denying intervention: NDA and privilege disputes are outside the defamation trial's subject matter.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 23

colloquySidebar: Scope of Heard Rebuttal Cross-Examination3highlights52lines spoken

Summary

Judge limits Vasquez's cross of Heard to rebuttal-case topics only, permitting TMZ, Kate Moss, and Baruch but excluding Neumeister photos and Beverly Leonard.

Highlights (3)

Quote“You're going to limit it just to whatever evidence from your rebuttal case.”— Penney AzcarateThe judge's core ruling limiting Vasquez's cross to rebuttal-case topics only.Open in transcript →
Quote“It opens quite a bit, Mr. Rottenborn.”— Penney AzcarateJudge signals that Heard's testimony referencing Internet reaction and this trial opened the door to broader cross on damages.Open in transcript →
Quote“anything that's tied to damages, we're not going to go back to 2009. Anything that's tied to damages.”— Penney AzcarateJudge articulates the operative standard: cross topics must relate to Heard's counterclaim damages; pre-rebuttal history is off the table.Open in transcript →
colloquyJury Instructions Finalized; Closing Argument Ground Rules2highlights237lines spoken

Summary

After Heard rests her counterclaim case, the court finalizes contested jury instructions, approves the verdict form, and sets closing argument ground rules for the next morning.

Highlights (2)

Quote“The only way they find defamatory statements in this case is if there's actual malice, and that's unique to this case; I understand that. But so if they find actual malice, defamatory statements, you don't have protected speech privilege.”— Penney AzcarateThe judge's reasoning for denying the self-defense privilege instructions as moot — actual malice and the privilege are mutually exclusive on these facts.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Merely linking to an article does not amount to republication, but adding content to a linked article may constitute republication. You must determine whether any added content was intended to reach a new audience. If you find it was intended to reach a new audience, it constitutes a republication.”— Penney AzcarateThe final jury instruction language on republication — directly relevant to whether Heard's Twitter activity extended liability for the op-ed.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 24

Jury InstructionJury Instructions — Defamation Elements and Damages4highlights32lines spoken

Summary

Judge Azcarate reads final jury instructions on defamation elements, actual malice, and damages standards before closing arguments begin.

Highlights (4)

Quote“Our system of law does not permit jurors to be governed by sympathy, prejudice, or public opinion.”— Penney AzcarateCore impartiality instruction delivered directly to jurors before closing arguments, framing the standard for deliberation.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“The term "actual malice" should not be confused with the more common meaning of the word "malice," such as "ill will" or "hatred."”— Penney AzcarateCritical definitional instruction separating the legal standard from its colloquial meaning — central to both parties' claims.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Merely linking to an article does not amount to republication, but adding content to a linked article may constitute republication.”— Penney AzcarateGoverns whether Heard's December 19, 2018 tweet constitutes actionable republication of the op-ed — a distinct basis for liability.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Mr. Depp cannot recover damages for any harm that occurred after November 2nd, 2020.”— Penney AzcarateEstablishes the damages cutoff date for Depp's claims, limiting the scope of compensable harm the jury could award.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Jury InstructionJury Instructions — Deliberations BeginPenney Azcarate4highlights8lines spoken

Summary

Judge Azcarate delivers final deliberation instructions, releases alternates Jurors 3 and 14, and sends the jury to deliberate in the Depp v. Heard case.

Highlights (4)

Quote“It is rarely helpful for jurors, upon first entering the jury room, to take a straw vote or for any juror to make an emphatic expression of his or her opinion in the case, or to announce a determination to stand for a certain verdict.”— Penney AzcarateCaution against anchoring bias and premature position-locking before full deliberation.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“none of you should surrender your honest conviction as to the weight, or-effect of the evidence solely because of the opinion of your fellow jurors, or for the mere purpose of returning a verdict.”— Penney AzcarateProtection of individual juror conscience against social pressure toward a verdict.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“You'll have two sets of verdict forms, one for Mr. Depp's case and one for Ms. Heard's case”— Penney AzcarateConfirms the jury must evaluate Depp's defamation claims and Heard's counterclaim independently.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 25

colloquyJury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full Content3highlights12lines spoken

Summary

The jury asked whether falsity Question 43 applied to the op-ed headline or the full article; Judge Azcarate clarified it refers to the headline only.

Highlights (3)

Quote“it's clear that the title is the statement”— Penney AzcarateJudge's threshold determination that narrows the falsity question to the headline alone, not the full op-ed.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“since the jury has the case now and it's out of my hands, I appreciate your motion but I'm not going to entertain it at this time, okay?”— Penney AzcarateJudge explains her policy of not acting on motions once deliberations have begun.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 26

colloquyJury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins Counterclaim3highlights23lines spoken

Summary

The jury unanimously finds for Depp on all three defamation claims ($10M compensatory, $5M punitive) and for Heard on one counterclaim ($2M); judge caps punitive at $350K.

Highlights (3)

Quote“Regardless of the verdict, I will not tolerate any outburst, whatsoever, okay?”— Penney AzcarateJudge's admonishment to the gallery before the verdict is read, underscoring the formal stakes of the proceeding.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“As against John C. Depp, II: We, the jury, award compensatory damages in the amount of $2 million.”— Penney AzcarateThe damages verdict on Heard's successful counterclaim over Waldman's 'hoax' statement.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“I will amend the punitive damages award to the statutory cap of $350,000 on Mr. Depp's award, okay?”— Penney AzcarateJudge immediately applies Virginia's statutory punitive cap, reducing the $5M jury award to $350K.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶