Fairfax County Circuit Court judge who presided over the Depp v. Heard civil trial.
Penney Azcarate

Fairfax County Circuit Court judge who presided over the Depp v. Heard civil trial.
About
Penney Azcarate presided over the 2022 Depp v. Heard trial, managing witness testimony, evidence, courtroom procedure and the time allotted to each side. She struck Gina Deuters’s testimony after Deuters acknowledged watching trial clips, and she resolved disputes over which exhibits and deposition excerpts the jury could consider.
When Heard moved to strike Depp’s claims at the close of his case, Azcarate denied the motion as to two challenged statements and took the first under advisement. After further evidence, she denied the motion as to the first statement as well, finding a question for the jury rather than deciding it herself. During deliberations, she answered a jury question by clarifying that its falsity inquiry concerned the op-ed headline, not the entire article. She returned an incomplete verdict form for the required damages entries and, after the jury’s verdict, reduced Depp’s punitive damages award from $5 million to Virginia’s $350,000 statutory cap.
Trial Record (241)
No proceedings match this filter.