Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayJessica MeyersSamuel MonizAdam NadelhaftJ. Benjamin RottenbornBen KingJohnny DeppcrossredirectdirectDay 8 - April 25, 2022Rottenborn completed his cross of Depp using recordings and texts; redirect revisited key exhibits; Ben King testified about the Australia house and fingertip discovery and said he saw no injuries on Heard at the house on Sunday but noticed forearm marks or cuts near the end of the following flight.
← Day 72022 Defamation TrialDay 9 →

Day 8 - April 25, 2022

Depp's Cross and Redirect; Ben King's Testimony

Judge Penney Azcarate
9Proceedings
2Pages
2Witnesses
2,825Lines
Day 8 of 27
Appearing:

Rottenborn completed his cross of Depp using recordings and texts; redirect revisited key exhibits; Ben King testified about the Australia house and fingertip discovery and said he saw no injuries on Heard at the house on Sunday but noticed forearm marks or cuts near the end of the following flight.

Full day summary

Day 8 opened with Rottenborn completing his cross-examination of Johnny Depp. He played recordings containing Depp's degrading language toward Heard, including "bloodbath" references tied to Australia and a statement that he was "never getting clean and sober," and used a post-Australia text in which Depp wrote that he "cut the top of my middle finger off" to question Depp's account of the injury. Rottenborn also reviewed negative press coverage published before the op-ed while challenging the claimed causal link to reputational harm. On redirect, Jessica Meyers asked Depp about the Bettany texts, his use of "the monster," and PX 357A, a recording in which Heard tells Depp to "tell the world" that he is also a domestic-violence victim. The afternoon shifted to Ben King, who described arriving at the Australia house, finding Depp's fingertip near the lower-ground bar, and seeing property damage but no injuries on Heard. On cross, Nadelhaft introduced photographs of cuts on Heard's arm and wrist and established that King never saw Heard act violently. On redirect, King used a floor plan to identify where he saw damage and found the fingertip.

Video thumbnail8:35:52
Watch →

1. Johnny Depp — Cross/Redirect

Rottenborn closes cross with audio recordings and damaging texts, then Meyers redirects with counter-recordings and Depp's explanations.

→
Procedural
Exhibit Redactions and UK Trial Admissibility
56 lines

Court addresses redacted exhibit logistics and holds a sidebar on whether Depp's testimony opened the door to UK trial evidence, which the judge declines to admit.

Cross
Cross Examination of Johnny Depp (Continued) Johnny Depp J. Benjamin Rottenborn
768 lines

Rottenborn continued cross of Depp with audio recordings of arguments and texts revealing violent wishes toward Heard and a finger injury admission.

Procedural
Morning Recess and Jury Return
12 lines

Jury takes morning recess from 11:47 a.m. to 12:05 p.m.; court reconvenes for redirect examination.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Johnny Depp Johnny Depp Jessica Meyers
760 lines

On redirect, Meyers asked Depp to explain the Bettany texts, the term 'monster,' recordings of arguments, his finger injury, and the San Francisco knife incident.

Procedural
Ben King Called as Witness
9 lines

Ben King is called as a witness for the plaintiff, sworn in by the clerk, and examination by counsel begins.

Highlights

Cross Examination of Johnny Depp (Continued)Rottenborn plays audio recordings capturing Depp's 'bloodbath' reference tied to Australia and his statement 'I'm never getting clean and sober,' while a post-Australia text stating he 'cut the top of my middle finger off' directly challenged his direct-examination account.Cross Examination of Johnny Depp (Continued)“it's just going to be a bloodbath like it, you know, like it was on the island, of course, like it was, you know -- it's just not worth it, no. It's just not worth it.”— Johnny DeppAudio recording captures Depp referencing 'bloodbath' in the context of their conflicts and explicitly tying it to the Australia incident, reinforcing Rottenborn's broader impeachment linking the same phrase across multiple texts and recordings.Cross Examination of Johnny Depp (Continued)“I'm never getting clean and sober.”— Johnny DeppCaptured in an audio recording played to the jury, this statement directly undermines Depp's portrayal of himself as striving for sobriety during the relationship and is one of the most damaging exhibits Rottenborn deploys on cross.Cross Examination of Johnny Depp (Continued)Rottenborn walks through over a dozen pre-op-ed negative press headlines from 2014–2018, challenging the causal connection between the 2018 Washington Post publication and Depp's alleged reputational damages.Redirect Examination of Johnny DeppMeyers introduces PX 357A, a recording in which Heard tells Depp to 'tell the world' he is a domestic violence victim — presented as a counter-narrative to Heard's framing of herself as the sole victim in the relationship.Redirect Examination of Johnny Depp“Tell the world, Johnny. Tell them, Johnny Depp, I, Johnny Depp, yes, I'm a victim, too, of domestic violence and I --”— Amber HeardHeard's own recorded words, introduced by Meyers on redirect, acknowledge Depp's framing of himself as a domestic violence victim — the single most significant counter-recording introduced during redirect examination.

2. Ben King — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Ben King's complete testimony arc: his direct account of the Australia aftermath, cross-examination on gaps in his firsthand knowledge, and redirect with floor-plan damage geolocations.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Ben King Ben King Samuel Moniz
430 lines

Depp's former house manager describes finding the severed fingertip, extensive Australia property damage, and Heard asking if he had ever 'lost it' on the flight to LA.

Cross
Cross Examination of Ben King Ben King Adam Nadelhaft
664 lines

Heard's counsel challenged King on timeline gaps in Australia, his selective sharing of damage photos, and admitted photos of cuts on Heard's arm while two audio recordings were excluded as hearsay.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Ben King Ben King Samuel Moniz
97 lines

Moniz uses a floor plan to geolocate Australia damage and the fingertip discovery, while rehabilitating King's photo-taking as routine professional practice.

colloquy
Photo Production and Exhibit 485
29 lines

Sidebar requiring photo production by end of day; judge clarifies Exhibit 485 pagination and confirms next day's remote witness setup.

Highlights

← Day 72022 Defamation TrialDay 9 →