Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayStephanie CalnanWayne DennisonLeo J. PresiadoElaine BredehoftShannon CurryTara RobertsMelissa SaenzdirectcrossredirectcolloquyDay 9 - April 26, 2022Day 9: island manager Tara Roberts corroborated a December 2015 Bahamas altercation, forensic psychologist Shannon Curry diagnosed Heard with BPD and found no PTSD, and LAPD Officer Saenz testified she observed no injuries on May 21, 2016.
← Day 82022 Defamation TrialDay 10 →

Day 9 - April 26, 2022

Tara Roberts, Shannon Curry and Officer Melissa Saenz

Judge Penney Azcarate
13Proceedings
4Pages
3Witnesses
2,825Lines
Day 9 of 27
Appearing:

Day 9: island manager Tara Roberts corroborated a December 2015 Bahamas altercation, forensic psychologist Shannon Curry diagnosed Heard with BPD and found no PTSD, and LAPD Officer Saenz testified she observed no injuries on May 21, 2016.

Full day summary

Day 9 presented three witnesses across ten proceedings. Tara Roberts, Depp's Bahamian island manager for fifteen years, described a December 2015 altercation in which Heard verbally berated Depp and physically grabbed him, with Roberts observing a mark across Depp's nose and no injuries on Heard; cross-examination established her $120,000 annual salary from Depp, her limited access to house interiors, and a 2013 incident in which Depp was found passed out on the beach with his children present. Dr. Shannon Curry, Depp's forensic psychologist, diagnosed Heard with borderline and histrionic personality disorders and found no PTSD — cross exposed an undisclosed pre-retention dinner at Depp's home and Curry's concession that the MMPI-2 showed a defensive rather than exaggerated profile, while redirect countered with Heard's 98th-percentile score on Hughes's own intentional-exaggeration scale. The day closed with LAPD Officer Melissa Saenz's deposition establishing that on May 21, 2016 she observed no injuries on Heard, filed no domestic violence report, and had not yet been issued a body-worn camera.

Video thumbnail7:52:40
Watch →

1. Tara Roberts — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Tara Roberts — Depp's Bahamas island manager — gives direct, cross, and redirect testimony about a December 2015 altercation and Depp's 2014 detox stay.

→
Procedural
Late Photo Exhibits and Witness Scheduling
38 lines

Preliminary discussion of 126 photos received late and Officer Saenz's upcoming video testimony before jury enters.

Direct
Direct Examination of Tara Roberts Tara Roberts Stephanie Calnan
204 lines

Depp's island manager of 15 years describes a December 2015 altercation in which Heard berated Depp, blocked his vehicle, and grabbed at him; Roberts saw a mark on Depp's nose, no injuries on Heard.

Cross
Cross Examination of Tara Roberts Tara Roberts Elaine Bredehoft
281 lines

Bredehoft establishes Roberts' $120K annual salary from Depp as a bias foundation, elicits admissions she could not observe the house interior, and draws out that Depp was passed out face-first on the beach in summer 2013.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Tara Roberts Tara Roberts Stephanie Calnan
12 lines

A brief redirect in which one drug-consumption question is sustained as leading, then Roberts repeats that Depp was "passed out" on the beach and says she believed he had been asleep and the hammock had overturned.

Highlights

2. Shannon Curry — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Shannon Curry's complete testimony arc: direct on BPD/HPD diagnoses of Heard, cross challenging Curry's independence, and Dennison's redirect.

→
Procedural
Calling Dr. Shannon Curry
9 lines

The court calls and swears in Dr. Shannon Curry as the next witness.

Direct
Direct Examination of Shannon Curry Shannon Curry Wayne Dennison
303 lines

Forensic psychologist Shannon Curry testifies that Amber Heard has borderline and histrionic personality disorders, does not have PTSD, and showed gross exaggeration of PTSD symptoms during testing.

Procedural
Lunch Recess and Jury Instructions
16 lines

Judge calls lunch recess and instructs jury not to discuss the case or conduct outside research; expert witness Curry reminded to avoid discussing her ongoing testimony.

Cross
Cross Examination of Shannon Curry Shannon Curry Elaine Bredehoft
756 lines

Bredehoft challenges Curry's independence through her pre-retention dinner with Depp, an expert designation listing opinions Curry hadn't formed, and prior-statement impeachment on IPV expertise.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Shannon Curry Shannon Curry Wayne Dennison
31 lines

On redirect, Curry addressed the CAPS-5 and trauma-test findings and explained how she distinguished treating and forensic roles.

Highlights

Direct Examination of Shannon CurryDr. Shannon Curry delivers Depp's central psychological opinion: Heard meets criteria for borderline and histrionic personality disorders and did not have PTSD, with significant indicators of symptom exaggeration.Direct Examination of Shannon Curry“The results of Ms. Heard's evaluation supported two diagnoses: Borderline personality disorder and histrionic personality disorder.”— Shannon CurryThe central opinion of Depp's forensic expert, delivered without qualification — the pivot point of the entire day.Direct Examination of Shannon Curry“Ms. Heard did not have PTSD. And there were also pretty significant indications that she was grossly exaggerating symptoms of PTSD when asked about them.”— Shannon CurryDirectly refutes the psychological-harm component of Heard's abuse narrative, coupling a negative PTSD finding with an exaggeration finding.Cross Examination of Shannon CurryCross-examination exposes Curry's undisclosed pre-retention dinner at Depp's home and elicits her concession that the MMPI-2 showed a defensive — not exaggerated — response profile, directly qualifying her direct testimony.Cross Examination of Shannon Curry“The MMPI-2 profile, it's specific to how she approached this test, and you're correct, for this test, it was a defensive profile, not an exaggerated profile.”— Shannon CurryCurry's own concession on cross that the MMPI-2 showed minimization rather than exaggeration — the most significant impeachment of the day's expert testimony.
← Day 82022 Defamation TrialDay 10 →