Wayne Dennison
Wayne Dennison is a litigation partner at Brown Rudnick LLP, where his practice centers on complex commercial disputes and high-stakes trial work. He served as one of Johnny Depp's trial attorneys at the Fairfax County Circuit Court, working alongside Benjamin Chew and Camille Vasquez. His assignment within the team concentrated almost exclusively on the expert witness docket — both presenting Depp's retained experts and cross-examining the witnesses called by Heard's defense.
Testimony Impact
Dennison handled the bulk of the expert witness work for Depp's side, conducting direct examinations of forensic accountant Michael Spindler and rebuttal forensic psychologist Shannon Curry, while cross-examining nearly every major expert Heard's team called. His cross-examinations of Dawn Hughes — across two separate court sessions — methodically attacked the methodological foundations of her PTSD diagnosis, using the witnesses' own test manuals and prior deposition statements to document protocol deviations and impeach her conclusions. He similarly dismantled the causal framework of Heard's $45–50M counterclaim by exposing Ron Schnell's hashtag timeline and Kathryn Arnold's inability to isolate the Waldman statements from pre-existing reputational damage. A recurring technique was prior-deposition impeachment: surfacing inconsistencies adopted wholesale from other experts or built on incomplete data, then leaving the contradiction for the jury without overplaying it.
Notable Quotes From The Record
“you made no effort to connect those tweets and hashtags to the statements made by Adam Waldman?”
Dennison's question signals that he intends to challenge the relevance of Schnell's entire analysis to the counterclaim, not just his qualifications.
“Wait a minute. Is the new standard "It's not that big of a stretch''?”
Dennison pointedly rebuts Schnell's informal reasoning about Waldman name mentions, highlighting the gap between scientific methodology and the inference Schnell actually drew.
“we have no idea, clinically, if they are high, wasted, stoned, stroke. We have no idea.”
Spiegel acknowledges the standard of care does not require knowing a patient's state when administering the MMSE — undercutting his own cognitive-decline inference when applied to Depp's exam.
“correlation does not imply causation, does it, ma'am?”
Dennison's central challenge to Arnold's methodology: that temporal proximity between the Waldman statements and Heard's career decline does not establish that one caused the other.
“They have the exact same file name, don't they, sir?”
The sharpest point of the cross — two visually different photos sharing an identical filename and timestamp, presented to the jury as an unresolved evidentiary conflict.
Key Moments
On cross, Hughes conceded that Depp suffered physical and psychological violence at Heard's hands — an admission that cut directly against the defense's victim-only framing.
Day 14 · Cross of Dawn Hughes
Using the witnesses' own admitted test manuals as exhibits, Dennison documented Hughes's departures from standardized administration instructions across every major diagnostic instrument she used, leaving her PTSD diagnosis without a procedurally sound foundation.
Day 23 · Cross of Dawn Hughes
Dennison confronted Schnell with deposition testimony stating the four key hashtags had no connection to Waldman, then established that all four predated Waldman's first statement — some traceable to 2013 — collapsing the causal core of Heard's social-media damages theory.
Day 19 · Recross of Ron Schnell
Dennison read the APA Goldwater Rule aloud and then revealed that Spiegel had called Depp 'an idiot' in deposition, forcing Spiegel into an unsteady contextual explanation while the ethics violation framing lingered before the jury.
Day 20 · Cross of David Spiegel
Dennison pressed Arnold to acknowledge she could not isolate Waldman's statements as the cause of Heard's career losses from the UK trial, pre-existing social-media sentiment, or the defecation story — leaving her $45–50M projection without a defensible causal anchor.
Day 20 · Cross of Kathryn Arnold
Dennison walked Spindler through a two-component methodology culminating in a demonstrative chart showing $40.3M in lost earnings — the concrete damages figure the jury would carry into deliberations on Depp's defamation claims.
Day 13 · Direct of Michael Spindler
Evidence From Their Proceedings (47)
Bonnie Jacobs Therapy Notes (Heard, from October 2011)
Treatment notes of psychologist Dr. Bonnie Jacobs documenting Heard's sessions over approximately five years beginning October 2011, including Heard's reports of physical and…
Catalog entry →CAPS-5 — Hughes Administration (Heard, Dec. 27, 2021)
The CAPS-5 structured clinical interview was administered by Hughes to Heard on December 27, 2021, producing an approximately 59-page handwritten scoring form. The plaintiff…
Catalog entry →Depp–Heard Multi-Segment Argument Recording (PX 343)
Extended audio recording played in multiple proceedings across several segments, covering discussions of the Australia fight, bathroom retreat disputes, and Heard's…
Catalog entry →Heard's Aquaman Option Contract with Warner Bros.
Amber Heard's test option agreement with Warner Brothers for the role of Mera in the Aquaman franchise, establishing a tiered salary structure across multiple pictures, identified…
Catalog entry →TSI-2 — Hughes Administration (Heard)
The TSI-2, a clinical instrument assessing trauma-related symptoms including an Atypical Response Scale measuring exaggeration, was administered by Hughes to Heard. The plaintiff…
Catalog entry →Depp Ice Cream / Passed-Out Photo (Def. 1094)
Photograph of Depp passed out with ice cream spilled on him, taken during the Black Mass filming period. Heard sent the photo to Raquel Pennington on August 7, 2014 with the…
Catalog entry →Falati Nursing Notes for Amber Heard (Aug 2014–May 2016)
Erin Falati (née Boerum), Heard's personal nurse, maintained clinical notes documenting Heard's physical condition, emotional state, and medication regimen from August 2014…
Catalog entry →Hasta la muerte bowie knife gifted by Amber Heard
A large bowie knife inscribed "Hasta la muerte / XX Slim" (until death), given by Amber Heard to Johnny Depp as a gift, variously dated to circa 2012 (during The Lone Ranger…
Catalog entry →PAI — Hughes Administration (Heard)
The PAI, a broadband personality inventory with built-in validity scales, was administered by Hughes to Heard. The plaintiff introduced critical item endorsements as Plaintiff's…
Catalog entry →Plaintiff's Ex. 144 — ER Photo, Depp's Severed Fingertip (Australia)
Graphic emergency room photograph of Johnny Depp's severed right middle finger sustained during the Australia incident. The photograph provides a clear profile of the injured…
Catalog entry →Schnell Social Media Hashtag Analysis / Dataset
Ron Schnell's social media analysis and underlying Twitter API dataset tracking negative hashtag tweets against Heard from April 2020 through January 2021 and into 2022, tracking…
Catalog entry →Blaustein Session Notes — October 2014 through January 2015
Dr. Alan Blaustein's handwritten session notes for Johnny Depp, beginning with an initial telephone consultation on October 2, 2014, and spanning through January 8, 2015. Notes…
Catalog entry →Connell Cowan Treatment Records (Defendant's Ex. 1057)
Clinical treatment notes and deposition of Dr. Connell Cowan, who treated Heard for approximately two years; reviewed by both Shannon Curry and Dawn Hughes as part of their expert…
Catalog entry →May 21, 2016 Face Photos — DX-710/712/713/714 + Metadata
Defendant's Exhibits 710, 712, 713, and 714, consisting of May 21, 2016 face photographs of Heard. Exhibits 712 and 713 appear visually different but share identical timestamps…
Catalog entry →White Cover Letter to ACLU — $100K Pledge Installment
A cover letter from Edward White to the ACLU, dated August 24, 2016, enclosing Depp's $100,000 check and characterizing the payment as the first of multiple scheduled installments…
Catalog entry →CAPS-5 — Curry Administration (Heard)
The CAPS-5, a structured clinical interview for PTSD developed by the National Center for PTSD and the VA, was administered by Curry to Heard.
Catalog entry →Danger Assessment Scale — Hughes Administration (Heard)
The Danger Assessment Scale, a validated instrument identifying risk factors for serious or lethal domestic violence, was administered by Hughes to Heard.
Catalog entry →Hughes Expert Witness Training Presentation — National Clearinghouse
A PowerPoint presentation titled 'Expert Witness Testimony in Cases Involving Domestic Violence,' given by Hughes and Mary Ann Dutton to the National Clearinghouse for the Defense…
Catalog entry →Hughes IPV Expert Witness Presentation — Kings County Bar Assoc.
A PowerPoint presentation titled 'The Use of Psychological Experts in Cases of Domestic Violence,' given by Hughes to the Kings County Bar Association, covering myths and…
Catalog entry →MMPI-2 — Curry Administration (Heard)
The MMPI-2, a 567-item objective personality and psychopathology inventory, was administered by Curry to Heard on an iPad. Curry produced a 25-page scoring outline summarizing the…
Catalog entry →PCL-5 — Hughes Administration (Heard)
The PCL-5, a face-value self-report checklist of DSM-5 PTSD symptoms, was administered by Hughes to Heard as part of her evaluation protocol.
Catalog entry →Plaintiff's Ex. 145 — ER Photo, Cigarette Burn on Depp's Cheek (Australia)
Emergency room photograph showing a cigarette burn wound on Johnny Depp's cheek, taken during the Australia incident. The photograph is among the images associated with Depp's…
Catalog entry →Abusive Behaviors Observation Checklist — Hughes Administration (Heard)
The Abusive Behaviors Observation Checklist, a brief therapeutic checklist with no published validation research, was administered by Hughes to Heard.
Catalog entry →APA Goldwater Rule text — the 2017 amendment stating it is unethical to offer a
APA Goldwater Rule text — the 2017 amendment stating it is unethical to offer a professional opinion about an individual without conducting an examination — read aloud by Dennison.
Catalog entry →CTS-2 — Hughes Administration (Heard)
The Conflict Tactic Scale 2 (Revised, 2nd edition), a research instrument developed for studying family violence prevalence in anonymous survey populations, was administered by…
Catalog entry →CTS-2 Instructions with Dennison Annotations (Demonstrative)
The published CTS-2 instructions bearing Dennison's redline annotations, introduced as Plaintiff's 1309 as a demonstrative exhibit.
Catalog entry →Danger Assessment Scale — Blank Test Form (Demonstrative)
A blank Danger Assessment Scale test form, published as a demonstrative exhibit and introduced as Plaintiff's 1310.
Catalog entry →David Spiegel's deposition transcript — specifically the line 'So, I mean, he's
David Spiegel's deposition transcript — specifically the line 'So, I mean, he's an idiot' and earlier statements about comparing Depp's Pirates performances to deposition…
Catalog entry →Dawn Hughes Deposition (March 28, 2022)
The pre-trial deposition of Dawn Hughes taken March 28, 2022.
Catalog entry →Divorce Settlement Payment Records
Records documenting the full financial scope of Depp's payments under the divorce agreement, including amounts paid directly to Heard, to her attorneys, and toward community…
Catalog entry →Heard Gully Film Contract (~SAG minimum)
Heard's contract for the film Gully at approximately $2,190 per week, near SAG minimum.
Catalog entry →Heard Tax Returns 2013–2019 (~$10M total)
Heard's tax returns for 2013–2019 showing total compensation of approximately $10 million.
Catalog entry →Hughes Forensic Evaluation Report and Interview Notes (Heard)
Dr. Dawn Hughes's forensic psychological evaluation report and interview notes of Amber Heard, including a recorded disclosure of Heard's self-reported arm-cutting at intake.
Catalog entry →Hughes Intake Background Information Sheet (Plaintiff's 938)
A background information sheet from Hughes's evaluation of Heard, previously admitted into evidence as Plaintiff's 938.
Catalog entry →Hughes Intake Background Questionnaire (Plaintiff's 1246)
The background information questionnaire completed by Hughes during her initial intake evaluation of Amber Heard, including sections on intimate relationships noting James Franco…
Catalog entry →Keenan Wyatt's prior trial testimony establishing that the earpiece Depp wore on
Keenan Wyatt's prior trial testimony establishing that the earpiece Depp wore on set carried music, not script lines.
Catalog entry →Kipper and Banks Medical Records — Curry Record Review
Dr. David Kipper's medical records for Amber Heard, together with records from Dr. Amy Banks, reviewed by Dr. Shannon Curry as part of her comprehensive pre-evaluation case record…
Catalog entry →L'Oreal Communications re Heard Marketability
L'Oreal communications regarding Amber Heard's marketability, referenced at trial.
Catalog entry →PCL-5 Instruction Manual (National Center for PTSD)
The official PCL-5 instruction manual published by the National Center for PTSD, introduced as Plaintiff's 1312.
Catalog entry →Raquel Pennington's deposition testimony and/or declaration.
Raquel Pennington's deposition testimony and/or declaration.
Catalog entry →Schnell Hashtag Timeline Chart — Negative Volume 2020–2022
A demonstrative chart of negative hashtag usage over time from 2020 to 2022, showing volume spikes intended to be correlated with Waldman statement dates, presented during…
Catalog entry →Spindler Deposition Transcript (Vol. 2, Mar. 25)
Spindler deposition transcript, Volume 2, March 25, referenced by Rottenborn at the first sidebar.
Catalog entry →Spindler Expert Report (scope / designation)
Spindler's expert report referenced in sidebar discussions about his designation boundaries, covering historical earnings only.
Catalog entry →Spindler Lost Earnings Demonstrative ($40.3M)
Lost earnings demonstrative chart prepared by Spindler's firm showing a two-component breakdown and a $40,318,237 total, used as a demonstrative and not moved into evidence.
Catalog entry →Twenty Twenty Wine Invoices (~$160K balance)
Twenty Twenty Wine Merchants invoices showing a balance of approximately $160,000 at the time of the Depp-Heard divorce and a near-zero current balance.
Catalog entry →Walter Hamada deposition testimony
Walter Hamada deposition testimony
Catalog entry →White Checks to Children's Hospital LA and ACLU
Checks issued by Edward White to Children's Hospital Los Angeles ($100,000 ×2) and the ACLU ($100,000), reflecting Depp's direct charitable contributions prior to or alongside the…
Catalog entry →