Skip to content
personpersonDawn HughesDawn HughesForensic psychologist who evaluated Amber Heard and testified about intimate partner violence and PTSD.← All People
Expert witness

Dawn Hughes

Courtroom still of Dawn Hughes.

Forensic psychologist who evaluated Amber Heard and testified about intimate partner violence and PTSD.

814 lines·6 proceedings

About

Hughes, an expert called by Heard’s legal team, testified that her approximately 29-hour evaluation, psychological testing and review of records supported a PTSD diagnosis. In her opinion, Heard’s reported experiences were consistent with intimate partner violence, and Depp’s conduct caused the PTSD.

On cross-examination, Wayne Dennison played a recording in which Heard said she had hit Depp and started physical fights, challenging Hughes’s account of reactive violence. He also questioned her $500 hourly rate and how she administered PTSD assessments, including diagnosing PTSD before administering the CAPS-5 and leaving frequency fields blank. Hughes defended clinical interviewing and retrospective use, and said frequency information was recorded on the scoring side with supplemental notes. On redirect, additional audio was played in which Depp referred to physical fights between them. Hughes said her opinions remained unchanged.

When recalled to address Shannon Curry’s criticism of her methods and conclusions, Hughes disputed Curry’s interpretations of the test results. She defended her broader evaluation and said her notes supplied clinical context beyond the assessment forms.

Trial Record (6)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022Called by defendant

Forensic psychologist who evaluated Amber Heard and testified about intimate partner violence and PTSD.

Day 13

DirectDirect Examination of Dawn HughesDawn HughesElaine Bredehoft5highlights329lines spoken

Summary

Defense expert Dr. Dawn Hughes testified that Heard's reported abuse is consistent with intimate partner violence and that she suffers from PTSD attributed to Depp's conduct.

Highlights (5)

Quote“intimate partner violence is a pattern of manipulation, fear, and coercive control that happens within an intimate relationship”— Dawn HughesHughes defines intimate partner violence as a pattern involving manipulation, fear, and coercive control.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“when you pair sort of this violent dynamic, physical violence, sexual violence, with love and attachment, it creates a trauma bond.”— Dawn HughesHughes explains trauma bonding as the combination of violence with love and attachment.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Ms. Heard's report of intimate partner violence, and the records that I reviewed, is consistent with what we know in the field about intimate partner violence, characterized by physical violence, psychological aggression, sexual violence, coercive control, and surveillance behaviors.”— Dawn HughesHughes states her opinion that Heard's reports and the records she reviewed were consistent with patterns of intimate partner violence.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Show all 5 highlights
Quote“And this is the one thing that women are always afraid of, that no one's going to believe them.”— Dawn HughesHughes explains the psychological effect she attributed to the statement that Heard's sexual-violence account was a hoax.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 14

CrossCross-Examination of Dawn HughesDawn HughesWayne Dennison2highlights347lines spoken

Summary

Dennison challenged Hughes on gender bias, financial stake, and flawed PTSD testing methodology, then played an audio recording of Heard admitting to hitting Depp and starting physical fights.

Highlights (2)

RedirectRedirect Examination of Dawn HughesDawn HughesElaine Bredehoft2highlights59lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft rehabilitates Hughes via additional audio clips showing Depp acknowledging mutual violence, while hearsay objections block full test document admission.

Highlights (2)

Quote“The phraseology is that Mr. Depp told her the only way out of this relationship is death.”— Dawn HughesHughes recounts the context Heard reported for the knife's inscription.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 23

DirectDirect Examination of Dawn Hughes — RebuttalDawn HughesElaine Bredehoft4highlights30lines spoken

Summary

Dr. Dawn Hughes rebuts Shannon Curry's Day 22 criticisms, defending her multi-method forensic methodology, test interpretations, and PTSD conclusions regarding Amber Heard.

Highlights (4)

Quote“Dr. Curry did not independently administer -- measure malingering, and there are other ones that she could have done to augment her evaluation.”— Dawn HughesHughes says Curry did not administer a separate malingering measure.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“On this measure, Amber Heard scored in a moderate range. She did not overexaggerate on this test. She could have said no, mild, moderate, severe, and extreme. All of hers were either 2s, or 1s, or 0s.”— Dawn HughesHughes describes Heard's CAPS-5 responses as falling in a moderate range.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“I vehemently disagree with that. As I stated to you, over 29 hours and 12 psychological tests and reviewing a slew of documents in this case, most importantly, therapy records and interview, collateral interviews with therapists, using all that data, that is what a solid forensic methodological exam looks like.”— Dawn HughesHughes explains the interviews, tests, and records on which she based her evaluation.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“That score, the one that's elevated, that she's talking about that percentile rank, has a raw score. Amber's raw score is a 10, the cutoff score is a 15. She's nowhere near that level of exaggerated symptoms where I can't further look at that test.”— Dawn HughesHughes disputes Curry's interpretation of Heard's TSI-2 score and cites the raw-score cutoff she used.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
CrossCross Examination of Dawn HughesDawn HughesWayne Dennison4highlights46lines spoken

Summary

Dennison challenges Hughes’s PTSD diagnosis and use of test instructions. Hughes defends clinical interviewing, retrospective use, and her recording of frequency information on the scoring side.

Highlights (4)

Quote“I made my diagnosis during clinical interviewing and 11 other psychological tests that supported diagnosis of PTSD and symptomatology consistent with PTSD.”— Dawn HughesHughes explains that she relied on clinical interviews and other psychological tests before administering the CAPS-5.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“And I oriented her to not limit herself to the last year, to get an accurate assessment of the violence and abuse that she experienced in the relationship.”— Dawn HughesHughes explains why she did not limit the CTS-2 responses to the preceding year; the court later struck the response after Dennison's objection.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“We talked about this before, Mr. Dennison, I had 88 pages of notes of what happened. It would have been redundant to put it there.”— Dawn HughesHughes says she left CAPS-5 frequency fields blank because the information appeared in her notes.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
RedirectRedirect Examination of Dawn HughesDawn HughesElaine Bredehoft3highlights3lines spoken

Summary

Brief redirect rehabilitates Hughes on static risk factors, the 88-page notes, and clinical versus research scoring of the CAPS-5.

Highlights (3)

Quote“the more successive traumas that you have, the greater likelihood that somebody is going to have psychological consequences and symptomatology as a result”— Dawn HughesHughes explains why she assessed reported trauma across the full relationship rather than a fixed time window.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“In the 88 pages were many of the documented incidents of intimate partner violence.”— Dawn HughesHughes describes the incident information contained in her supplemental notes.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“when they're used in research, that means the document stands alone”— Dawn HughesHughes distinguishes research scoring from the use of a test within a broader clinical evaluation.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶