Person Dawn Hughes Depp v. Heard← All People
Expert Witness

Dawn Hughes

Courtroom still of Dawn Hughes.

Forensic psychologist who evaluated Amber Heard and testified about intimate partner violence and PTSD.

2022 Defamation Trial Apr 11 – Jun 1, 2022
Called by defendant
814 lines 6 proceedings 20 highlights

About

Hughes, an expert called by Heard’s legal team, testified that her approximately 29-hour evaluation, psychological testing and review of records supported a PTSD diagnosis. In her opinion, Heard’s reported experiences were consistent with intimate partner violence, and Depp’s conduct caused the PTSD.

On cross-examination, Wayne Dennison played a recording in which Heard said she had hit Depp and started physical fights, challenging Hughes’s account of reactive violence. He also questioned her $500 hourly rate and how she administered PTSD assessments, including diagnosing PTSD before administering the CAPS-5 and leaving frequency fields blank. On redirect, additional audio was played in which Depp referred to physical fights between them. Hughes said her opinions remained unchanged.

When recalled to address Shannon Curry’s criticism of her methods and conclusions, Hughes disputed Curry’s interpretations of the test results. She defended her broader evaluation and said her notes supplied clinical context beyond the assessment forms.

Trial Record (6)

2022 Defamation Trial Apr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022 6 proceedings

Day 13

Direct Direct Examination of Dawn Hughes Dawn Hughes Elaine Bredehoft 5 329
Summary

Defense expert Dr. Dawn Hughes testified that Heard's reported abuse is consistent with intimate partner violence and that she suffers from PTSD attributed to Depp's conduct.

Highlights (5)
Quote

“Ms. Heard's report of intimate partner violence, and the records that I reviewed, is consistent with what we know in the field about intimate partner violence, characterized by physical violence, psychological aggression, sexual violence, coercive control, and surveillance behaviors.”

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Show 1 more

Day 14

Redirect Redirect Examination of Dawn Hughes Dawn Hughes Elaine Bredehoft 2 59
Summary

Bredehoft rehabilitates Hughes via additional audio clips showing Depp acknowledging mutual violence, while hearsay objections block full test document admission.

Highlights (2)

Day 23

Direct Direct Examination of Dawn Hughes — Rebuttal Dawn Hughes Elaine Bredehoft 4 30
Summary

Dr. Dawn Hughes rebuts Shannon Curry's Day 22 criticisms, defending her multi-method forensic methodology, test interpretations, and PTSD conclusions regarding Amber Heard.

Highlights (4)
Quote

“That score, the one that's elevated, that she's talking about that percentile rank, has a raw score. Amber's raw score is a 10, the cutoff score is a 15. She's nowhere near that level of exaggerated symptoms where I can't further look at that test.”

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“On this measure, Amber Heard scored in a moderate range. She did not overexaggerate on this test. She could have said no, mild, moderate, severe, and extreme. All of hers were either 2s, or 1s, or 0s.”

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Quote

“I vehemently disagree with that. As I stated to you, over 29 hours and 12 psychological tests and reviewing a slew of documents in this case, most importantly, therapy records and interview, collateral interviews with therapists, using all that data, that is what a solid forensic methodological exam looks like.”

Open in transcript → Watch this moment ▶
Cross Cross Examination of Dawn Hughes Dawn Hughes Wayne Dennison 4 46
Summary

Dennison cross-examines Hughes using test manuals to show she diagnosed PTSD before the CAPS-5 and deviated from PCL-5, CTS-2, and Danger Assessment instructions.

Highlights (4)
Redirect Redirect Examination of Dawn Hughes Dawn Hughes Elaine Bredehoft 3 3
Summary

Brief redirect rehabilitates Hughes on static risk factors, the 88-page notes, and clinical versus research scoring of the CAPS-5.

Highlights (3)

Locations

Evidence From Their Proceedings (29)

Documents Excluded

Bonnie Jacobs Therapy Notes (Heard, from October 2011)

Treatment notes of psychologist Dr. Bonnie Jacobs documenting Heard's sessions over approximately five years beginning October 2011, including Heard's reports of physical and…

Catalog entry →
Documents Mixed

CAPS-5 — Hughes Administration (Heard, Dec. 27, 2021)

The CAPS-5 structured clinical interview was administered by Hughes to Heard on December 27, 2021, producing an approximately 59-page handwritten scoring form. The plaintiff…

Catalog entry →
Audio Recordings Admitted

Depp–Heard Multi-Segment Argument Recording (PX 343)

Extended audio recording played in multiple proceedings across several segments, covering discussions of the Australia fight, bathroom retreat disputes, and Heard's…

Catalog entry →
Documents Excluded

TSI-2 — Hughes Administration (Heard)

The TSI-2, a clinical instrument assessing trauma-related symptoms including an Atypical Response Scale measuring exaggeration, was administered by Hughes to Heard. The plaintiff…

Catalog entry →
Physical Objects Admitted

Hasta la muerte bowie knife gifted by Amber Heard

A large bowie knife inscribed "Hasta la muerte / XX Slim" (until death), given by Amber Heard to Johnny Depp as a gift, variously dated to circa 2012 (during The Lone Ranger…

Catalog entry →
Documents Mixed

PAI — Hughes Administration (Heard)

The PAI, a broadband personality inventory with built-in validity scales, was administered by Hughes to Heard. The plaintiff introduced critical item endorsements as Plaintiff's…

Catalog entry →
Photographs Admitted

Plaintiff's Ex. 144 — ER Photo, Depp's Severed Fingertip (Australia)

Graphic emergency room photograph of Johnny Depp's severed right middle finger sustained during the Australia incident. The photograph provides a clear profile of the injured…

Catalog entry →
Documents Excluded

Connell Cowan Treatment Records (Defendant's Ex. 1057)

Clinical treatment notes and deposition of Dr. Connell Cowan, who treated Heard for approximately two years; reviewed by both Shannon Curry and Dawn Hughes as part of their expert…

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Danger Assessment Scale — Hughes Administration (Heard)

The Danger Assessment Scale, a validated instrument identifying risk factors for serious or lethal domestic violence, was administered by Hughes to Heard.

Catalog entry →
Documents Admitted

Depp–Falati Text Messages, Oct 31, 2015

Text messages between Johnny Depp and Erin Falati dated October 31, 2015, produced from Depp's own records, in which Depp references the Australia finger injury with the phrase…

Catalog entry →
Documents Admitted

Hughes Expert Witness Training Presentation — National Clearinghouse

A PowerPoint presentation titled 'Expert Witness Testimony in Cases Involving Domestic Violence,' given by Hughes and Mary Ann Dutton to the National Clearinghouse for the Defense…

Catalog entry →
Documents Admitted

Hughes IPV Expert Witness Presentation — Kings County Bar Assoc.

A PowerPoint presentation titled 'The Use of Psychological Experts in Cases of Domestic Violence,' given by Hughes to the Kings County Bar Association, covering myths and…

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

PCL-5 — Hughes Administration (Heard)

The PCL-5, a face-value self-report checklist of DSM-5 PTSD symptoms, was administered by Hughes to Heard as part of her evaluation protocol.

Catalog entry →
Photographs Admitted

Plaintiff's Ex. 145 — ER Photo, Cigarette Burn on Depp's Cheek (Australia)

Emergency room photograph showing a cigarette burn wound on Johnny Depp's cheek, taken during the Australia incident. The photograph is among the images associated with Depp's…

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Audio recordings, text messages, emails, and kitchen video reviewed as part of evaluation

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

CTS-2 Instructions with Dennison Annotations (Demonstrative)

The published CTS-2 instructions bearing Dennison's redline annotations, introduced as Plaintiff's 1309 as a demonstrative exhibit.

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Danger Assessment Scale — Blank Test Form (Demonstrative)

A blank Danger Assessment Scale test form, published as a demonstrative exhibit and introduced as Plaintiff's 1310.

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Dawn Hughes 88-Page Supplemental Clinical Notes

Hughes's 88-page supplemental clinical notes prepared in connection with her evaluation of Heard.

Catalog entry →
Documents Excluded

Dawn Hughes Curriculum Vitae

The curriculum vitae of Dawn Hughes, Ph.D., submitted as Defendant's 1434.

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Dawn Hughes Deposition (March 28, 2022)

The pre-trial deposition of Dawn Hughes taken March 28, 2022.

Catalog entry →
Digital Communications Admitted

Depp to Kipper — March 19, 2015 Finger Injury Email

Email from Depp to Dr. David Kipper, dated March 19, 2015, in which Depp states 'I've chopped off my left middle finger,' introduced in redacted form as Defendant's Exhibit 398.

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Hughes 12-Instrument Psychological Testing Battery (Heard)

Hughes administered a battery of 12 psychological instruments to Heard: the PAI, TSI-2, M-FAST, PCL-5, CAPS-5, Beck Depression Inventory, Beck Anxiety Inventory, Mood Disorders…

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Hughes Comprehensive Therapy Records Review

Set of therapy records reviewed by Dr. Dawn Hughes encompassing records of Dr. Bonnie Jacobs (2011–2014), Dr. Connell Cowan (2014–2015), Dr. Laurel Anderson, and Dr. Amy Banks,…

Catalog entry →
Documents Admitted

Hughes Intake Background Information Sheet (Plaintiff's 938)

A background information sheet from Hughes's evaluation of Heard, previously admitted into evidence as Plaintiff's 938.

Catalog entry →
Documents Admitted

Hughes Intake Background Questionnaire (Plaintiff's 1246)

The background information questionnaire completed by Hughes during her initial intake evaluation of Amber Heard, including sections on intimate relationships noting James Franco…

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

M-FAST — Hughes Administration (Heard)

The M-FAST, a forensic assessment instrument designed to detect feigned psychiatric symptoms, was administered by Hughes to Heard as the sole malingering measure in her evaluation.

Catalog entry →
Documents Admitted

PCL-5 Instruction Manual (National Center for PTSD)

The official PCL-5 instruction manual published by the National Center for PTSD, introduced as Plaintiff's 1312.

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Testimony and Depositions Reviewed by Hughes

Deposition and trial testimony of Heard and Depp from both U.S. and UK proceedings, plus depositions of therapists Bonnie Jacobs, Connell Cowan, and Amy Banks, reviewed by Dr.…

Catalog entry →
Documents Unclear

Three Waldman Statements April–June 2020 (Hughes Basis)

The three public statements issued by Adam Waldman on April 8, April 27, and June 24, 2020, considered together as a set during Dawn Hughes's expert testimony.

Catalog entry →