Skip to content
personpersonMichael SpindlerMichael SpindlerForensic accountant who assessed Depp’s claimed lost earnings and challenged Heard’s damages analysis.← All People
Expert witness

Michael Spindler

Courtroom still of Michael Spindler.

Forensic accountant who assessed Depp’s claimed lost earnings and challenged Heard’s damages analysis.

170 lines·5 proceedings

About

Michael Spindler testified as an economic damages expert for Depp. His estimate compared Depp’s actual earnings with expected earnings based on 2017 and included a proposed Pirates film role based on agent Jack Whigham’s testimony. A chart presented to the jury put the total claimed loss at about $40.3 million. On cross-examination, Rottenborn questioned the absence of a written contract for the film role and the choice of 2017 as a baseline. Spindler defended that year as recent and one Whigham had described as typical. His calculation did not establish what caused the claimed losses.

Recalled to address Kathryn Arnold’s damages analysis for Heard, Spindler criticized her comparable-actor approach as insufficiently supported and used Heard’s historical earnings as an alternative baseline. He did not offer an opinion on whether the Depp/Waldman statements affected her career or on her future earning potential.

Trial Record (5)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022Called by plaintiff

Forensic accountant who assessed Depp’s claimed lost earnings and challenged Heard’s damages analysis.

Day 13

DirectDirect Examination of Michael SpindlerMichael SpindlerWayne Dennison4highlights44lines spoken

Summary

Forensic accountant Spindler testified to $40.3M in Depp lost earnings: $20.25M net from the lost Pirates 6 role and ~$20M net from reduced non-franchise bookings post-op-ed.

Highlights (4)

Quote“I concluded that Mr. Depp suffered lost earnings of about $30 million.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler's oral summary figure, stated before the demonstrative chart was published; notably lower than the $40.3M grand total the chart ultimately showed.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“the loss related to the loss of that role and that franchise picture was $22.5 million, based on testimony provided by Mr. Jack Whigham”— Michael SpindlerIdentifies the Pirates 6 component as the largest single item and ties it explicitly to Whigham's testimony rather than independent calculation.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Mr. Whigham testified that that was a typical year for Mr. Depp, and it's also the most recent, clean year”— Michael SpindlerRationale for choosing 2017 as the damages baseline: both agent-confirmed as typical and uncontaminated by the op-ed's effects.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Well, that's grand total. That's the sum of those two components for total lost earnings of $40.3 million.”— Michael SpindlerFinal damages figure from the chart, higher than the $30M stated orally earlier in the examination.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
CrossCross-Examination of Michael SpindlerMichael SpindlerJ. Benjamin Rottenborn2highlights80lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn questioned Spindler about the absence of a written Pirates 6 contract, his choice of 2017 as a baseline, and the limits of his opinion on causation.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Correct. And I'm not acknowledging any of this being accurate. I'm just saying that that wasn't part of my calculations.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler attempts to preserve his credibility by clarifying he is not conceding the factual premises of Rottenborn's questions, only the scope of his analysis.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“That sounds like hyperbole to me. I didn't take that very seriously.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler dismisses Depp's own statement about refusing Pirates 6 for any sum, a response Rottenborn used to suggest the expert selectively weighed evidence favorable to his client.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
RedirectRedirect Examination of Michael SpindlerMichael SpindlerWayne Dennison2highlights3lines spoken

Summary

Two-question redirect in which Spindler defends his 2017 base year choice and earnings-comparison methodology; witness excused subject to recall.

Highlights (2)

Quote“2017 was a year in which Mr. Whigham indicated that that was a typical year for Mr. Depp. He had a studio. He had an independent. He had an endorsement deal.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler anchors the base year choice in Whigham's testimony and the composition of Depp's income that year, directly rebutting the cross-examination challenge that 2017 was an anomalous peak.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“You're taking a look at what Mr. Depp would have been expected to earn in a typical year, and then you're comparing that to the period of time where you're analyzing following the op-ed from December of 2018 through October 2020.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler restates the core logic of his damages model in plain terms, reinforcing that the methodology is a straightforward expected-versus-actual comparison tied directly to the op-ed.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 21

DirectDirect Examination of Michael SpindlerMichael SpindlerWayne Dennison3highlights17lines spoken

Summary

Forensic accountant Spindler testifies Arnold's damages analysis for Heard is methodologically unsupported, and presents Heard's historical earnings as a factual baseline.

Highlights (3)

Quote“It is not adequately supported, and it is unreasonable.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler's headline opinion on Arnold's damages analysis — the central purpose of his recall as a rebuttal expert.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“you also don't have the - any potential impact from the alleged defamatory Waldman statements that occurred in April of 2020. So 2019 is clean of all that.”— Michael SpindlerDefines the 'clean year' concept that anchors Spindler's historical-baseline methodology.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“That methodology was unsound. It's just unsupported. There are no numbers. There's no data that she provided in support for that.”— Michael SpindlerDirect attack on Arnold's comparable-actor methodology, the foundation of Heard's lost earnings claim.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
CrossCross Examination of Michael SpindlerMichael SpindlerJ. Benjamin Rottenborn3highlights26lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn's brief cross confirms Spindler's opinion is limited to rebutting Arnold's calculations and elicits that he has no experience calculating actress defamation damages.

Highlights (3)

Quote“There was a slight increase during that period of time in her earnings from 2013 through 2019.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler acknowledges an upward earnings trend in Heard's career through 2019, supporting the premise that her trajectory was positive before the alleged defamation.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“That's correct. I'm not testifying on causation issues.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler confirms he cannot speak to whether the Depp/Waldman statements caused Heard to lose roles, limiting the evidentiary reach of his rebuttal opinion.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“I've been involved in defamation cases, but I've not done the calculations as an expert.”— Michael SpindlerSpindler concedes he has no prior experience as a testifying expert on actress defamation damages, undercutting his authority to rebut Arnold's methodology.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶