Skip to content
personpersonElaine BredehoftElaine BredehoftTrial counsel for Amber Heard, examining witnesses and arguing her counterclaim.← All People
Attorney for DefendantCharlson Bredehoft Cohen Brown & Nadelhaft

Elaine Bredehoft

Courtroom still of Elaine Bredehoft.

Trial counsel for Amber Heard, examining witnesses and arguing her counterclaim.

8,875 lines·135 proceedings

About

Elaine Bredehoft represented Amber Heard in the 2022 defamation trial. She questioned prospective jurors, previewed Heard’s evidence in opening, and conducted Heard’s direct and redirect examinations. She pressed responding LAPD officers about their brief visit to the penthouse, the witnesses they did not interview, and the absence of photographs or a report. The officers testified that they saw no visible injuries on Heard. Bredehoft also questioned the department’s domestic-violence coordinator about officers’ duties when an injury is visible.

Bredehoft challenged forensic psychologist Shannon Curry about a dinner with Depp and his counsel before Curry was retained. Curry confirmed that she had formed no opinion on who abused whom. Bredehoft examined defense expert Dawn Hughes, who attributed Heard’s PTSD to Depp’s conduct; Depp’s counsel challenged Hughes’s testing methods, and Bredehoft gave Hughes an opportunity to respond on redirect.

On damages, Bredehoft questioned Depp’s agent Jack Whigham about his claim of a sixth Pirates film deal. Whigham acknowledged that he had seen no written document confirming it, but maintained that there was a verbal agreement and that the role was lost in early 2019. Disney executive Tina Newman testified that no company document referenced Heard’s op-ed, while noting that casting decisions were outside her authority. In closing, Bredehoft argued Heard’s counterclaim over Adam Waldman’s statements calling her allegations a hoax and sought damages for claimed career harm.

Trial Record (135)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022

Trial counsel for Amber Heard, examining witnesses and arguing her counterclaim.

Day 0

Day 1

OpeningOpening Statement — DefendantJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight108lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn and Bredehoft present Heard's opening, arguing the 2018 op-ed is First Amendment-protected policy advocacy, not defamation, and previewing evidence of Depp's abuse.

Highlights (1)

Quote“"I thought I had put the monster away for good."”— Elaine BredehoftBredehoft quotes Depp's own words to Heard after the first alleged assault, introducing the 'monster' framing that the defense returns to throughout the trial.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 2

Day 3

Day 4

Day 5

Day 7

Day 8

Day 9

colloquyExhibit Rulings Before Officer Saenz Deposition1highlight28lines spoken

Summary

Pre-deposition sidebar resolves exhibit admissibility for Officer Saenz testimony; incident report admitted, injury photos excluded for lack of foundation.

Highlights (1)

Quote“It's credibility. It's all credibility of showing her these pictures. No, I don't see an injury. No, I don't see it (indiscernible) carpeting. No, I don't see it. You know, that's what she's saying; no, I don't see it. No, I don't see the damage. It's credibility. Credibility is huge.”— Elaine BredehoftHeard's counsel articulates the strategic purpose of showing injury photos during the deposition — to establish that Officer Saenz saw no evidence of injury or damage.Open in transcript →
RedirectRedirect Examination of Melissa SaenzMelissa SaenzElaine Bredehoft1highlight12lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft's brief redirect reconfirms via elevator timestamps that Officers Saenz and Hadden spent approximately 15 minutes at the penthouse on May 21, 2016.

Highlights (1)

Quote“are you aware of any documentation that either you or Officer Hadden collected relating, in any manner, to your visit to the penthouse on May 21, 2016?”— Elaine BredehoftFrames the documentation-gap question that Saenz's 'No' answer closes out, underscoring the absence of any contemporaneous record beyond CAD entries.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 10

colloquyExhibit Rulings for Wasser, Carino, and Dougherty Depositions1highlight77lines spoken

Summary

Pre-deposition sidebar where Judge Azcarate ruled on exhibit admissibility for three upcoming deposition playbacks: Laura Wasser, Christian Carino, and ACLU's Terence Dougherty.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Still hearsay, Your Honor, and relevance because the only thing that's at issue in this case is what ultimately was published and whether that was defamatory.”— Elaine BredehoftDefense's recurring objection to op-ed drafting and editing emails, articulating the argument that pre-publication communications are irrelevant to the defamation claim.Open in transcript →

Day 11

Day 12

Day 13

Day 14

Day 15

Day 16

Day 17

colloquyPhoto Metadata Ruling; Deposition De-Designation Dispute2highlights22lines spoken

Summary

Judge sustains objection to Heard's photo metadata exhibits and rules Heard's team may continue de-designating deposition clips under the 61-hour time constraint.

Highlights (2)

Quote“we believe that we should be able to get those in on the foundation/hearsay. If they challenge the legitimacy, then in rebuttal, we have an expert to say those are legitimate photos.”— Elaine BredehoftBredehoft's argument for admitting the photo metadata exhibits — that Heard's testimony provided foundation and an expert was available for rebuttal — which the court rejected.Open in transcript →
Quote“Yes, Your Honor, when Your Honor cut us back to 61 hours, we were in huge trouble, and we needed to cut a lot of testimony, and that's what we did.”— Elaine BredehoftExplains Heard's team's rationale for de-designating deposition clips after the court imposed a 61-hour overall time limit on the defense case.Open in transcript →

Day 18

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Pennington Photo Timestamp Ruling1highlight3lines spoken

Summary

Court signed a juror order and ruled on admissibility of photo timestamps for Raquel Pennington's deposition, distinguishing iPhone display data from extracted metadata.

Highlights (1)

Quote“But Ms. Heard did testify that she did put those on here. She gave the foundation testimony.”— Elaine BredehoftHeard's counsel argues Heard's own prior testimony supplies the foundation for the photo timestamps.Open in transcript →

Day 19

RedirectRedirect Examination of Michele MulrooneyMichele MulrooneyElaine Bredehoft1highlight2lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft's two-question redirect confirms no further postnuptial communications followed Depp's call, and that Mulrooney had no doubt Depp was the caller.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Was it any doubt in your mind that it was Mr. Depp who called you?”— Elaine BredehoftFrames the final redirect question, locking in Mulrooney's certainty of Depp's identity.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 20

Day 21

CrossCross Examination of Morgan NightMorgan NightElaine Bredehoft2highlights65lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft impeaches Night via his pro-Depp tweet and connection to Depp's first wife, then constrains his testimony to a brief, partial view of the Hicksville visit.

Highlights (2)

Quote“you seized the moment and responded to the Umbrella Guy, the lead person for Mr. Depp's Twitters; did you not?”— Elaine BredehoftFrames Night's tweet as opportunistic engagement with Depp's social media network rather than a spontaneous, neutral reaction.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“That never happened. I was with them all night. Amber was the one acting all jealous and crazy.”— Elaine BredehoftBredehoft reads Night's own tweet aloud, placing his characterization of Heard into the record as a prior out-of-court statement.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 22

colloquyRebuttal Expert Exclusion; Depp Returns to Testify1highlight5lines spoken

Summary

Post-recess sidebar excludes Dr. Collins as rebuttal expert; Neumeister ruling deferred to noon; defense discloses Hughes and Heard as rebuttal witnesses; Depp recalled.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Yes, Your Honor, we're planning on calling Dr. Hughes and Amber Heard. That's it. And both are relatively short.”— Elaine BredehoftDefense formally discloses its rebuttal case, signaling the trial is near conclusion.Open in transcript →
CrossCross Examination of Morgan TremaineMorgan TremaineElaine Bredehoft2highlights21lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft challenged Tremaine's motives and probed whether TMZ's tips about Heard's TRO filing originated from Depp's own legal team.

Highlights (2)

Quote“And so this gets you your 15 minutes of fame, doesn't it?”— Elaine BredehoftBredehoft's direct credibility attack on Tremaine's motive for testifying, suggesting he sought publicity from the nationally televised trial.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Do you know whether Blair Berk, one-of Mr. Depp's divorce attorneys, has a very close -- had a very close relationship with TMZ at that 'time?”— Elaine BredehoftBredehoft introduces the possibility that Depp's own divorce counsel had a pipeline to TMZ, redirecting suspicion about the source of insider tips away from Heard's camp.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
CrossCross-Examination of Beverly LeonardBeverly LeonardElaine Bredehoft1highlight9lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft's brief cross challenged Leonard's credibility, noting she contacted Depp's counsel only the night before testifying—13 years after the 2009 incident.

Highlights (1)

Quote“And so you know that if you have something that might be significant to say, that that way you can get on television, right?”— Elaine BredehoftBredehoft's core credibility challenge—implying Leonard's motive for coming forward was media exposure rather than civic duty.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 23

Day 24

closing argument counterclaimClosing Argument — Counterclaim (Heard's Team)Elaine Bredehoft4highlights92lines spoken

Summary

Bredehoft presents Heard's counterclaim closing, arguing Waldman's three statements were defamatory, the May 21 incident was not staged, and seeking career and emotional damages.

Highlights (4)

Quote“He has never accepted responsibility for anything in his life.”— Elaine BredehoftCentral thesis of the counterclaim closing — Bredehoft frames the lawsuit itself as Depp's pattern of refusing accountability.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“We've reached the beginning of the end of Ms. Heard's abuse hoax against Johnny Depp.”— Elaine BredehoftVerbatim text of Waldman's third defamatory statement, presented as the clearest example of false defamatory meaning in the counterclaim.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“both the corporate designees for ACLU and for Children's Hospital said donation and pledge are interchangeable”— Elaine BredehoftDirectly rebuts Depp's team's argument that Heard's charitable pledge was not a real donation and therefore undermined her stated motive.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“over 2.36 million negative tweets, negative Instagrams, negative social media comments, about Amber that relate specifically to the information that was in those three defamatory statements”— Elaine BredehoftRon Schnell's social media tracking data quantifying the downstream reach and ongoing harm of the Waldman statements.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 25

Day 26