Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewLeo J. PresiadoElaine BredehoftChristian CarinoWilliam GatlinTyler HaddenAlejandro RomeroLaura WasserdirectcrossredirectcolloquyDay 10 - April 27, 2022Day 10 examined the May 21, 2016 penthouse incident through LAPD and building-staff testimony that exposed investigative gaps, then shifted to deposition evidence on career damages, post-TRO conduct, and divorce proceedings.
← Day 92022 Defamation TrialDay 11 →

Day 10 - April 27, 2022

LAPD and Building Witnesses; Career and Divorce Depositions

Judge Penney Azcarate
15Proceedings
6Pages
5Witnesses
2,874Lines
Day 10 of 27
Appearing:

Day 10 examined the May 21, 2016 penthouse incident through LAPD and building-staff testimony that exposed investigative gaps, then shifted to deposition evidence on career damages, post-TRO conduct, and divorce proceedings.

Full day summary

Day 10 centered almost entirely on the May 21, 2016 Eastern Columbia Building incident: two LAPD officers — Tyler Hadden and William Gatlin — each confirmed they observed no visible injuries on Heard, while Bredehoft used policy exhibits and protocol failures to challenge the weight of both conclusions. ECB front desk worker Alejandro Romero corroborated no observed injuries across multiple dates but conceded he could not detect makeup in video clips and acknowledged the photographed swelling was significant enough he likely would have noticed it. A pretrial sidebar shaped three upcoming deposition playbacks, admitting post-TRO reconciliation texts and a narrow ACLU pledge record while excluding op-ed drafting emails on hearsay grounds. Talent agent Christian Carino testified that Heard's accusations had the most dramatic impact on Depp's off-screen reputation and attributed the loss of Pirates of the Caribbean 6 to those allegations, though cross-examination revealed that attribution rested on industry inference and that Heard had never disclosed abuse to him as a mutual confidant. The day closed with divorce attorney Laura Wasser's deposition establishing California's community property framework, the no-notice May 27 TRO, and Wasser's belief that her firm probably retained ECB surveillance footage, without having searched for it or knowing its current location.

Video thumbnail7:19:56
Watch →

1. Tyler Hadden — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Probationary LAPD officer Tyler Hadden's complete testimony on the May 21, 2016 penthouse call — direct, cross, and redirect.

→
colloquy
Exhibit Admissions and Logistics
78 lines

Judge Azcarate and counsel place exhibit numbers on the record for witness testimony, clarifying admissions for Saenz materials and establishing which exhibits will be shown to Hadden and Officer Gatlin.

Direct
Direct Examination of Tyler Hadden Tyler Hadden Elaine Bredehoft
334 lines

LAPD Officer Tyler Hadden, a probationary officer responding to the May 21, 2016 domestic violence call, testifies he saw no injuries on Heard and logged the incident as a verbal dispute.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Tyler Hadden Tyler Hadden Benjamin Chew
86 lines

Depp's counsel establishes Hadden had clear views of Heard's face on two occasions and saw no injuries, swelling, or property damage on May 21, 2016.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Tyler Hadden Tyler Hadden Elaine Bredehoft
116 lines

Bredehoft presses Hadden on investigative gaps: uninterviewed witnesses, unasked questions, and LAPD protocol steps neither officer followed on May 21, 2016.

Highlights

3. Alejandro Romero — Direct/Cross/Redirect

ECB front desk worker Romero testifies on Heard's appearance around March 25 and May 24, 2016; complete direct, cross, and redirect on this page.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Alejandro Romero Alejandro Romero Elaine Bredehoft
198 lines

ECB front desk worker testifies he noticed no injuries on Heard on May 25, 2016, but Bredehoft establishes he was not actively observing Heard's face.

Cross
Cross Examination of Alejandro Romero Alejandro Romero Leo J. Presiado
47 lines

Presiado asks Romero about March 25 encounters, when he says he saw no bruising, marks, or swelling. Asked about May 24, Romero says he does not recall seeing anything; on redirect he says he does not remember seeing Heard that day.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Alejandro Romero Alejandro Romero Elaine Bredehoft
49 lines

Bredehoft redirects Romero to establish he had no memory of Heard on May 23–24 and could not identify whether Heard wore concealing makeup in the cross-examination videos.

Highlights

5. Christian Carino — Direct/Cross

CAA talent agent Christian Carino testifies on Depp's career impact and Pirates 6, then faces cross on his dual loyalties and Heard's reconciliation texts.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Christian Carino Christian Carino Elaine Bredehoft
337 lines

CAA talent agent Christian Carino testifies about Depp's reputation and career, attributing the loss of Pirates 6 to Heard's allegations while maintaining Depp's acting reputation remained unchanged.

Procedural
Afternoon Recess and Exhibit Ruling
47 lines

After a 15-minute recess, the court addresses a sidebar on admitting Exhibit 1639, a business record; Depp's counsel objects on hearsay grounds, and the judge sustains the objection.

Cross
Cross Examination of Christian Carino Christian Carino Leo J. Presiado
384 lines

Carino, mutual confidant to Depp and Heard, testifies he arranged a secret post-TRO reconciliation meeting at Heard's request and never witnessed or was told of any abuse.

Highlights

Direct Examination of Christian CarinoTalent agent Carino testifies that Heard's accusations had 'the most dramatic impact' on Depp's off-screen reputation and attributes the loss of Pirates of the Caribbean 6 to those allegations — though his attribution rests on industry inference rather than explicit statements from Disney or Bruckheimer.Direct Examination of Christian Carino“My opinion is that Amber's accusations would have had the most dramatic impact on his off-screen reputation. I'm not talking about any one specific accusation.”— Christian CarinoCarino's most direct attribution of reputational harm to Heard's allegations — the central statement supporting Depp's damages theory for the day, though cross-examination immediately limited its inferential basis.Cross Examination of Christian CarinoCross-examination of Carino introduces texts showing Heard expressing ongoing love for Depp and characterizing her Musk relationship as 'filling space,' while establishing that Heard — who spoke to Carino throughout the relationship — never disclosed abuse to their mutual confidant.Cross Examination of Christian Carino“She promised me and told me to relay to him that she would never accuse him of violating the restraining order as a result of agreeing to meet her.”— Christian CarinoDocuments Heard's role in arranging and framing the post-TRO San Francisco reconciliation meeting, portraying her as the driving force behind contact with Depp while the restraining order she obtained was still in effect.

6. Laura Wasser — Direct

Depp's divorce attorney Laura Wasser testifies on California community property law, the May 27 ex parte DVTRO, and ECB building surveillance footage.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Laura Wasser Laura Wasser Elaine Bredehoft
272 lines

Heard's counsel examines Depp's divorce attorney Laura Wasser by deposition on California property law, the May 2016 ex parte TRO, ECB surveillance footage, and the August 2016 settlement.

Procedural
Jury Dismissal and Next Day Scheduling
12 lines

Judge dismisses jury for the day and schedules tomorrow's deposition and remote witness testimony, noting her need for a lunch break.

← Day 92022 Defamation TrialDay 11 →