Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewAndrew CrawfordWayne DennisonSamuel MonizElaine BredehoftAdam NadelhaftJ. Benjamin RottenbornMalcolm ConnollyTerence DoughertyStarling Jenkins IIIEdward WhitedirectcrossredirectDay 11 - April 28, 2022Day 11 concluded the ACLU donation thread with Dougherty's cross, heard financial testimony from CPA Edward White — impeached with his UK "catastrophic" characterization — then shifted to security witnesses Connolly and Jenkins on Australia and the April 2016 penthouse.
← Day 102022 Defamation TrialDay 12 →

Day 11 - April 28, 2022

ACLU Pledges and Payments, Edward White and Security Witnesses

Judge Penney Azcarate
14Proceedings
4Pages
4Witnesses
2,579Lines
Day 11 of 27
Appearing:

Day 11 concluded the ACLU donation thread with Dougherty's cross, heard financial testimony from CPA Edward White — impeached with his UK "catastrophic" characterization — then shifted to security witnesses Connolly and Jenkins on Australia and the April 2016 penthouse.

Full day summary

Day 11 opened with Chew's direct examination of ACLU COO Terence Dougherty on the payment breakdown credited toward Heard's pledge and the ACLU's role in drafting the op-ed. Bredehoft then cross-examined him, working to reframe the $2.2M shortfall in Heard's pledge as a semantic distinction between "donate" and "pledge" and establishing that Heard acted on legal advice throughout the op-ed process. CPA Edward White then testified that Depp was alert and engaged at the April 21, 2016 financial meeting, but Rottenborn impeached him with his own UK trial characterization of that same meeting as "catastrophic," and used a redacted Tracey Jacobs text reporting five-hour lateness for Pirates 5 ADR work, admitted only to impeach White's claimed lack of awareness. Security guard Malcolm Connolly described witnessing objects thrown at Depp on multiple occasions, recurring marks on Depp's face over time, and extracting Depp from a chaotic scene in Australia on the day of the finger injury — cross-examination exposed financial bias, omissions from his UK witness statement, and gaps in direct observation. Long-serving chauffeur Starling Jenkins III testified that Heard disclosed the April 21–22 altercation on the morning of April 22 and characterized the bed defecation as "a horrible practical joke gone wrong," while cross-examination impeached him with a UK statement contradicting his account of Depp's phone recovery and catalogued his absence from every other key incident.

1. Terence Dougherty — Direct/Cross

ACLU COO Dougherty testifies on Heard's $3.5M donation pledge — $1.3M paid to date — and discloses the ACLU drafted the Washington Post op-ed.

→
Procedural
Exhibit Submission and Jury Entry
18 lines

Judge addresses preliminary matters, Bredehoft submits Defendant's Exhibit 1246 (redacted), and jury enters as Terence Dougherty is called to testify.

Direct
Direct Examination of Terence Dougherty Terence Dougherty Benjamin Chew
889 lines

ACLU COO confirms Heard paid $1.3M of a pledged $3.5M donation, and that ACLU staff drafted the 2018 Washington Post op-ed, timing its release to coincide with Aquaman.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Terence Dougherty Terence Dougherty Elaine Bredehoft
105 lines

Bredehoft cross-examines ACLU's Dougherty on the donate/pledge distinction, payment timeline, and Heard's reliance on attorney advice during op-ed drafting.

Procedural
Extended Lunch and Witness Scheduling
23 lines

Judge extends lunch recess to 2:30 p.m. for a remote witness testimony expected to exceed 30 minutes, instructs the jury, and swears in Edward White as the next witness.

Highlights

2. Edward White — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Depp's accountant testifies on the $14.25M divorce settlement and charity payments, then faces impeachment on Depp's financial state and Heard's donation pledge.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Edward White Edward White Wayne Dennison
204 lines

Depp's accountant testified about the April 21, 2016 meeting, settlement negotiations totaling $14.25M, charity payments, and Heard's wine orders at the birthday party.

Cross
Cross Examination of Edward White Edward White J. Benjamin Rottenborn
366 lines

Rottenborn impeaches Depp's business manager on prior oath statements about financial catastrophe, Depp's work punctuality, and the nature of Heard's charitable pledge.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Edward White Edward White Wayne Dennison
17 lines

Dennison elicits the pledge letter language confirming Heard's $3.5M gift as installment-based, then closes by confirming Depp is fully current on all taxes.

Highlights

3. Malcolm Connolly — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Security guard Malcolm Connolly's complete testimony: direct on Heard's behavior and the Australia incident, cross on financial bias and UK omissions, brief redirect on observation conditions.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Malcolm Connolly Malcolm Connolly Samuel Moniz
298 lines

Depp's security guard Malcolm Connolly testified remotely about arguments, objects thrown by Heard, recurring marks on Depp, and the chaotic Australia finger-injury day.

Cross
Cross Examination of Malcolm Connolly Malcolm Connolly Adam Nadelhaft
303 lines

Defense cross-examined Connolly on financial ties to Depp, gaps in direct observation, UK testimony omissions, and played an audio clip of Depp's agitated state in Australia.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Malcolm Connolly Malcolm Connolly Samuel Moniz
16 lines

Moniz briefly redirected on Connolly's observation conditions in Australia: roughly 3-4 feet from Heard for 15-20 seconds in faint stairwell light.

Highlights

4. Starling Jenkins III — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Depp's driver and security guard Starling Jenkins III testifies about the April 21–22 penthouse aftermath, then faces impeachment on cross via his UK trial statement.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Starling Jenkins III Starling Jenkins III Andrew Crawford
144 lines

Depp's longtime driver and security testified he saw no injuries on Heard after the April 21 penthouse incident and that she described the bed defecation as a "practical joke gone wrong."

Cross
Cross-Examination of Starling Jenkins III Starling Jenkins III J. Benjamin Rottenborn
146 lines

Rottenborn questioned Jenkins about his employment and loyalty to Depp, his phone-location testimony and UK statement, and a series of incidents he did not witness.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Starling Jenkins III Starling Jenkins III Andrew Crawford
29 lines

Crawford completed Rottenborn's partial UK statement quote and clarified Amber — not Whitney — was sick at Coachella before Jenkins was released.

Procedural
Jury Instructions and Trial Scheduling
21 lines

Judge dismisses jury with standard end-of-week instructions on media avoidance and communication restrictions, then discusses deposition scheduling with attorneys.

Highlights

← Day 102022 Defamation TrialDay 12 →