Starling Jenkins III

“I arrived early, 10:45, went upstairs to the penthouse. I was informed by Amber that she got in a fight with Johnny last night. She threw his personal property over the balcony into the streets, 9th and Broadway.”

Heard's own disclosure to Jenkins on the morning of April 22, 2016, providing a firsthand account of the altercation's aftermath from a neutral employee.

“$420, chicken tacos, chips, apple, Fiji water.”

The reward paid to recover Depp's phone from a homeless man in skid row — illustrates the concrete consequences of the property-throwing incident.

“No marks, no injuries.”

Direct eyewitness denial of visible injuries on Heard the morning after the alleged April 21–22 incident.

“A horrible practical joke gone wrong.”

Jenkins's recounting of Heard's own words characterizing the bed defecation — offered without prompting by Heard herself during the drive to Coachella.

“Eating magic mushrooms and drinking red wine on an empty stomach.”

Jenkins's firsthand account of the cause of Heard's illness at Coachella, based on what he personally observed in the hotel room and vehicle.

“Him and his family. And his family.”

Jenkins' instinctive qualifier on his loyalty — repeating 'and his family' — illustrates the depth of the relationship Rottenborn is using to frame his bias argument.

“If that's what it says, that's what it says. I'm telling you the phone was in skid row.”

Jenkins' response to being confronted with his own UK witness statement — he neither accepts nor coherently explains the contradiction.

“What abuse?”

Jenkins' unrehearsed reaction when asked about Heard seeking comfort with friends after alleged abuse — reveals his personal disbelief and reinforces the bias framing.

“I walked out onto the street, did not see the phone. I then asked several homeless people if they had the phone. One homeless man admitted to me that he had the phone, returned the phone to me in exchange for the following: 425 in cash, three chicken tacos, two bags of chips, four apples - two apples, four bottles of water.”

Completes the paragraph Rottenborn partially quoted on cross; the full text confirms the phone was recovered from a homeless man on the street, consistent with Jenkins' trial testimony.

“Amber was sick.”

Directly clarifies that Jenkins' Coachella observations — including no visible injuries — pertained to Amber Heard, not her sister Whitney.