Skip to content
personpersonJ. Benjamin RottenbornJ. Benjamin RottenbornTrial counsel for Amber Heard in her defamation defense and counterclaim.← All People
Attorney for DefendantWoods Rogers

J. Benjamin Rottenborn

Courtroom still of J. Benjamin Rottenborn.

Trial counsel for Amber Heard in her defamation defense and counterclaim.

4,956 lines·73 proceedings

About

A Woods Rogers attorney, Rottenborn represented Amber Heard in Fairfax County alongside Elaine Bredehoft. In opening and closing arguments, he focused on the scope of Heard’s op-ed, which did not name Johnny Depp, and argued that Depp had to prove each element of his defamation claims.

Rottenborn cross-examined Depp using texts, recordings and the parties’ joint divorce statement, which said neither had made false accusations for financial gain. He questioned whether Depp’s career losses predated the op-ed and whether the op-ed caused the losses calculated by Depp’s economic expert. Depp characterized his texts to Paul Bettany about harming Heard as Monty Python humor and denied abusing her. Rottenborn also questioned Raquel Pennington about the May 2016 penthouse confrontation and photographs of Heard’s injuries. Pennington described what she saw but said she did not see Depp strike or throw anything at Heard.

Rottenborn presented hand surgeon Richard Moore, who considered Depp’s finger injury inconsistent with Depp’s account of a thrown vodka bottle. On cross-examination, Moore acknowledged that he had not examined Depp and could not definitively rule out a bottle. When questioning opposing expert Richard Gilbert, Rottenborn established that Gilbert was not offering a causation opinion and corrected his characterization of Heard’s testimony: she had said she did not know how the injury occurred.

On Heard’s counterclaim, Rottenborn questioned Adam Waldman about his public statements calling her allegations a hoax and his contacts with social media personalities. He also elicited Heard’s account of harassment and career harm she attributed to those statements. In rebuttal closing, he argued that Waldman’s statements were attributable to Depp as his agent.

Trial Record (73)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022

Trial counsel for Amber Heard in her defamation defense and counterclaim.

Day 1

OpeningOpening Statement — DefendantJ. Benjamin Rottenborn3highlights74lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn and Bredehoft present Heard's opening, arguing the 2018 op-ed is First Amendment-protected policy advocacy, not defamation, and previewing evidence of Depp's abuse.

Highlights (3)

Quote“You're being asked to decide a very simple question, and that question is, were the words that Amber used in the December 18th, 2018 opinion piece, that was published in the Washington Post, protected, free speech under the First Amendment or not?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornDefines Heard's core trial theory: the case turns solely on First Amendment protection, not on the truth or falsity of abuse allegations.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“He wants to turn this case into a six-week long, public spectacle of the most intimate aspects of their relationship and their marriage.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornFrames Depp's litigation strategy as designed to humiliate Heard rather than vindicate a legitimate legal claim.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Johnny Depp's reputation is in tatters. His career is in free fall. But it's because of problems that he created. Problems that he is responsible for.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornCentral damages argument: Depp's career decline is self-caused by substance abuse and behavior, not caused by the op-ed.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 2

CrossCross Examination of Christi Dembrowski (Continued)Christi DembrowskiJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight225lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn uses Dr. Kipper's email and Christi's own texts to establish that concerns about Depp's substance abuse and on-set conduct came from sources beyond Amber Heard.

Highlights (1)

Quote“I love him so much, but he needs help, and I don't have all the information to help alone.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads Christi's own May 2014 text to Amber aloud, placing her admission that Depp 'needs help' into the record against her minimizing testimony.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 3

DirectDirect Examination of Kate JamesKate JamesJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight257lines spoken

Summary

Heard's counsel questions ex-personal assistant on Waldman contacts, absence of observed violence, and impeaches her with contradictory UK trial testimony about a Depp text.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Do you see where he says Will hit you when I get back doll Come over for a spot of purple and we'll fix her flabby ass nice and good”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads Depp's August 2016 text aloud to the jury, establishing the predicate for the UK-testimony impeachment on its meaning.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
DirectDirect Examination of Gina DeutersGina DeutersSamuel Moniz1highlight1line spoken

Summary

Depp friend Gina Deuters testifies about his substance use and her observations of Heard's behavior, before a sidebar over her social media posts interrupts the examination.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Our dear friend got a few wins in court this week, and, yet, some of us continue to belittle him”— J. Benjamin RottenbornExcerpt from Deuters's social media post read aloud at sidebar, directly triggering the witness credibility issue and jury dismissal.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 4

Day 5

CrossCross Examination of Sean BettSean BettJ. Benjamin Rottenborn2highlights197lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn challenges Bett's credibility through text message impeachment, deposition contradictions, and surveillance video showing a 90-minute stay Bett had significantly underestimated.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Steaks were excellent and pondering, though we will likely have dinner here. Steaks were excellent. A couple of bottles of perfect wine. We then pounded an entire bottle of tequila!!! Then the savagery commenced!! Good morning!!!”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads Depp's own text aloud, directly contradicting Bett's prior testimony that he had seen Depp drink only a glass or two of wine at a time.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“I prevented them from calling po-po. Glad you had fun. You mean dinner in room or restaurant?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads Bett's reply text, establishing that Bett himself acknowledged preventing a police call and expressed approval of Depp's conduct — undercutting his role as a neutral security professional.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 6

CrossCross Examination of Johnny DeppJohnny DeppJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight77lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn challenges Depp on the op-ed's limited scope, questions his awareness of a pre-op-ed report about Disney cutting ties; Depp denies prior awareness, and introduces a divorce document stating neither party made false accusations for financial gain.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Neither party has made false accusations for financial gain.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornReading aloud the joint divorce statement Depp signed in 2016 — used to challenge his defamation narrative at its foundation.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 7

CrossCross Examination of Johnny Depp (Continued)Johnny DeppJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight1,296lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn impeached Depp with violent texts about Heard, drug-use admissions contradicting claimed sobriety, and inconsistencies in his Australia finger-injury account.

Highlights (1)

Quote“I got drunk and destroyed my room. There are hookers and animals in here.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reading verbatim from Depp's April 2012 email to Deuters, admitted as Exhibit 143.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 8

Day 9

colloquyExhibit Rulings Before Officer Saenz Deposition1highlight5lines spoken

Summary

Pre-deposition sidebar resolves exhibit admissibility for Officer Saenz testimony; incident report admitted, injury photos excluded for lack of foundation.

Highlights (1)

Quote“To your point, Your Honor, that's exactly why the pictures need to come in now. Otherwise, the jury's not going to know what Officer Saenz is talking about. In closing, when the officer says she didn't see anything in these pictures, they're going to have no idea.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn argues the photos are necessary context for the jury to follow Saenz's deposition testimony and closing argument references.Open in transcript →

Day 11

CrossCross Examination of Edward WhiteEdward WhiteJ. Benjamin Rottenborn3highlights178lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn impeaches Depp's business manager on prior oath statements about financial catastrophe, Depp's work punctuality, and the nature of Heard's charitable pledge.

Highlights (3)

Quote“She didn't pay $5 million to blast Hunter Thompson's ashes out of a cannon, did she?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn contrasts Heard's financial conduct with Depp's spending habits to undercut the premise that she bore responsibility for his financial problems.Open in transcript →
Quote“And the reason I'm asking, sir, is because you just gave the exact opposite testimony here. So that's why we pointed that out.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornEncapsulates the impeachment after White's UK trial testimony calling the April 21 briefing 'catastrophic' directly contradicted his trial testimony.Open in transcript →
Quote“I got a call from Disney last week saying he showed up five hours late for ADR work in London for Pirates 5. I really need to speak to him before he starts work on his next project in LA”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads the admitted Tracey Jacobs text aloud, establishing White had prior knowledge of Depp's on-set punctuality problems despite denying it.Open in transcript →
CrossCross-Examination of Starling Jenkins IIIStarling Jenkins IIIJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight73lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn questioned Jenkins about his employment and loyalty to Depp, his phone-location testimony and UK statement, and a series of incidents he did not witness.

Highlights (1)

Quote“So one of these two sworn statements, either what you just said in court just now that it was found six miles away or this, one of these is false, correct?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornThe impeachment pivot — Rottenborn frames the contradiction as a binary between two sworn statements, one of which must be false.Open in transcript →

Day 12

CrossCross Examination of Travis McGivernTravis McGivernJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight70lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn challenges McGivern's account of the March 23, 2015 incident using his UK trial witness statement and establishes he was absent from most disputed incidents.

Highlights (1)

Quote“When Ms. Lloyd and I entered his residence, Ms. Heard and Mr. Depp were having a verbal argument.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads aloud from McGivern's UK witness statement, which directly contradicts his direct testimony that he met Heard in the lobby before entering the penthouse.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 13

CrossCross-Examination of Michael SpindlerMichael SpindlerJ. Benjamin Rottenborn2highlights87lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn questioned Spindler about the absence of a written Pirates 6 contract, his choice of 2017 as a baseline, and the limits of his opinion on causation.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Despite the fact that 2017, he made more than twice as much as he's made in any year over the last five years, correct?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornFrames the 2017 base year as a statistical outlier, implying Spindler's selection inflated the projected damages by anchoring to an unrepresentative peak year.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“So if 2017 was clean, then the first 352 days of 2018 were also clean, weren't they, sir?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn's sharpest methodological challenge: the op-ed was published December 18, 2018, so Spindler's rationale for excluding all of 2018 as a base year is internally inconsistent.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
colloquyMotion to Strike Argued; Plaintiff Rests, Defense Begins1highlight50lines spoken

Summary

Plaintiff rests; defense moves to strike all three defamatory statements; judge denies as to statements 2 and 3 and takes statement 1 under advisement.

Highlights (1)

Quote“if Mr. Depp abused Ms. Heard, physically, verbally, emotionally, or psychologically even one time, then she wins on those claims. Then she wins.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornCore argument of the motion to strike: undisputed nonphysical abuse by Depp renders the domestic abuse statements non-false as a matter of law.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 16

colloquyMotion to Admit Heard's Prior Violence Incidents1highlight30lines spoken

Summary

Judge rules at sidebar on Depp's motion to admit Heard's alleged prior violent conduct toward Tasya van Ree and Rocky Pennington for impeachment.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Whether Ms. Heard was abusive to Mr. Depp and whether she ever committed abuse towards someone else is not an essential element of any claim or defense in this case. It's just not.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornCore of Rottenborn's Rule 404/405 opposition, arguing the parties are asymmetrically situated with respect to character evidence.Open in transcript →

Day 17

Day 18

Day 19

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Alpaca Photo, TikTok Incident, Rebuttal Ruling2highlights9lines spoken

Summary

Judge reprimands Chew for violating her photography order near the courthouse, discloses a TikTok balcony incident involving courthouse staff's children, and limits Bercovici to rebuttal.

Highlights (2)

Quote“It's deeply troubling. It appears to be, I know it's up to you, a blatant violation of the Court's order.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn frames the alpaca photo as a court order violation with direct jury-integrity implications.Open in transcript →
Quote“Mr. Depp's online army of support is zealous, to say the least, and when things like this go viral, it only makes it harder for the jury to avoid.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn identifies Depp's large online following as a structural jury-contamination risk amplified by any courthouse media incident.Open in transcript →

Day 20

RedirectRedirect Examination of Richard MooreRichard MooreJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight21lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn rehabilitates defense hand expert Moore, who reaffirms that Depp's vodka-bottle account is inconsistent with the finger injury pattern.

Highlights (1)

Quote“the mechanism that was described by Mr. Depp and demonstrated by Mr. Depp is inconsistent with the injury pattern that's found on the images and the description.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads the truncated half of Moore's deposition answer, restoring the opinion Vasquez's selective reading had obscured: Depp's own account is inconsistent with the physical evidence.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 21

colloquySidebar — Dr. Kulber Admissibility and Scope1highlight43lines spoken

Summary

Sidebar resolves Dr. Kulber's admissibility as a rebuttal witness; court limits his testimony to the state of Depp's hand after the March 2015 finger surgery.

Highlights (1)

Quote“that's total sandbagging. It's gamesmanship. It's not appropriate”— J. Benjamin RottenbornDefense characterizes Depp's team's interrogatory response — pointing to a Bates range rather than naming Kulber — as a deliberate attempt to obscure a rebuttal witness.Open in transcript →
CrossCross Examination of David KulberDavid KulberJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight15lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn's brief cross establishes that Depp's March 2015 cast did not prevent use of his uninjured hand, conceded by Kulber.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Is there anything about the cast that was put on Mr. Depp's hand on March 20th, 2015, that would have prevented him from doing this damage to Ms. Heard's closet on March 23rd, 2015?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn asked whether the cast would have prevented the alleged closet damage three days after surgery.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
colloquyDefense Evidence Proffers for the Record4lines spoken

Summary

Defense counsel Nadelhaft proffers excluded testimony and exhibits from nine witnesses and the UK judgment for the appellate record, with distinct grounds including hearsay, improper expert opinion, speculation, and the finding that the door to the U.K. judgment had not been opened.

Day 22

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Rebuttal Witness Rulings1highlight37lines spoken

Summary

Sidebar rulings admit Beverly Leonard for limited impeachment, restrict Kate Moss to staircase testimony, and exclude Dr. Collins and Bryan Neumeister as rebuttal experts.

Highlights (1)

Quote“I just, in my head, instantly think of Kate Moss on the stairs when I swing at him.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn quotes Heard's trial testimony — the single sentence that opened the door to Kate Moss's appearance and defined the strict scope of her permitted testimony.Open in transcript →

Day 23

CrossCross-Examination of Richard GilbertRichard GilbertJ. Benjamin Rottenborn1highlight37lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn impeaches plaintiff's hand surgeon on the Australia finger injury theory, eliciting that he had read no report of hand movement; Gilbert explained a medical inference from the absent nailbed injury and rejected counsel's stronger characterization.

Highlights (1)

Quote“you're being paid a thousand dollars an hour for your work on this case, correct?”— J. Benjamin RottenbornOpens by framing Gilbert as a paid advocate, a standard bias challenge to expert witnesses.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
colloquyPlaintiff Rests; Motion to Strike Denied; Rebuttal Opens1highlight8lines spoken

Summary

Plaintiff rests rebuttal case; Heard's renewed motion to strike denied; jury sketch and jigsaw puzzle housekeeping; defense calls Julian Ackert.

Highlights (1)

Quote“the undisputed evidence shows that Mr. Depp did not -- did abuse Ms. Heard, at a minimum, emotionally, verbally, psychologically and otherwise. That's undisputed.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornCentral argument in the motion to strike: even a single act of abuse in any form would defeat Depp's defamation claim.Open in transcript →

Day 24

ClosingClosing Argument — Defendant (Rottenborn)J. Benjamin Rottenborn3highlights77lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn delivers Heard's closing, arguing the op-ed is First Amendment-protected, Depp cannot meet his burden of proof, and reviewing evidence of alleged abuse chronologically.

Highlights (3)

Quote“If you didn't take pictures, it didn't happen. If you did take pictures, they're fake. If you didn't tell your friends, you're lying. And if you did tell your friends, they're part of the hoax.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn's rhetorical framework summarizing what he characterizes as Depp's team's position on victim credibility, delivered as the opening of the closing argument.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“you cannot simultaneously protect and uphold the First Amendment and find in favor of Johnny Depp on his claim. You simply cannot.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornCore First Amendment argument framing the verdict as a choice between constitutional protection of speech and siding with Depp.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“it is time to tell Mr. Depp this was his last chance, tell him to move on with his life, tell him to let Amber move on with hers, stand up for the freedom of speech, stand up for the First Amendment.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn's closing words to the jury, framing the verdict as a statement on free speech rather than just the outcome of a private dispute.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
RebuttalDefendant's Rebuttal Closing ArgumentJ. Benjamin Rottenborn4highlights5lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn's rebuttal closing argues any single instance of abuse supports Heard's counterclaim, argues Depp's malice should be attributed to Waldman as Depp's agent, and closes with a direct jury appeal.

Highlights (4)

Quote“If you believe that Depp was abusive to Amber one time ever, in any of the various forms of abuse, not only physical, verbal, emotional, psychological, sexual, any of the ways of abuse, then your job is very easy.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornFrames the low threshold Rottenborn is urging for the jury's verdict on both the claim and counterclaim.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“the suggestion that Amber's abuse allegations are a hoax is vicious and vile.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornDirect characterization of Waldman's statements as the core of the defamation counterclaim.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶