Skip to content
personpersonRichard MooreRichard MooreHand surgeon who testified about the cause of Depp’s finger injury← All People
Witness

Richard Moore

Courtroom still of Richard Moore.

Hand surgeon who testified about the cause of Depp’s finger injury

190 lines·3 proceedings

About

Richard Moore, a hand surgeon with 25 years’ experience, testified for Amber Heard about Depp’s middle-finger injury in Australia. He said the intact fingernail and loss of tissue on the palm side did not fit the top-down vodka-bottle strike described in Depp’s testimony. He described the fracture shown on X-rays as consistent with a crush mechanism.

On cross-examination, Moore acknowledged that he had not examined Depp, had no firsthand knowledge of the incident, and had not reviewed Ben King’s testimony or photographs of the bar area. He said he could not rule out a vodka bottle under a different mechanism. On redirect, he maintained his opinion about the mechanism Depp described. Depp’s later rebuttal expert, Richard Gilbert, disagreed and said the injury was consistent with a bottle striking a hand resting on a marble bar.

Trial Record (3)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022Called by defendant

Hand surgeon who testified about the cause of Depp’s finger injury

Day 20

DirectDirect Examination of Richard MooreRichard MooreJ. Benjamin Rottenborn3highlights100lines spoken

Summary

Defense orthopedic expert Richard Moore testifies Depp's finger injury is inconsistent with a thrown vodka bottle, citing intact nail, palmar tissue loss, and absent glass.

Highlights (3)

Quote“Well, the medical data is inconclusive. It's not consistent with what we see in the described injury pattern or in the clinical photographs.”— Richard MooreMoore described the medical record as inconclusive and said the injury pattern did not match the mechanism Depp described.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“the mechanism described would have almost certainly led to severe nail injury. You know, I see no subungual hematoma.”— Richard MooreMoore said the intact nail did not fit the top-down bottle strike he was asked to evaluate.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“any mechanism that squeezes the finger between two hard, opposing surfaces could create this type of injury.”— Richard MooreMoore identified compression between two hard surfaces as one possible injury mechanism.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
CrossCross Examination of Richard MooreRichard MooreCamille Vasquez2highlights80lines spoken

Summary

Vasquez challenges Moore's finger-injury opinion, establishing he never examined Depp, didn't review bar-scene photos, and could not rule out a vodka bottle as the cause.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Well, I can't rule out that a vodka bottle caused the injury, but I can rule out that it was caused in the manner described in his testimony.”— Richard MooreMoore's central admission on cross: the object could have been a vodka bottle, undercutting the force of his opinion that the mechanism was inconsistent.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
RedirectRedirect Examination of Richard MooreRichard MooreJ. Benjamin Rottenborn2highlights10lines spoken

Summary

Rottenborn rehabilitates defense hand expert Moore, who reaffirms that Depp's vodka-bottle account is inconsistent with the finger injury pattern.

Highlights (2)

Quote“Mr. Depp indicated that he had cut his finger off.”— Richard MooreMoore distinguishes Depp's contemporaneous texts to Kipper — which mention only cutting his finger — from the vodka-bottle account raised in Kipper's deposition, undermining that version of events.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“it can be - it can be slightly off center, it would pinch that tissue away in a similar fashion. But because it's below the level of the nail bed, it could create this injury with the fracture and the tissue loss and preserve the nail bed”— Richard MooreMoore completes the explanation Vasquez cut short on cross, articulating how a door/hinge mechanism accounts for all observed features of the injury.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶