Skip to content
personpersonBenjamin ChewBenjamin ChewJohnny Depp’s attorney in the defamation trial against Amber Heard.← All People
Attorney for PlaintiffBrown Rudnick

Benjamin Chew

Courtroom still of Benjamin Chew.

Johnny Depp’s attorney in the defamation trial against Amber Heard.

2,646 lines·80 proceedings

About

Chew represented Johnny Depp in his defamation case against Amber Heard. In opening argument, he identified three statements from Heard’s 2018 Washington Post op-ed that Depp alleged were defamatory. He later questioned witnesses about the parties’ accounts of violence, Heard’s charitable pledge and Depp’s claimed career losses.

Chew questioned couples therapist Laurel Anderson about notes recording Heard’s reports that she had initiated physical confrontations. Anderson characterized the relationship as mutually abusive and said she had not witnessed violence herself. Chew also questioned ACLU executive Terence Dougherty, who testified that the organization had received $1.3 million from multiple sources toward Heard’s $3.5 million pledge and that ACLU staff prepared the op-ed’s first draft.

On Depp’s claimed career losses, Chew questioned agent Jack Whigham about a reported $22.5 million agreement for a sixth Pirates film. Heard’s counsel challenged the absence of a written contract and Whigham’s earlier account of when the deal faltered. On redirect, Chew elicited Whigham’s explanation that franchise paperwork can follow a verbal agreement and that Disney had not formally ruled Depp out when the op-ed appeared. Chew also questioned Kate Moss, who testified remotely that she slipped on wet stairs and denied that Depp pushed, kicked or threw her down them.

Chew opposed Heard’s motions to strike Depp’s claims and addressed the op-ed’s alleged defamatory implication, claimed damages and verdict form in closing argument. He also argued that attorney Adam Waldman was an independent contractor when Depp sought to strike Heard’s counterclaims; the judge denied that motion, finding sufficient evidence for the jury to consider agency and malice.

Trial Record (80)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022

Johnny Depp’s attorney in the defamation trial against Amber Heard.

Day 0

Day 1

OpeningOpening Statement — Plaintiff's CaseBenjamin Chew3highlights39lines spoken

Summary

Benjamin Chew and Camille Vasquez outline Depp's theory that Heard fabricated abuse allegations to control him and advance her career, causing irreparable harm to his reputation.

Highlights (3)

Quote“I spoke up against sexual violence and faced our culture's wrath.”— Benjamin ChewFirst of three op-ed statements identified as defamatory — the headline allegation of sexual violence that Depp argues was understood as directed at him.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“Two years ago, I became a public figure representing domestic abuse.”— Benjamin ChewSecond op-ed statement — the phrase Chew argues everyone in Hollywood understood as a reference to Depp, despite the absence of his name.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“I had the rare vantage point of seeing, in real time, how institutions protect men accused of abuse.”— Benjamin ChewThird op-ed statement — implies Heard personally witnessed systemic protection of Depp and grounds the defamation claim in specific factual assertion.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 2

Day 3

Day 4

Day 5

RedirectRedirect Examination of Keenan WyattKeenan WyattBenjamin Chew1highlight16lines spoken

Summary

Chew rehabilitates Wyatt on financial independence and elicits Wyatt's understanding that Depp's Pirates 5 lateness involved arguments with Heard; Wyatt had said he did not know the cause or Depp's alcohol and drug use at the house.

Highlights (1)

Quote“What was your understanding of why Mr. Depp was late occasionally on the set of Pirates 5?”— Benjamin ChewThe rehabilitative question that invited Wyatt to attribute on-set tardiness to Heard rather than substance abuse.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 6

Day 7

Day 8

Day 9

Day 10

Day 11

DirectDirect Examination of Terence DoughertyTerence DoughertyBenjamin Chew1highlight473lines spoken

Summary

ACLU COO confirms Heard paid $1.3M of a pledged $3.5M donation, and that ACLU staff drafted the 2018 Washington Post op-ed, timing its release to coincide with Aquaman.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Wondering if we might interest you in a piece by Amber Heard (who, as you may recall, was beaten up during her brief marriage to Johnny Depp) on what the incoming Congress can do to help protect women in similar situations.”— Benjamin ChewACLU staffer's internal pitch email to The Washington Post explicitly frames the op-ed around Heard's allegations against Depp — showing the ACLU understood the piece's implicit subject even as lawyers scrubbed Depp's name.Open in transcript →

Day 12

Day 13

colloquyMotion to Strike Argued; Plaintiff Rests, Defense Begins2highlights67lines spoken

Summary

Plaintiff rests; defense moves to strike all three defamatory statements; judge denies as to statements 2 and 3 and takes statement 1 under advisement.

Highlights (2)

Day 14

Day 16

colloquyMotion to Admit Heard's Prior Violence Incidents1highlight43lines spoken

Summary

Judge rules at sidebar on Depp's motion to admit Heard's alleged prior violent conduct toward Tasya van Ree and Rocky Pennington for impeachment.

Highlights (1)

Quote“She said "I know you don't come back from that. I mean, you can't hit a woman, you can't hit a man, you can't hit anyone."”— Benjamin ChewChew's key 'opening the door' argument — quoting Heard's own trial testimony to justify introducing her prior alleged violence.Open in transcript →

Day 17

Day 18

RedirectRedirect Examination of Josh DrewJosh DrewBenjamin Chew2highlights3lines spoken

Summary

Chew pressed Drew on an inconsistency: the dogs were too small to climb stairs, yet one could jump on the bed. Drew clarified one dog had both abilities, the other had neither.

Highlights (2)

Quote“You testified that the dogs were too small to climb the stairs; is that correct?”— Benjamin ChewChew pins Drew's prior testimony as the predicate for his redirect challenge on internal consistency.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“So it's your testimony that one of the dogs could -- had the ability to climb the stairs and jump on the bed and the other had neither?”— Benjamin ChewChew frames the logical inconsistency directly, forcing Drew to either confirm or clarify the apparent contradiction.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 19

colloquyPreliminary Matters — Alpaca Photo, TikTok Incident, Rebuttal Ruling1highlight16lines spoken

Summary

Judge reprimands Chew for violating her photography order near the courthouse, discloses a TikTok balcony incident involving courthouse staff's children, and limits Bercovici to rebuttal.

Highlights (1)

Quote“it's completely my fault. I was taking a picture for my boys, who I haven't seen in five weeks.”— Benjamin ChewChew's apology and personal explanation for the photo, offered in mitigation of the order violation.Open in transcript →

Day 21

colloquyDefense Rests; Motion to Strike Counterclaims Denied1highlight55lines spoken

Summary

Defense rests; judge denies Depp's motion to strike Heard's counterclaims; sidebar resolves disputes over six late-identified rebuttal witnesses before jury enters.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Mr. Depp hereby moves to strike defendant, Amber Heard's counterclaims because Ms. Heard has not proven by clear and convincing evidence that Mr. Waldman made the three allegedly defamatory statements with actual malice.”— Benjamin ChewFormal statement of Depp's motion to strike, framing the core legal standard at issue in Heard's counterclaims.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
colloquyRuling: Morgan Night Rebuttal Testimony Allowed1highlight5lines spoken

Summary

The court heard defense objections to Morgan Night as a rebuttal witness and ruled to allow his limited testimony, finding probative value outweighed any prejudice.

Highlights (1)

Quote“What they're objecting to is he's going to tell the truth and the truth is inconsistent with what Ms. Heard has said.”— Benjamin ChewChew reframes the disclosure dispute as a defense effort to exclude testimony harmful to Heard's account of the Hicksville incident.Open in transcript →
colloquyDefense Evidence Proffers for the Record5lines spoken

Summary

Defense counsel Nadelhaft proffers excluded testimony and exhibits from nine witnesses and the UK judgment for the appellate record, with distinct grounds including hearsay, improper expert opinion, speculation, and the finding that the door to the U.K. judgment had not been opened.

Day 22

Day 23

colloquyPlaintiff Rests; Motion to Strike Denied; Rebuttal Opens3highlights8lines spoken

Summary

Plaintiff rests rebuttal case; Heard's renewed motion to strike denied; jury sketch and jigsaw puzzle housekeeping; defense calls Julian Ackert.

Highlights (3)

Quote“the clear implication of the defamatory statements is physical abuse”— Benjamin ChewDepp's counter-framing: the defamation claim turns on implied physical abuse, not verbal conduct, so verbal abuse evidence is legally irrelevant to the motion.Open in transcript →
Quote“As long as there's no Aquaman.”— Benjamin ChewLighthearted moment during jigsaw puzzle housekeeping, nodding to Heard's film work; judge extends the joke to Pirates of the Caribbean.Open in transcript →
colloquyJury Instructions Finalized; Closing Argument Ground Rules1highlight11lines spoken

Summary

After Heard rests her counterclaim case, the court finalizes contested jury instructions, approves the verdict form, and sets closing argument ground rules for the next morning.

Highlights (1)

Quote“since the last motion to strike, Mr. Depp has confirmed that he never saw any of the three counterclaim statements until he was served with the counterclaims”— Benjamin ChewChew's new procedural ground for renewing the motion to strike — Depp's lack of knowledge of Waldman's statements.Open in transcript →

Day 24

ClosingClosing Argument — Plaintiff (Vasquez and Chew)Camille Vasquez1highlight28lines spoken

Summary

Depp's attorneys Vasquez and Chew deliver closing argument on the sixth anniversary of Heard's TRO filing, replaying audio admissions and challenging the lack of corroborating injury evidence.

Highlights (1)

Quote“The ship, the Titanic, is Mr. Depp, and Ms. Heard was the iceberg that sank him.”— Benjamin ChewChew's gloss on Heard's op-ed Titanic metaphor, arguing it was designed to cast Depp as the enterprise destroyed by her public allegations.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 25

Day 26