Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewRebecca LecarozJessica MeyersDoug BaniaElaine BredehoftRichard MarksAdam NadelhaftJ. Benjamin RottenbornErin FalatiTravis McGivernJack WhighamcolloquydirectcrossredirectDay 12 - May 2, 2022Day 12 featured McGivern's eyewitness account of Heard striking Depp, Whigham's contested $22.5M Pirates 6 deal testimony, expert analyses of op-ed reputational harm from Marks and Bania, and nurse Falati's contemporaneous medical records.
← Day 112022 Defamation TrialDay 13 →

Day 12 - May 2, 2022

McGivern and Whigham; Damages Experts and Nurse Falati

Judge Penney Azcarate
17Proceedings
5Pages
5Witnesses
2,630Lines
Day 12 of 27
Appearing:

Day 12 featured McGivern's eyewitness account of Heard striking Depp, Whigham's contested $22.5M Pirates 6 deal testimony, expert analyses of op-ed reputational harm from Marks and Bania, and nurse Falati's contemporaneous medical records.

Full day summary

Day 12 opened with bodyguard Travis McGivern testifying via video link that he watched Heard punch Depp in the face with a closed fist on March 23, 2015 — cross-examination then impeached him with his own UK witness statement, which contradicted his trial account of where the parties were when the altercation began. Depp's team advanced its damages case through agent Jack Whigham, who claimed a completed $22.5M Pirates 6 deal before Bredehoft elicited that he had not seen $22.5 million written on a page. Whigham allowed that related franchise paperwork might exist and explained that amendments could be finalized when production began. Entertainment expert Richard Marks opined the op-ed created a devastating "cancel situation" under MeToo norms; Nadelhaft challenged him with pre-existing negative press and limited Disney credentials. Brand analyst Doug Bania presented Q score and Google Trends data showing a post-op-ed reputational decline, but cross-examination exposed his inability to isolate op-ed impact from earlier events and significant gaps in his dataset. The day closed with Heard's nurse Erin Falati authenticating contemporaneous notes documenting Heard's December 2015 injuries, a March 2015 text recording suicidal statements, and Depp's substance use and emotional state during the divorce.

Video thumbnail7:09:08
Watch →

1. Travis McGivern — Direct/Cross

Preliminary housekeeping precedes McGivern's full examination — direct testimony placing Heard as the aggressor in a March 2015 incident, then cross challenging his account with his own UK trial statement.

→
colloquy
Preliminary Matters — Marks Expert Scope Ruling
63 lines

Court handles expert attendance, witness address redaction, exhibit housekeeping, and rules on the scope of Richard Marks's op-ed impact testimony.

Direct
Direct Examination of Travis McGivern Travis McGivern Jessica Meyers
217 lines

McGivern, Depp's bodyguard for nine years, describes escalating arguments after Australia and testifies he witnessed Heard punch Depp in the face during a March 2015 penthouse incident.

Cross
Cross Examination of Travis McGivern Travis McGivern J. Benjamin Rottenborn
147 lines

Rottenborn challenges McGivern's account of the March 23, 2015 incident using his UK trial witness statement and establishes he was absent from most disputed incidents.

Highlights

2. Jack Whigham — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Depp's agent Whigham covers studio deals and career trajectory across direct, cross, and redirect, with the undocumented Pirates 6 deal and causation of the career decline at center.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Jack Whigham Jack Whigham Benjamin Chew
429 lines

Depp's agent Whigham details his studio-film career and $22.5M Pirates 6 deal, testifying that Heard's op-ed led to zero studio work and Disney dropping Depp.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Jack Whigham Jack Whigham Elaine Bredehoft
287 lines

Bredehoft challenged Whigham's Pirates 6 deal claim, extracted an admission of no written contract, and introduced pre-op-ed UK press to argue earlier causes for Depp's career decline.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Jack Whigham Jack Whigham Benjamin Chew
35 lines

Chew rehabilitates Whigham on the undocumented Pirates 6 deal and clarifies Disney had not formally dropped Depp as of the December 2018 op-ed date.

colloquy
Offer of Proof: Pirates 6 Expert Testimony
17 lines

Sidebar where Depp's counsel makes an offer of proof that expert Marks would have testified Depp lost Pirates 6 due to Heard's op-ed.

Highlights

3. Richard Marks — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Entertainment industry expert Richard Marks testifies in full — direct, cross, and redirect — on the career damage Heard's 2018 op-ed caused Depp.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Richard Marks Richard Marks Rebecca Lecaroz
196 lines

Depp's entertainment law expert Richard Marks details nearly 50 years of industry experience and opines that Heard's 2018 op-ed caused devastating reputational harm to Depp's career.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Richard Marks Richard Marks Adam Nadelhaft
263 lines

Nadelhaft challenged Marks's $975/hour fee and credentials, then cataloged pre-op-ed negative publicity about Depp to contest the causal link between Heard's op-ed and his career harm.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Richard Marks Richard Marks Rebecca Lecaroz
16 lines

Lecaroz rehabilitates Marks on redirect, eliciting that pre-existing negative press did not change Depp's Hollywood standing while the op-ed was categorically different.

Highlights

4. Doug Bania — Direct/Cross/Redirect

IP damages expert Doug Bania's full examination: direct establishing Q score and Google Trends analysis, cross challenging methodology, redirect rehabilitating key points.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Doug Bania Doug Bania Rebecca Lecaroz
195 lines

IP damages expert Doug Bania testifies that Q scores and Google search results show measurable reputational decline for Depp following Heard's 2016 allegations and 2018 op-ed.

Procedural
Recess and Exhibit 1639 Submission
15 lines

Judge calls a fifteen-minute recess; upon reconvening, Heard's counsel submits Exhibit 1639 and cross-examination resumes.

Cross
Cross Examination of Doug Bania Doug Bania Adam Nadelhaft
336 lines

Nadelhaft questioned Bania about his deposition testimony, Google Trends results, and the three Q-score time points used in his analysis.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Doug Bania Doug Bania Rebecca Lecaroz
19 lines

Lecaroz rehabilitates Bania on two cross points: his opinion that the op-ed negatively impacted Depp's image and the rationale for his three-point Q score methodology.

Highlights

← Day 112022 Defamation TrialDay 13 →