Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayWayne DennisonJessica MeyersElaine BredehoftDawn HughesAdam NadelhaftJ. Benjamin RottenbornMichael SpindlerErin FalaticrossredirectdirectcolloquyDay 13 - May 3, 2022Day 13 concluded plaintiff's case — including a contested $40M damages figure — then the defense opened with Dr. Dawn Hughes diagnosing Heard with PTSD caused by Depp's intimate partner violence.
← Day 122022 Defamation TrialDay 14 →

Day 13 - May 3, 2022

Depp Rests; Defense Opens with Dr. Dawn Hughes

Judge Penney Azcarate
9Proceedings
4Pages
3Witnesses
1,868Lines
Day 13 of 27
Appearing:

Day 13 concluded plaintiff's case — including a contested $40M damages figure — then the defense opened with Dr. Dawn Hughes diagnosing Heard with PTSD caused by Depp's intimate partner violence.

Full day summary

Day 13 began with the conclusion of nurse Erin Falati's examination, as Depp's attorneys used her own nursing notes to establish that Heard self-reported bipolar disorder, cocaine history, and simultaneous polydrug use at Coachella weeks before the May 2016 penthouse incident. Forensic accountant Michael Spindler presented a $40.3M lost earnings figure attributing $20.25M to the lost Pirates 6 role and approximately $20M to reduced non-franchise bookings, but cross-examination exposed assumed causation, exclusive reliance on an oral agreement for the largest component, and use of Depp's anomalous peak year as the baseline. Plaintiff then rested his case-in-chief, prompting a defense motion to strike on three grounds; Judge Azcarate denied the motion as to statements 2 and 3 and took statement 1 under advisement, confirming sufficient evidence for the jury. Heard's forensic psychologist Dr. Dawn Hughes opened the defense case with a 29-hour evaluation diagnosing Heard with PTSD caused by Depp's intimate partner violence, directly rebutting Dr. Curry's malingering finding and laying the expert foundation for Heard's defense and counterclaim.

Video thumbnail7:05:46
Watch →

1. Erin Falati — Cross/Redirect

Cross and redirect of Heard's nurse Falati: Depp's counsel mines her nursing notes; Heard's counsel authenticates May 21, 2016 photos.

→
colloquy
Exhibit Admissibility and Morning Matters
25 lines

Sidebar discussion of exhibit numbering and admissibility—tax returns (Plaintiff's 936), witness exhibit (Defendant's 1055), and demonstratives (Plaintiff's 889)—before jury enters.

Cross
Cross Examination of Erin Falati Erin Falati Jessica Meyers
299 lines

Depp's counsel used Falati's nursing notes to establish Heard's self-reported substance abuse, mental health history, and no documented injuries after Australia.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Erin Falati Erin Falati Adam Nadelhaft
21 lines

Nadelhaft confirms photos Heard texted Falati on May 21, 2016, and probes the December 17, 2015 penthouse visit, including whether Heard wore makeup.

colloquy
Exhibit 46 Redaction Ruling
12 lines

Judge rules on exhibit redaction patterns and admits Plaintiff's Exhibit 46 into evidence after sidebar discussion with counsel.

Highlights

2. Michael Spindler — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Spindler's complete damages testimony: direct presenting the $40.3M lost-earnings figure, cross impeaching its assumptions, and a brief redirect.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Michael Spindler Michael Spindler Wayne Dennison
102 lines

Forensic accountant Spindler testified to $40.3M in Depp lost earnings: $20.25M net from the lost Pirates 6 role and ~$20M net from reduced non-franchise bookings post-op-ed.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Michael Spindler Michael Spindler J. Benjamin Rottenborn
174 lines

Rottenborn questioned Spindler about the absence of a written Pirates 6 contract, his choice of 2017 as a baseline, and the limits of his opinion on causation.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Michael Spindler Michael Spindler Wayne Dennison
12 lines

Two-question redirect in which Spindler defends his 2017 base year choice and earnings-comparison methodology; witness excused subject to recall.

Highlights

← Day 122022 Defamation TrialDay 14 →