Skip to content
evidenceevidencedocumentary2022 Defamation TrialPAI — Hughes Administration (Heard)Heard's PAI testing by Hughes. Critical item endorsements were introduced as Plaintiff's 1244; the full profile, offered as Defendant's 1858, was excluded as hearsay.
← All Evidence
Documentary Evidence

PAI — Hughes Administration (Heard)

Heard's PAI testing by Hughes. Critical item endorsements were introduced as Plaintiff's 1244; the full profile, offered as Defendant's 1858, was excluded as hearsay.

4 proceedings4 mentions1 trial

About

Plaintiff used Heard's endorsement of 'sometimes true' on items flagged for potential aggression and potential malingering to challenge Hughes's malingering rebuttal and Heard's self-reported violence. Curry additionally testified that the PAI showed an elevated catchall discriminant function indicating intentional minimization and a borderline personality disorder configuration that Hughes had not disclosed. Hughes responded in rebuttal that the elevation did not reach the threshold for meaningful response distortion.

The PAI, a broadband personality inventory with built-in validity scales, was administered by Hughes to Heard. The plaintiff introduced critical item endorsements as Plaintiff's 1244; the defense sought to admit the full scoring profile as Defendant's 1858, which was excluded on hearsay grounds.

Trial Record (4)