Skip to content
personpersonAidan MurphyAidan MurphyDefense attorney who examined digital forensics witnesses about photograph metadata.← All People
Attorney for DefendantCharlson Bredehoft Cohen Brown & Nadelhaft

Aidan Murphy

Courtroom still of Aidan Murphy.

Defense attorney who examined digital forensics witnesses about photograph metadata.

251 lines·9 proceedings

About

Aidan Murphy represented Amber Heard in the Fairfax County defamation trial. He cross-examined Johnny Depp’s forensic expert Bryan Neumeister about his qualifications and the limits of his photograph opinions. Murphy pressed whether a “Photos 3.0” metadata notation established that an image had been visually edited. Neumeister disputed the framing, distinguished metadata from EXIF data, and said the backup extractions could not verify individual photographs.

Murphy later examined Heard’s forensic expert Julian Ackert, who testified that he found original versions on Heard’s devices for all but one photograph Neumeister had flagged. On cross-examination, Ackert acknowledged that he could not authenticate every photograph Heard produced and had not performed the software analysis needed to resolve a question about visually different photographs with matching metadata. On redirect, Murphy asked about the photographs Neumeister had challenged. Ackert said he had no reason to question their forensic authenticity and affirmed that his opinions met a reasonable degree of forensic certainty.

Trial Record (9)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022

Defense attorney who examined digital forensics witnesses about photograph metadata.

Day 0

Day 1

Day 22

CrossCross-Examination of Bryan NeumeisterBryan NeumeisterAidan Murphy1highlight54lines spoken

Summary

Murphy challenges Neumeister's credentials and uses deposition testimony to limit his opinions on photo editing software and EXIF metadata modification.

Highlights (1)

Quote“Your only degree is in political science, correct?”— Aidan MurphyOpens credential attack establishing Neumeister lacks formal academic training in computer science or forensics.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶

Day 23