Skip to content
personpersonRichard ShawRichard ShawPsychiatrist called to address the ethics of an opposing expert’s testimony← All People
Expert witness

Richard Shaw

Courtroom still of Richard Shaw.

Psychiatrist called to address the ethics of an opposing expert’s testimony

65 lines·3 proceedings

About

Richard Shaw, a Stanford psychiatry professor, testified for Depp in rebuttal to psychiatrist David Spiegel. Shaw argued that Spiegel violated the Goldwater Rule by offering opinions about Depp’s personality traits and cognitive functioning without examining him or obtaining his consent and, in Shaw’s view, without sufficient data. The court limited Shaw’s testimony to ethical issues, not an assessment of Depp’s mental condition. Shaw also said that general risk factors for intimate-partner violence could not establish what happened in this case.

On cross-examination, Shaw acknowledged that Spiegel had twice asked to examine Depp and that Depp had declined. He also agreed that the court had authorized Spiegel to testify. Shaw said he had not previously published or presented work on the Goldwater Rule or served on a committee addressing it.

Trial Record (3)

Defamation Trial2022 Defamation TrialApr 11, 2022 – Jun 1, 2022Called by plaintiff

Psychiatrist called to address the ethics of an opposing expert’s testimony

Day 21

DirectDirect Examination of Richard ShawRichard ShawStephanie Calnan4highlights52lines spoken

Summary

Stanford psychiatrist Richard Shaw, called by Depp, testified that Heard's expert Dr. Spiegel violated the APA's Goldwater Rule by opining on Depp's personality and cognition without examination.

Highlights (4)

Quote“about 2,000 psychiatrists responded, a thousand of whom expressed very negative opinions about Senator Goldwater, and made comments such as, for example, he was a megalomaniac, he was a paranoid schizophrenic, that he had narcissistic personality disorder.”— Richard ShawShaw's account of the 1964 Fact magazine survey that prompted the Goldwater Rule — contextualizing why the APA viewed remote psychiatric diagnosis as a serious professional and legal hazard.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“the main premise of the Goldwater Rule is that it was improper for a psychiatrist to render professional opinion about a public figure unless they had personally and closely evaluated them.”— Richard ShawShaw's concise statement of the Goldwater Rule's core prohibition — the doctrinal standard against which Spiegel's conduct was measured throughout this proceeding.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“my opinion is that he did not. He expressed a number of professional opinions about Mr. Depp that we heard about yesterday. And, again, he did so without an evaluation, without consent.”— Richard ShawShaw's direct conclusion that Spiegel violated the Goldwater Rule, identifying the two most fundamental deficiencies: no examination and no consent.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
Quote“the actual presence of risks factors for IPV that Dr. Spiegel was talking about, they say absolutely nothing about what happened in this case.”— Richard ShawShaw's closing argument against Spiegel's IPV testimony: even a full constellation of risk factors cannot establish that any individual perpetrated abuse, directly attacking the probative value of Spiegel's opinions for the jury.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶
RedirectRedirect Examination of Richard ShawRichard ShawStephanie Calnan1highlight1line spoken

Summary

Calnan's redirect of psychiatrist Richard Shaw lasted moments: one confirmatory question, a single affirmative answer, and "nothing further."

Highlights (1)

Quote“I heard that yesterday in testimony, yes.”— Richard ShawShaw's sole substantive response on redirect — a brief affirmation of having heard testimony from the prior day; the triggering question is absent from the transcript.Open in transcript →Watch this moment ▶