Day 26 - June 1, 2022
The jury delivers a unanimous verdict finding Depp proved defamation on all three challenged op-ed statements, awarding $10M compensatory; Heard wins one counterclaim for $2M; judge immediately caps Depp's punitive award at $350K.
Full day summary
9:00:101. Verdict
Verdict read-back and jury polling: Depp prevails on all three defamation claims; Heard prevails on one of three counterclaims.
Highlights
Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins CounterclaimJudge Azcarate admonishes the gallery against any outburst before the verdict is read, underscoring the formal gravity of the proceeding.Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins Counterclaim“Regardless of the verdict, I will not tolerate any outburst, whatsoever, okay?”— Penney AzcarateJudge's pre-verdict admonishment to the gallery, marking the charged atmosphere as the jury prepares to deliver its decision.Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins CounterclaimThe Court Clerk reads the operative verdicts: $10M compensatory to Depp on all three defamation claims, and $2M compensatory to Heard on her one successful counterclaim over Waldman's 'hoax' statement.Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins Counterclaim“As against Amber Heard: We, the jury, award compensatory damages in the amount of $10 million.”— Court ClerkThe operative damages verdict on Depp's defamation claims, the central outcome of the six-week trial.Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins Counterclaim“As against John C. Depp, II: We, the jury, award compensatory damages in the amount of $2 million.”— Penney AzcarateThe damages verdict on Heard's one successful counterclaim, establishing mutual liability between the parties.Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins CounterclaimJudge Azcarate immediately applies Virginia's statutory cap, reducing the jury's $5M punitive award to Depp to $350,000.Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins Counterclaim“I will amend the punitive damages award to the statutory cap of $350,000 on Mr. Depp's award, okay?”— Penney AzcarateJudge immediately applies Virginia's statutory punitive cap, reducing the jury's $5M punitive award to $350K and setting the operative judgment figure.Jury Verdict: Depp Prevails, Heard Wins CounterclaimThe jury is briefly sent back to correct an incomplete damages form before the verdict is read aloud in full.