Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-daycolloquyDay 25 - May 31, 2022The deliberating jury asked whether Question 43's falsity inquiry applied to the op-ed headline or the full article; Judge Azcarate clarified in writing that the headline alone is the statement at issue.
← Day 242022 Defamation TrialDay 26 →

Day 25 - May 31, 2022

Jury Question

Judge Penney Azcarate
1Proceedings
1Pages
0Witnesses
27Lines
Day 25 of 27

The deliberating jury asked whether Question 43's falsity inquiry applied to the op-ed headline or the full article; Judge Azcarate clarified in writing that the headline alone is the statement at issue.

Full day summary

Day 25 consisted of a single colloquy during jury deliberations. The jury submitted a question asking whether the falsity inquiry for Question 43 applied to the op-ed headline or the entire article. Judge Azcarate, with agreement from all counsel, determined that the headline is the statement at issue and sent a written clarification to the deliberating jury: "The statement is the headline not the entire op-ed." The response clarified that the existing instruction concerned the headline as the alleged defamatory statement. Separately, Judge Azcarate declined to entertain a pending motion from Depp's counsel, citing her practice of not acting on motions once deliberations have begun.

Video thumbnail8:24:55
Watch →

1. Jury Question

Mid-deliberation colloquy: the jury surfaces a question about Question 43, and Judge Azcarate clarifies that the falsity inquiry targets the op-ed headline only.

→
colloquy
Jury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full Content
27 lines

The jury asked whether falsity Question 43 applied to the op-ed headline or the full article; Judge Azcarate clarified it refers to the headline only.

Highlights

Jury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full ContentJudge Azcarate determines that the headline — not the full article — is the statement at issue for the Question 43 falsity inquiry, with all counsel in agreement.Jury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full Content“it's clear that the title is the statement”— Penney AzcarateJudge's threshold ruling narrowing the falsity question to the op-ed headline alone, a determination that directly shaped the jury's deliberations on Depp's primary defamation claim.Jury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full ContentThe court sends the deliberating jury a written clarification: 'The statement is the headline not the entire op-ed.'Jury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full Content“The statement is the headline not the entire op-ed.”— Penney AzcarateThe exact written clarification transmitted to the deliberating jury, establishing the formal scope of the falsity inquiry for Question 43.Jury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full ContentJudge Azcarate declines to entertain a pending motion from Depp's counsel, explaining her policy against acting on motions while the case is in the jury's hands.Jury Question — Op-Ed Headline vs. Full Content“since the jury has the case now and it's out of my hands, I appreciate your motion but I'm not going to entertain it at this time, okay?”— Penney AzcarateJudge explains her deliberation-phase policy, declining to act on Depp counsel's pending motion while the verdict remains the jury's to decide.
← Day 242022 Defamation TrialDay 26 →