Day 24 - May 27, 2022
Day 24 was devoted entirely to closing arguments: Judge Azcarate charged the jury with defamation instructions, both sides presented closing and rebuttal arguments, and the jury retired to deliberate.
Full day summary
9:35:232. Closing Argument - Plaintiff
Plaintiff's closing argument — Vasquez and Chew consolidate Depp's defamation case through audio admissions and the seven-element verdict form.
Highlights
Closing Argument — Plaintiff (Vasquez and Chew)Vasquez plays audio recordings of Heard admitting to hitting Depp and challenges her injury documentation; Chew uses the op-ed's Titanic metaphor to argue defamatory implication.Closing Argument — Plaintiff (Vasquez and Chew)“Tell the world, Johnny.' Tell them, Johnny Depp, I, Johnny Depp, a man, I am a victim, too, of domestic violence.”— Amber HeardAudio recording played by Vasquez in which Heard mocks the idea of Depp claiming victimhood, used as the centerpiece of the plaintiff's closing to argue Heard never believed her own abuse allegations.
3. Closing Argument — Defense
Rottenborn opens the defense closing, framing Depp's legal burden and arguing the op-ed is First Amendment-protected speech.
Highlights
Closing Argument — Defendant (Rottenborn)Rottenborn argues the op-ed is First Amendment-protected and surveys Depp's own texts, audio, and recordings to document alleged abuse chronologically.Closing Argument — Defendant (Rottenborn)“you cannot simultaneously protect and uphold the First Amendment and find in favor of Johnny Depp on his claim. You simply cannot.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornCore framing of the defense's closing — Rottenborn argues the verdict is a choice between constitutional speech protection and siding with Depp.
4. Closing Argument - Counterclaim
Bredehoft delivers Heard's counterclaim closing, walking the jury through Waldman's three allegedly defamatory statements and the damages framework.
Highlights
Closing Argument — Counterclaim (Heard's Team)Bredehoft presents the counterclaim closing, walking through Waldman's three defamatory statements, the May 21 penthouse incident, and a $47–50 million career-damages estimate.Closing Argument — Counterclaim (Heard's Team)“We've reached the beginning of the end of Ms. Heard's abuse hoax against Johnny Depp.”— Elaine BredehoftVerbatim text of Waldman's third defamatory statement, presented as the clearest example of the false and defamatory meaning underpinning Heard's counterclaim.
5. Rebuttal Closing — Plaintiff
Plaintiff's rebuttal closing — Vasquez's final argument before jury deliberation, the last contested speech of the trial.
Highlights
Rebuttal Closing — Vasquez for PlaintiffVasquez's rebuttal attacks Heard's credibility on the charity pledge and escalating sexual assault allegations, and disputes causation in Heard's counterclaim damages evidence.Rebuttal Closing — Vasquez for Plaintiff“It's not about money. It's about giving Mr. Depp his life back, six years ago when she took it away.”— Camille VasquezVasquez's closing appeal reframing the verdict as restoration of reputation rather than financial compensation, delivered as the final line of the plaintiff's rebuttal.