Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayCamille VasquezElaine BredehoftJ. Benjamin Rottenbornjury_instructionsclosing_argumentclosing_argument_counterclaimrebuttal_closingDay 24 - May 27, 2022Day 24 was devoted entirely to closing arguments: Judge Azcarate charged the jury with defamation instructions, both sides presented closing and rebuttal arguments, and the jury retired to deliberate.
← Day 232022 Defamation TrialDay 25 →

Day 24 - May 27, 2022

Closing Arguments

Judge Penney Azcarate
10Proceedings
7Pages
0Witnesses
665Lines
Day 24 of 27
Appearing:

Day 24 was devoted entirely to closing arguments: Judge Azcarate charged the jury with defamation instructions, both sides presented closing and rebuttal arguments, and the jury retired to deliberate.

Full day summary

Judge Azcarate opened Day 24 by reading comprehensive jury instructions establishing the seven-element defamation test for Depp's three op-ed claims, the five-element test for Heard's three Waldman counterclaims, and the actual malice standard requiring clear and convincing evidence. Vasquez and Chew delivered the plaintiff's closing, playing audio recordings of Heard admitting to hitting Depp, challenging the absence of corroborating medical evidence for her injuries, and walking the jury through the 21-question verdict form. Rottenborn argued the op-ed was First Amendment-protected speech and walked the jury chronologically through Depp's own texts and recordings documenting alleged abuse, while Bredehoft's counterclaim closing presented Waldman's three defamatory statements alongside a $47–50 million career-damages estimate. Vasquez's rebuttal directly attacked Heard's credibility on the charity pledge, the escalating sexual assault allegations, and the causation gap in her damages case, and Rottenborn's final rebuttal urged the jury that any single act of abuse—physical, verbal, or sexual—was sufficient to support Heard. After final deliberation instructions, alternate jurors were released and the jury retired.

Video thumbnail9:35:23
Watch →

7. Jury Instructions — Penney Azcarate

Judge Azcarate formally charges the jury, releases the two alternates, and sends the panel to deliberate following five weeks of testimony.

→
Jury Instruction
Jury Instructions — Deliberations Begin Penney Azcarate
8 lines

Judge Azcarate delivers final deliberation instructions, releases alternates Jurors 3 and 14, and sends the jury to deliberate in the Depp v. Heard case.

Procedural
Jury Instructions & Long Weekend Recess
35 lines

Judge thanks counsel and court staff, clarifies verdict form instructions via sidebar, and instructs jury on conduct during three-day break before resuming deliberations Tuesday.

Highlights

← Day 232022 Defamation TrialDay 25 →