Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayWayne DennisonSamuel MonizCamille VasquezElaine BredehoftRichard GilbertDawn HughesAidan MurphyJ. Benjamin RottenbornJulian AckertAmber HearddirectcrossredirectcolloquyDay 23 - May 26, 2022Depp rests rebuttal; defense counters with digital-forensics expert Ackert and rebuttal psychologist Hughes before Heard's emotional counterclaim testimony and heated cross-examination by Vasquez.
← Day 222022 Defamation TrialDay 24 →

Day 23 - May 26, 2022

Depp Rests Rebuttal; Ackert, Hughes and Heard Testify

Judge Penney Azcarate
18Proceedings
5Pages
4Witnesses
1,914Lines
Day 23 of 27
Appearing:

Depp rests rebuttal; defense counters with digital-forensics expert Ackert and rebuttal psychologist Hughes before Heard's emotional counterclaim testimony and heated cross-examination by Vasquez.

Full day summary

Day 23 opened with orthopedic expert Richard Gilbert testifying that Depp's comminuted finger fracture was consistent with a thrown vodka bottle and highly unlikely to result from wall-punching, before Depp formally rested his rebuttal case and Judge Azcarate denied Heard's renewed motion to strike. Defense digital-forensics expert Julian Ackert rebutted Neumeister's photo-tampering theory by locating original iOS-metadata versions of flagged photos on Heard's devices, but Dennison's cross surfaced two admitted exhibits sharing identical timestamps and filenames yet visually different — an evidentiary discrepancy left unresolved. Rebuttal psychologist Dawn Hughes contested Curry's TSI-2 qualifications and CAPS-5 findings, while Dennison used instrument manuals to challenge her methods. Hughes defended her clinical interviewing, retrospective Danger Assessment use, and CAPS-5 frequency recording on the scoring side. Heard then took the stand on counterclaim damages, describing daily death threats and career losses she attributes to the Waldman statements, before Vasquez challenged her about the TMZ courthouse tip and cabinet video; Heard expressly denied supplying the information or leaking or editing the video. Vasquez separately questioned photo exhibits attributed to conflicting incidents. The day closed with jury instructions finalized, self-defense privilege instructions denied as moot under the actual malice standard, and proffers of excluded evidence — including the Deuters "he kicked you, he cried" text message — entered for the record.

Video thumbnail8:39:26
Watch →

1. Richard Gilbert — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Depp's rebuttal orthopedic expert Dr. Richard Gilbert testifies on the Australia finger injury — direct, cross, and redirect.

→
Procedural
Sidebar re: Dr. Gilbert's Finger Injury Rebuttal Scope
37 lines

The court clarifies that Dr. Gilbert's rebuttal testimony may address alternative causes of the finger injury, overruling defense objections to his scope regarding the phone.

Direct
Direct Examination of Richard Gilbert Richard Gilbert Samuel Moniz
106 lines

Hand surgeon Dr. Richard Gilbert testified that Depp's Australia finger injury is medically consistent with a thrown vodka bottle and inconsistent with Heard's punching account.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Richard Gilbert Richard Gilbert J. Benjamin Rottenborn
72 lines

Rottenborn impeaches plaintiff's hand surgeon on the Australia finger injury theory, eliciting that he had read no report of hand movement; Gilbert explained a medical inference from the absent nailbed injury and rejected counsel's stronger characterization.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Richard Gilbert Richard Gilbert Samuel Moniz
14 lines

Moniz briefly redirects Gilbert, who clarifies that the absence of other hand injuries makes alternative injury mechanisms—not the thrown bottle—more unlikely.

Highlights

2. Julian Ackert — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Plaintiff rests rebuttal; Heard's motion to strike denied; then Ackert's full testimony arc rebutting Neumeister's photo-authenticity findings.

→
colloquy
Plaintiff Rests; Motion to Strike Denied; Rebuttal Opens
39 lines

Plaintiff rests rebuttal case; Heard's renewed motion to strike denied; jury sketch and jigsaw puzzle housekeeping; defense calls Julian Ackert.

Direct
Direct Examination of Julian Ackert Julian Ackert Aidan Murphy
131 lines

Heard's computer forensics expert rebutted Neumeister's EXIF metadata concerns, finding original iOS-metadata versions of flagged photos on Heard's actual devices.

Cross
Cross Examination of Julian Ackert Julian Ackert Wayne Dennison
55 lines

Dennison limits Ackert's authentication scope to Neumeister-flagged photos and presents two admitted exhibits with identical metadata but different visual appearance.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Julian Ackert Julian Ackert Aidan Murphy
13 lines

Ackert confirms on brief redirect that he has no reason to question the forensic authenticity of the photos Neumeister flagged, and reaffirms his opinions were made with reasonable forensic certainty.

Highlights

Plaintiff Rests; Motion to Strike Denied; Rebuttal OpensDepp formally rested his rebuttal case; Judge Azcarate denied Heard's renewed motion to strike on all three grounds — undisputed emotional abuse, headline non-attribution, and absence of actual malice — preserving all of Depp's defamation claims for the jury before the defense opened rebuttal with digital-forensics expert Julian Ackert.Plaintiff Rests; Motion to Strike Denied; Rebuttal Opens“the undisputed evidence shows that Mr. Depp did not -- did abuse Ms. Heard, at a minimum, emotionally, verbally, psychologically and otherwise. That's undisputed.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornThe central argument in Heard's renewed motion to strike: that even conceded non-physical abuse would defeat Depp's defamation claim by making the op-ed's implication true — the core legal theory Azcarate rejected.Direct Examination of Julian Ackert“This is a completely hypothetical scenario. Mr. Neumeister never specified.any pictures with specificity that had EXIF metadata modification, and it's a hypothetical, in my opinion…”— Julian AckertAckert's strongest rebuttal of Neumeister's photo-tampering theory, characterizing it as unanchored speculation never tied to a specific photograph — directly supporting the authenticity of Heard's injury photos.Cross Examination of Julian AckertDennison introduced Plaintiff's Exhibit 1308 showing two visually different photos sharing an identical filename and timestamp, leaving an unresolved evidentiary conflict before the jury about which version was authentic — a gap Ackert declined to fill because it fell outside Neumeister's challenged photos.

3. Dawn Hughes — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Dawn Hughes's full testimony arc on Day 23: direct rebuttal of Curry's methodology, Dennison's systematic cross on protocol deviations, and brief redirect.

→
Procedural
Sidebar re: Witness Timing and Rebuttal Scope
30 lines

Court allocates 51 minutes between witnesses, addresses bathroom break logistics, and restricts Dr. Hughes's rebuttal testimony to IPV factors Dr. Curry addressed.

Direct
Direct Examination of Dawn Hughes — Rebuttal Dawn Hughes Elaine Bredehoft
104 lines

Dr. Dawn Hughes rebuts Shannon Curry's Day 22 criticisms, defending her multi-method forensic methodology, test interpretations, and PTSD conclusions regarding Amber Heard.

Cross
Cross Examination of Dawn Hughes Dawn Hughes Wayne Dennison
170 lines

Dennison challenges Hughes’s PTSD diagnosis and use of test instructions. Hughes defends clinical interviewing, retrospective use, and her recording of frequency information on the scoring side.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Dawn Hughes Dawn Hughes Elaine Bredehoft
33 lines

Brief redirect rehabilitates Hughes on static risk factors, the 88-page notes, and clinical versus research scoring of the CAPS-5.

Procedural
Remaining Trial Time & Jury Instructions
46 lines

Judge Azcarate discusses remaining trial time for both sides, schedules jury instructions before closing arguments, and clarifies procedures for verdict form references and closing logistics.

Highlights

4. Amber Heard — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Heard testifies on counterclaim damages in rebuttal direct, then faces Vasquez's cross on corroboration gaps and TMZ evidence, closing with brief redirect.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Amber Heard Amber Heard J. Benjamin Rottenborn
51 lines

Rottenborn's brief rebuttal direct on the counterclaim draws Heard's testimony about daily harassment, death threats, career damage, and lasting psychological trauma from the Waldman statements.

colloquy
Sidebar: Scope of Heard Rebuttal Cross-Examination
167 lines

Judge limits Vasquez's cross of Heard to rebuttal-case topics only, permitting TMZ, Kate Moss, and Baruch but excluding Neumeister photos and Beverly Leonard.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Amber Heard (Continued) Amber Heard Camille Vasquez
290 lines

Vasquez closes cross-examination by impeaching Heard on the Hicksville trailer, TMZ courthouse tip-off, the cabinet video leak, and her contradictory attribution of the same floor photograph to two separate incidents.

Redirect
Amber Heard — Redirect Examination Amber Heard J. Benjamin Rottenborn
37 lines

Rottenborn's brief redirect rehabilitates Heard on faked-injury allegations and elicits her affirmations of physical, verbal, emotional, and psychological abuse.

Highlights

← Day 222022 Defamation TrialDay 24 →