Day 23 - May 26, 2022
Depp rests rebuttal; defense counters with digital-forensics expert Ackert and rebuttal psychologist Hughes before Heard's emotional counterclaim testimony and heated cross-examination by Vasquez.
Full day summary
8:39:262. Julian Ackert — Direct/Cross/Redirect
Plaintiff rests rebuttal; Heard's motion to strike denied; then Ackert's full testimony arc rebutting Neumeister's photo-authenticity findings.
Highlights
Plaintiff Rests; Motion to Strike Denied; Rebuttal OpensDepp formally rested his rebuttal case; Judge Azcarate denied Heard's renewed motion to strike on all three grounds — undisputed emotional abuse, headline non-attribution, and absence of actual malice — preserving all of Depp's defamation claims for the jury before the defense opened rebuttal with digital-forensics expert Julian Ackert.Plaintiff Rests; Motion to Strike Denied; Rebuttal Opens“the undisputed evidence shows that Mr. Depp did not -- did abuse Ms. Heard, at a minimum, emotionally, verbally, psychologically and otherwise. That's undisputed.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornThe central argument in Heard's renewed motion to strike: that even conceded non-physical abuse would defeat Depp's defamation claim by making the op-ed's implication true — the core legal theory Azcarate rejected.Direct Examination of Julian Ackert“This is a completely hypothetical scenario. Mr. Neumeister never specified.any pictures with specificity that had EXIF metadata modification, and it's a hypothetical, in my opinion…”— Julian AckertAckert's strongest rebuttal of Neumeister's photo-tampering theory, characterizing it as unanchored speculation never tied to a specific photograph — directly supporting the authenticity of Heard's injury photos.Cross Examination of Julian AckertDennison introduced Plaintiff's Exhibit 1308 showing two visually different photos sharing an identical filename and timestamp, leaving an unresolved evidentiary conflict before the jury about which version was authentic — a gap Ackert declined to fill because it fell outside Neumeister's challenged photos.
4. Amber Heard — Direct/Cross/Redirect
Heard testifies on counterclaim damages in rebuttal direct, then faces Vasquez's cross on corroboration gaps and TMZ evidence, closing with brief redirect.
Highlights
Direct Examination of Amber Heard“I have the right to tell my story. I have the right to say what happened to me. I have the right to my voice and my name. He took it long enough.”— Amber HeardHeard's closing statement on direct examination, framing her counterclaim as a fundamental assertion of the right to speak about her own experience — the most direct articulation of the legal and personal stakes driving her counterclaim.Cross-Examination of Amber Heard (Continued)“I know how many people will come out and say whatever for him. That's his power. That's why I wrote the op-ed. I was speaking to that phenomenon.”— Amber HeardHeard's overarching explanation for every contradicting rebuttal witness — attributing the testimony pattern to Depp's power rather than addressing specific factual contradictions — and her explicit link between that power and her decision to write the op-ed.Cross-Examination of Amber Heard (Continued)Vasquez's cross-examination of Heard exposed corroboration failures through Morgan Night, Morgan Tremaine's TMZ testimony, and a side-by-side comparison of exhibits 512 and 725 — attributed to two different incidents in Heard's prior testimony — that appeared to be the same photograph.