Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewWayne DennisonRebecca LecarozJessica MeyersCamille VasquezElaine BredehoftShannon CurryAidan MurphyJ. Benjamin RottenbornBeverly LeonardKate MossBryan NeumeisterMorgan TremaineJohnny DeppcolloquydirectcrossredirectDay 22 - May 25, 2022Day 22 saw Kate Moss deny any staircase push via WebEx, Depp rebut Heard's key factual claims, rebuttal psychologist Curry challenge Hughes's PTSD diagnosis, TMZ insider Tremaine describe pre-arranged media coverage, and Neumeister attack Heard's injury photos.
← Day 212022 Defamation TrialDay 23 →

Day 22 - May 25, 2022

Kate Moss, Depp's Rebuttal, TMZ Testimony and Photo Evidence

Judge Penney Azcarate
19Proceedings
8Pages
6Witnesses
2,804Lines
Day 22 of 27
Appearing:

Day 22 saw Kate Moss deny any staircase push via WebEx, Depp rebut Heard's key factual claims, rebuttal psychologist Curry challenge Hughes's PTSD diagnosis, TMZ insider Tremaine describe pre-arranged media coverage, and Neumeister attack Heard's injury photos.

Full day summary

Day 22 opened with evidentiary rulings confining Kate Moss to staircase testimony only; Moss then denied via WebEx that Depp had ever pushed her down stairs, addressing the rumor Amber Heard cited as her reason for striking Depp when she believed her sister was threatened in the penthouse altercation. Rebuttal psychologist Shannon Curry attacked Dawn Hughes's testing methodology — including a 98th-percentile TSI-2 atypical response finding — and concluded Heard showed no evidence of PTSD, though cross-examination established Curry lacked IPV qualification and had dined with Depp's team before her retention. Depp returned to the stand to rebut Heard's Australia drug-use claims and introduce honeymoon photos, but Rottenborn impeached him with Bangkok photos predating the Orient Express and a post-injury text requesting cocaine and ecstasy. Former TMZ assignment manager Morgan Tremaine testified that Heard-related media deployments were pre-arranged and that the kitchen cabinet video TMZ received was shorter than the trial version, missing footage of Heard setting up the camera. Forensic expert Bryan Neumeister identified photo-editing software signatures in EXIF metadata on Heard's injury photos, concluding no forensic expert could validate any of them — a conclusion Murphy challenged on cross. Neumeister rejected the premise that he found no modification evidence but acknowledged he offered no opinion that Heard intentionally modified a photograph.

Video thumbnail8:49:21
Watch →

1. Preliminary Matters

Pre-session sidebar rulings shaping Day 22's witness scope: Beverly Leonard admitted for limited impeachment, Kate Moss restricted to the staircase incident.

→
colloquy
Preliminary Matters — Rebuttal Witness Rulings
189 lines

Sidebar rulings admit Beverly Leonard for limited impeachment, restrict Kate Moss to staircase testimony, and exclude Dr. Collins and Bryan Neumeister as rebuttal experts.

3. Shannon Curry — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Curry's full rebuttal arc: direct critiquing Hughes's testing methodology, cross targeting credentials and pre-retention contacts, redirect on SCID and APA compliance.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Shannon Curry Shannon Curry Wayne Dennison
152 lines

Dr. Curry rebuts Dr. Hughes's expert testimony, challenging her test battery as forensically inappropriate, identifying response distortion Hughes ignored, and concluding Heard has no PTSD.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Shannon Curry Shannon Curry Elaine Bredehoft
198 lines

Bredehoft attacks Curry's independence and credentials via deposition impeachment, establishing that none of Heard's treating providers ever diagnosed her with BPD or HPD.

Redirect
Shannon Curry — Redirect Examination Shannon Curry Wayne Dennison
21 lines

Dennison briefly redirects Curry on two cross topics: her rationale for not using the SCID, and her confirmation of compliance with APA Specialty Guidelines 1.02 and 1.03.

Highlights

4. Colloquy

Post-recess sidebar on rebuttal expert scope: Dr. Collins excluded, Neumeister ruling deferred to noon, defense names Hughes and Heard as rebuttal witnesses.

→
colloquy
Rebuttal Expert Exclusion; Depp Returns to Testify
153 lines

Post-recess sidebar excludes Dr. Collins as rebuttal expert; Neumeister ruling deferred to noon; defense discloses Hughes and Heard as rebuttal witnesses; Depp recalled.

5. Johnny Depp — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Depp's rebuttal testimony — direct, cross, and redirect — covers Australia, MDMA, honeymoon photos, and closes with a denial of all abuse.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Johnny Depp Johnny Depp Jessica Meyers
446 lines

Meyers rehabilitates Depp on Waldman statements, Aquaman role, Australia MDMA claims, honeymoon injury photos, Kate Moss, and Whitney Henriquez.

colloquy
Neumeister Scope Ruling; TMZ Intervention Denied
254 lines

The court limited Neumeister's rebuttal testimony to photographs in evidence and their EXIF metadata, denied use of the UK trial judgment, and rejected TMZ's intervention motion.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Johnny Depp (Day 22) Johnny Depp J. Benjamin Rottenborn
434 lines

Rottenborn confronts Depp with pre-train honeymoon photos, post-injury drug texts, a vitriolic text to his agent, and his prior UK trial testimony.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Johnny Depp Johnny Depp Jessica Meyers
89 lines

Meyers rehabilitates Depp on cross-examination exhibits — the Carino text, sister/Aquaman text, and disclaimed DX883 messages — before closing with his direct denial of all physical abuse.

Highlights

6. Morgan Tremaine — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Former TMZ field manager Morgan Tremaine testifies about tip-offs to his newsroom, a staged courthouse photo op, and a length discrepancy in the kitchen cabinet video.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Morgan Tremaine Morgan Tremaine Camille Vasquez
138 lines

Former TMZ field manager describes tip-driven coverage of Heard's 2016 courthouse appearance and a shorter cabinet video; he did not identify who supplied either.

Cross
Cross Examination of Morgan Tremaine Morgan Tremaine Elaine Bredehoft
51 lines

Bredehoft challenged Tremaine's motives and probed whether TMZ's tips about Heard's TRO filing originated from Depp's own legal team.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Morgan Tremaine Morgan Tremaine Camille Vasquez
8 lines

Vasquez asks Tremaine why he contacted Depp's team; he explains noticing a video discrepancy and reaching out to clarify the timeline, not to testify.

Highlights

7. Bryan Neumeister — Direct/Cross/Redirect

All three rounds of Bryan Neumeister's testimony — direct, cross, and redirect — on digital forensic analysis of Heard's injury photos.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Bryan Neumeister Bryan Neumeister Rebecca Lecaroz
331 lines

Digital forensics expert Neumeister testifies that EXIF metadata in Heard's injury photos shows photo-editing software, making forensic authentication impossible.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Bryan Neumeister Bryan Neumeister Aidan Murphy
123 lines

Murphy challenges Neumeister's credentials and uses deposition testimony to limit his opinions on photo editing software and EXIF metadata modification.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Bryan Neumeister Bryan Neumeister Rebecca Lecaroz
14 lines

Lecaroz redirected Neumeister to clarify the EXIF/metadata distinction and explain why iTunes backup extractions cannot forensically verify photo provenance.

Highlights

8. Beverly Leonard — Direct/Cross

Beverly Leonard testifies via video about a 2009 Sea-Tac baggage-claim incident involving Heard; Bredehoft's cross targets the 13-year delay before she came forward.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Beverly Leonard Beverly Leonard Camille Vasquez
56 lines

Former Sea-Tac Airport employee Beverly Leonard testified by video that in 2009 she witnessed Heard grab and rip a necklace from a traveling companion while appearing intoxicated.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Beverly Leonard Beverly Leonard Elaine Bredehoft
22 lines

Bredehoft's brief cross challenged Leonard's credibility, noting she contacted Depp's counsel only the night before testifying—13 years after the 2009 incident.

colloquy
Final Witness Scheduling & Time Allocations
90 lines

Judge addresses Dr. Gilbert's delayed testimony due to a funeral, confirms jury instructions delivery, and allocates remaining trial time (plaintiff: 7h 8m; defendant: 1h 16m) before closing arguments.

← Day 212022 Defamation TrialDay 23 →