Day 21 - May 24, 2022
Stephanie Calnan Benjamin Chew Wayne Dennison Rebecca Lecaroz Jessica Meyers Samuel Moniz Camille Vasquez Doug Bania Elaine Bredehoft David Kulber Richard Marks Adam Nadelhaft Clarissa K. Pintado J. Benjamin Rottenborn Richard Shaw Michael Spindler Candie Davidson-Goldbronn Walter Hamada Jennifer Howell Morgan Night
The defense rested as Depp opened rebuttal with seven witnesses attacking Heard's counterclaim damages framework, the Aquaman chemistry rationale, the finger-injury record, and her 2013 Hicksville account.
Full day summary
9:14:251. Preliminary Matters
Defense rests; Azcarate denies Depp's motion to strike Heard's counterclaims; sidebar over six late-identified rebuttal witnesses precedes jury entry.
Highlights
Defense Rests; Motion to Strike Counterclaims DeniedThe defense formally rested and Judge Azcarate denied Depp's motion to strike Heard's counterclaims, ruling actual malice a jury question and preserving the Waldman counterclaim for deliberation.Defense Rests; Motion to Strike Counterclaims Denied“It is not my role to measure the veracity or weight of the evidence. The force record in the Virginia Supreme Court have made it crystal clear that actual malice is a question for …”— Penney AzcarateDefinitive ruling denying Depp's motion to strike and sending the Waldman actual-malice question to the jury, the pivotal procedural moment of the day.
7. Doug Bania — Direct/Cross
Bania is recalled on rebuttal to counter the defense's two economic experts, then faces cross on his methodology's limits.
Highlights
Direct Examination of Doug Bania (Recall)Bania's granular rebuttal reduced Schnell's 2.7 million hashtag tweets to five tweets referencing Waldman's actual language, effectively dismantling the scale-of-harm narrative underlying Heard's counterclaim.Direct Examination of Doug Bania (Recall)“I identified five tweets that were related to the Waldman statements.”— Doug BaniaBania's reduction of Schnell's 2.7 million tweet dataset to five tweets actually referencing Waldman content, effectively dismantling the evidentiary scale of Heard's counterclaim.
8. Morgan Night — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Voir Dire
Full arc of Morgan Night's rebuttal testimony: dual voir dire, admissibility ruling, and direct through redirect on a 2013 Hicksville incident.
Highlights
Direct Examination of Morgan NightMorgan Night testified that Heard yelled at a cowering Depp during their 2013 Hicksville stay and that Depp became quiet and subdued afterward, with Night affirmatively denying ever witnessing Depp become physical.Direct Examination of Morgan Night“I never saw Mr. Depp get physical with anyone when I saw him.”— Morgan NightNight's direct, closing denial of any physical conduct by Depp at Hicksville — the clearest single statement from Depp's eyewitness rebuttal to Heard's account of the Joshua Tree incident.