Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayStephanie CalnanBenjamin ChewWayne DennisonRebecca LecarozJessica MeyersSamuel MonizCamille VasquezDoug BaniaElaine BredehoftDavid KulberRichard MarksAdam NadelhaftClarissa K. PintadoJ. Benjamin RottenbornRichard ShawMichael SpindlerCandie Davidson-GoldbronnWalter HamadaJennifer HowellMorgan Nightcolloquydirectcrossredirectvoir_direDay 21 - May 24, 2022The defense rested as Depp opened rebuttal with seven witnesses attacking Heard's counterclaim damages framework, the Aquaman chemistry rationale, the finger-injury record, and her 2013 Hicksville account.
← Day 202022 Defamation TrialDay 22 →

Day 21 - May 24, 2022

Defense Rests; Depp's Rebuttal Begins

Judge Penney Azcarate
30Proceedings
12Pages
9Witnesses
2,553Lines
Day 21 of 27
Appearing:

The defense rested as Depp opened rebuttal with seven witnesses attacking Heard's counterclaim damages framework, the Aquaman chemistry rationale, the finger-injury record, and her 2013 Hicksville account.

Full day summary

The defense formally rested and Judge Azcarate denied Depp's motion to strike Heard's counterclaims, preserving the Waldman actual-malice question for the jury. Depp's rebuttal opened with Walter Hamada undercutting Heard's Aquaman damages claim, followed by three returning experts — Marks, Spindler, and Bania — jointly dismantling her $45M+ lost-earnings projection as methodologically unsupported; Bania's exact-phrase search of a post-April subset identified five related unique tweets after deduplication and exclusion of shares; he acknowledged that wording variants could escape the search. Surgeon David Kulber testified that Depp wore a soft plaster splint in March 2015, though cross-examination elicited the concession that his uninjured hand remained fully available. Trailer park owner Morgan Night survived voir dire and a late-disclosure objection to deliver eyewitness testimony of Heard yelling at a cowering Depp during the 2013 Hicksville visit, while rebuttal psychiatrist Richard Shaw challenged Spiegel's opinions as Goldwater Rule violations before his own cross exposed that Depp had twice refused Spiegel's examination requests. Deposition testimony from Jennifer Howell and Children's Hospital designee Candie Davidson-Goldbronn documented Heard's $3.5M CHLA pledge as 93% unfulfilled, and the day closed with defense proffers of excluded hearsay testimony for the appellate record.

Video thumbnail9:14:25
Watch →

2. Walter Hamada — Direct/Cross

Warner Brothers DC president Walter Hamada testifies on direct and cross about Heard's Aquaman 2 contract and any career impact from the Depp dispute.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Walter Hamada Walter Hamada Benjamin Chew
64 lines

Warner Brothers president Walter Hamada testifies Heard was never released from her Aquaman 2 contract and that Depp's or Waldman's statements had no effect on her compensation.

Cross
Cross Examination of Walter Hamada Walter Hamada Elaine Bredehoft
51 lines

Bredehoft cross-examines Hamada on Aquaman 2 chemistry concerns, eliciting that no documentation existed and that Heard tested well with audiences in 2018.

3. Colloquy

Rebuttal-opening sidebar: court scopes Dr. Kulber to the March 2015 finger surgery and rejects a motion to exclude Dr. Curry as a rebuttal witness.

→
colloquy
Sidebar — Dr. Kulber Admissibility and Scope
187 lines

Sidebar resolves Dr. Kulber's admissibility as a rebuttal witness; court limits his testimony to the state of Depp's hand after the March 2015 finger surgery.

4. David Kulber — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Depp's reconstructive surgeon David Kulber testifies on direct, cross, and redirect about the March 2015 fingertip surgery and cast limitations.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of David Kulber David Kulber Jessica Meyers
45 lines

Depp's reconstructive surgeon at Cedars-Sinai testifies about the March 2015 fingertip surgery, post-operative splint, hand mobility limitations, and months-long treatment.

Cross
Cross Examination of David Kulber David Kulber J. Benjamin Rottenborn
34 lines

Rottenborn's brief cross establishes that Depp's March 2015 cast did not prevent use of his uninjured hand, conceded by Kulber.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of David Kulber David Kulber Jessica Meyers
15 lines

Meyers elicits that Depp's soft cast left the sides of his fingers unprotected, he could not form a fist, and striking with the cast would likely have damaged it.

Highlights

5. Richard Marks — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Entertainment attorney Richard Marks takes the stand in Depp's rebuttal case to challenge opposing expert Kathryn Arnold's $45M+ damages projection for Heard.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Richard Marks (Recalled) Richard Marks Rebecca Lecaroz
112 lines

Depp's entertainment expert Richard Marks rebuts Kathryn Arnold's damages opinions, challenging her comparable actors, renegotiation assumptions, and $45M earnings projection as lacking factual foundation.

Cross
Cross Examination of Richard Marks Richard Marks Adam Nadelhaft
71 lines

Nadelhaft pressed Marks about superhero deal experience; Marks could not recall a specific deal but said he knew of one or two. He described Aquaman as Heard's breakthrough role and $4 million as a conditional negotiating starting point.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Richard Marks Richard Marks Rebecca Lecaroz
9 lines

Lecaroz's two-question redirect establishes that Marks negotiated deals for Chris Pratt and Paul Rudd — both Marvel superhero actors — rehabilitating his genre credentials after cross.

Highlights

6. Michael Spindler — Direct/Cross

Depp's forensic accountant Spindler challenges Arnold's damages methodology on direct, then Rottenborn narrows his role to pure rebuttal on cross.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Michael Spindler Michael Spindler Wayne Dennison
103 lines

Forensic accountant Spindler testifies Arnold's damages analysis for Heard is methodologically unsupported, and presents Heard's historical earnings as a factual baseline.

Cross
Cross Examination of Michael Spindler Michael Spindler J. Benjamin Rottenborn
77 lines

Rottenborn's brief cross confirms Spindler's opinion is limited to rebutting Arnold's calculations and elicits that he has no experience calculating actress defamation damages.

8. Morgan Night — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Voir Dire

Full arc of Morgan Night's rebuttal testimony: dual voir dire, admissibility ruling, and direct through redirect on a 2013 Hicksville incident.

→
colloquy
Rebuttal Witness Admissibility Voir Dire
16 lines

Judge Azcarate addresses the rule on witnesses for rebuttal witness Morgan Night, outlines Virginia case law factors for permitting testimony, and begins voir dire examination with the jury excused.

Voir Dire
Voir Dire of Morgan Night Morgan Night Penney Azcarate
19 lines

Judge Azcarate vets Morgan Night's trial exposure before testimony; Night watched one clip about Hicksville and was contacted by Depp's attorneys on May 3rd.

Voir Dire
Voir Dire Examination of Morgan Night Morgan Night Elaine Bredehoft
92 lines

Bredehoft probes Night's Twitter posts about a Hicksville fire pit incident and his contacts with Depp's attorneys, testing for pretrial contamination before his rebuttal testimony.

colloquy
Ruling: Morgan Night Rebuttal Testimony Allowed
38 lines

The court heard defense objections to Morgan Night as a rebuttal witness and ruled to allow his limited testimony, finding probative value outweighed any prejudice.

Direct
Direct Examination of Morgan Night Morgan Night Camille Vasquez
166 lines

Night, former Hicksville Trailer Palace owner, describes Heard yelling at Depp during their 2013 stay and a broken light fixture found the next morning.

Cross
Cross Examination of Morgan Night Morgan Night Elaine Bredehoft
139 lines

Bredehoft impeaches Night via his pro-Depp tweet and connection to Depp's first wife, then constrains his testimony to a brief, partial view of the Hicksville visit.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Morgan Night Morgan Night Camille Vasquez
39 lines

Vasquez redirects to establish Night was contacted by Depp's team, not the reverse, and testified only to share what he personally observed.

Highlights

9. Richard Shaw — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Depp's rebuttal psychiatrist Richard Shaw testifies on direct, cross, and redirect, challenging Heard's expert Dr. Spiegel's opinions on Goldwater Rule grounds.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Richard Shaw Richard Shaw Stephanie Calnan
245 lines

Stanford psychiatrist Richard Shaw, called by Depp, testified that Heard's expert Dr. Spiegel violated the APA's Goldwater Rule by opining on Depp's personality and cognition without examination.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Richard Shaw Richard Shaw Adam Nadelhaft
35 lines

Nadelhaft challenged Shaw's Goldwater Rule credentials, established Depp declined Spiegel's examination requests twice, and introduced ethics committee authority supporting Spiegel's approach.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Richard Shaw Richard Shaw Stephanie Calnan
6 lines

Calnan's redirect of psychiatrist Richard Shaw lasted moments: one confirmatory question, a single affirmative answer, and "nothing further."

10. Jennifer Howell — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Jennifer Howell testifies by video: Whitney Henriquez's residence dates, Howell's observations of Depp and Heard, and scrutiny of her outreach to Whitney.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Jennifer Howell Jennifer Howell Elaine Bredehoft
14 lines

Jennifer Howell, CEO of Art of Elysium, confirms via video deposition that Whitney Henriquez lived with her from May 2015 to April 2016.

Cross
Cross Examination of Jennifer Howell Jennifer Howell Camille Vasquez
62 lines

Howell testifies she never witnessed Depp use drugs or Heard disclose abuse, confirms she pays her own fees, and introduces an email urging Whitney Henriquez to tell the truth.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Jennifer Howell Jennifer Howell Clarissa K. Pintado
11 lines

Pintado redirects Howell on Waldman's role in drafting her email to Whitney and on the Fidelity Charitable donation Art of Elysium received in Heard's honor.

12. Post-Testimony Matters

After the jury is dismissed, defense counsel Nadelhaft proffers excluded testimony and exhibits from nine witnesses and the UK judgment for appellate review.

→
colloquy
Defense Evidence Proffers for the Record
59 lines

Defense counsel Nadelhaft proffers excluded testimony and exhibits from nine witnesses and the UK judgment for the appellate record, with distinct grounds including hearsay, improper expert opinion, speculation, and the finding that the door to the U.K. judgment had not been opened.

← Day 202022 Defamation TrialDay 22 →