Day 16 - May 16, 2022
Bredehoft completed Heard's direct through the May 2016 penthouse incident; a sidebar set character-evidence scope; Vasquez opened cross by challenging absent corroborating evidence and questioning her use of "donated" for the incompletely paid $7 million charity pledge.
Full day summary
8:54:291. Amber Heard — Direct/Cross
Heard completes direct on the May 2016 penthouse incident; a sidebar on prior-conduct evidence precedes Vasquez opening cross.
Highlights
Amber Heard Direct Examination (Continued)Heard revised the date of the first alleged assault to early 2012, then gave her most detailed trial account of the May 21, 2016 phone-throw and LAPD response, anchored by photographs and audio recordings Depp himself made.Amber Heard Direct Examination (Continued)“You never forget it; that's how I remember it. It changes your life forever.”— Amber HeardHeard's explanation for why the date — not the fact — of the first alleged assault shifted, offered on direct to pre-empt cross on her credibility.Motion to Admit Heard's Prior Violence IncidentsJudge Azcarate allowed impeachment questions on Heard's prior alleged violence against Tasya van Ree and Raquel Pennington but excluded arrest records as too prejudicial, defining the scope for cross-examination.Motion to Admit Heard's Prior Violence Incidents“Whether Ms. Heard was abusive to Mr. Depp and whether she ever committed abuse towards someone else is not an essential element of any claim or defense in this case. It's just not.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornThe core of Rottenborn's Rule 404/405 opposition, arguing the parties are asymmetrically situated with respect to character evidence on prior violence.Cross Examination of Amber HeardVasquez opened cross by playing the San Francisco 'you will not see my eyes again' recording and the 'tell the world' recording, then confronted Heard with her flat denial of ever hurting Depp.Cross Examination of Amber Heard“You don't like looking at my fucking eyes? You will not see my eyes again.”— Johnny DeppPlayed from Exhibit 1229 to reframe Depp's in-court behavior as a kept promise rather than consciousness of wrongdoing, opening the cross-examination.Cross Examination of Amber HeardVasquez closed cross by pressing Heard on the charity pledge, eliciting the admission that she had not yet paid $3.5 million to the ACLU and that she used 'pledge' and 'donation' interchangeably despite sworn statements to the contrary.Cross Examination of Amber Heard“I use pledge and donation synonymous with one another.”— Amber HeardCentral admission undercutting Heard's sworn UK statement and public interview, both of which described the full $7 million as already 'donated' to charity.Cross Examination of Amber Heard“I have not yet.”— Amber HeardDirect acknowledgment that the $7 million had not been paid, the sharpest single-line contradiction of Heard's prior sworn and public statements on the pledge.