Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayLeo J. PresiadoCamille VasquezElaine BredehoftRaquel PenningtoniO Tillett WrightAmber HeardcolloquycrossredirectdirectDay 17 - May 17, 2022Vasquez concluded her cross of Heard attacking the Australia sequence, May 21 injury accounts, and op-ed "of and concerning" claims; iO Tillett Wright and Raquel Pennington testified for Heard, with Wright placing a 911 call during the May 2016 incident.
← Day 162022 Defamation TrialDay 18 →

Day 17 - May 17, 2022

Heard Cross-Examination, iO Tillett Wright and Raquel Pennington

Judge Penney Azcarate
9Proceedings
3Pages
3Witnesses
4,190Lines
Day 17 of 27
Appearing:

Vasquez concluded her cross of Heard attacking the Australia sequence, May 21 injury accounts, and op-ed "of and concerning" claims; iO Tillett Wright and Raquel Pennington testified for Heard, with Wright placing a 911 call during the May 2016 incident.

Full day summary

Camille Vasquez completed an extensive cross-examination of Amber Heard, using audio recordings, prior sworn statements, and contradicting witness testimony to challenge the Australia bottle-assault sequence, the absence of May 21, 2016 injury photographs corroborated by six witnesses, and the op-ed's connection to Depp. Bredehoft's redirect attempted rehabilitation through prior consistent statements, but extended sidebars resulted in most Falati-note evidence excluded on double-hearsay grounds. iO Tillett Wright testified he never personally witnessed Depp assault Heard but corroborated Heard's account through observed injuries, Depp's own "monster" admissions, and a 911 call he placed during the May 21 phone call. On recross, Wright conceded both parties exchanged vicious statements. Raquel Pennington's direct examination narrowed her firsthand knowledge of the Hicksville incident to a single verbal statement by Depp, with the trailer account combining Heard's telling and Pennington's own observation of knocked-off light fixtures and other disarray the next morning; she did not witness the damage occur.

Video thumbnail8:31:55
Watch →

1. Amber Heard — Cross/Redirect

Day 17 opens with rulings on photo metadata and deposition clips, then runs Vasquez's full cross of Heard into a heavily objection-curtailed redirect.

→
colloquy
Photo Metadata Ruling; Deposition De-Designation Dispute
70 lines

Judge sustains objection to Heard's photo metadata exhibits and rules Heard's team may continue de-designating deposition clips under the 61-hour time constraint.

Cross
Cross Examination of Amber Heard Amber Heard Camille Vasquez
3012 lines

Vasquez cross-examines Heard across Australia, penthouse, Bahamas, 30th birthday, May 21 and the op-ed, repeatedly contrasting her testimony with recordings, photos, witness accounts and the UK record.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Amber Heard Amber Heard Elaine Bredehoft
440 lines

Bredehoft rehabilitates Heard on TMZ connections, Depp's post-mediation love note, ENT nose injuries, December 2015 Falati reporting, and Waldman's UK trial conduct.

Highlights

Cross Examination of Amber HeardVasquez played Depp's 30th-birthday 'haymakered me' audio recording — in which Heard did not deny the accusation in real time — then confronted Heard with testimony from six witnesses who reported seeing no visible injuries on the night of May 21, 2016.Cross Examination of Amber Heard“I didn't want you to fucking go to Coachella without fucking talking to me because I left you because you were fucking -- you fuckin' O haymakered me, man. You came around the bed …”— Johnny DeppDepp's recorded accusation about the 30th-birthday incident, played by Vasquez to show Heard did not deny it in real time — central to the cross-examination of the Australia-to-Coachella injury timeline.Cross Examination of Amber HeardVasquez conducted a line-by-line attack on the op-ed, pressing Heard on whether the phrase 'I became a public figure representing domestic abuse' was about Depp; Heard maintained it referred to the aftermath rather than to him.Cross Examination of Amber Heard“It is not. It is about what happened to me afterward. That's the more interesting - was the more interesting thing for me to write about.”— Amber HeardHeard's core defense on the 'of and concerning' element — the legal linchpin of Depp's defamation claim — insisting the op-ed described her public identity, not Depp.Photo Metadata Ruling; Deposition De-Designation DisputeThe court excluded Heard's photo metadata exhibits on foundation and hearsay grounds, keeping potentially authenticated photographic evidence from the jury, while allowing Heard's team to continue de-designating deposition clips under the 61-hour trial limit.

3. iO Tillett Wright — Direct/Cross/Redirect

iO Tillett Wright's complete testimony — direct, cross, and redirect — spanning his friendship with both parties, observed injuries, and his 911 call during the May 2016 penthouse incident.

→
Procedural
Count I Motion to Strike Denied; Tweet Republication
17 lines

Judge denies motion to strike on Count I, ruling that tweeting the op-ed with additional content could constitute republication; jury resumes after deposition setup.

Direct
Direct Examination of iO Tillett Wright iO Tillett Wright Leo J. Presiado
97 lines

Wright confirms he never witnessed Depp assault Heard, describes Depp's substance-fueled behavior as misogynistic and cruel, and characterizes Heard's drug use as minimal.

Cross
Cross Examination of iO Tillett Wright iO Tillett Wright Elaine Bredehoft
191 lines

Bredehoft elicits Wright's accounts of Depp's substance abuse, demeaning behavior toward Heard, a wedding punch comment, injury photos, and the May 2016 911 call.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of iO Tillett Wright iO Tillett Wright Leo J. Presiado
35 lines

Presiado drew concessions on mutual verbal hostility while Wright maintained Depp mixed substances and characterized thrown dishware as physical violence.

Highlights

← Day 162022 Defamation TrialDay 18 →