Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewJ. Benjamin RottenbornChristi Dembrowskiopening_statementdirectcrosscolloquyDay 1 - April 12, 2022Plaintiff and defense delivered opening statements framing the defamation and First Amendment theories, then Christi Dembrowski opened the witness phase before being impeached on texts revealing her awareness of Depp's substance use.
← Day 02022 Defamation TrialDay 2 →

Day 1 - April 12, 2022

Opening Statements and Christi Dembrowski's Testimony

Judge Penney Azcarate
8Proceedings
4Pages
1Witnesses
1,819Lines
Day 1 of 27
Appearing:

Plaintiff and defense delivered opening statements framing the defamation and First Amendment theories, then Christi Dembrowski opened the witness phase before being impeached on texts revealing her awareness of Depp's substance use.

Full day summary

Plaintiff's counsel Chew and Vasquez identified three specific op-ed statements as defamatory, previewed police and photo evidence they argue contradicts Heard's account of the May 21 apartment incident, and outlined Depp's irreversible reputational harm. Defense counsel Rottenborn countered that the op-ed never named Depp and that his career decline predates its publication; a sidebar barred Bredehoft from referencing the UK libel proceedings during her opening. Christi Dembrowski, Depp's older sister and personal manager, then opened the evidentiary phase by tracing their abusive childhood and drawing a parallel to the Depp-Heard relationship dynamic. On cross, Rottenborn confronted her with February 2014 texts in which she told Depp to "stop drinking, stop coke, stop pills," drawing the concession "I wrote the words" and undermining her minimization of his substance use. The day closed with evidentiary rulings partially admitting Heard's "JD is on a bender" text. Bredehoft alleged that a juror had waved to Depp; Vasquez disputed that the gesture was directed at him. Judge Azcarate said she had not seen it and would repeat the no-contact instruction when jurors returned the next morning.

Video thumbnail7:29:40
Watch →

1. Opening Statement — Plaintiff

Plaintiff's opening statement: Chew and Vasquez present Depp's theory that Heard fabricated abuse allegations, displaying the Washington Post op-ed and identifying the three statements at issue.

→
Procedural
Opening Procedures and Jury Instructions
21 lines

Court opens proceedings, judge addresses jury on seating and courtroom conduct, transition to opening statements.

Opening
Opening Statement — Plaintiff's Case Benjamin Chew
92 lines

Benjamin Chew and Camille Vasquez outline Depp's theory that Heard fabricated abuse allegations to control him and advance her career, causing irreparable harm to his reputation.

Highlights

3. Christi Dembrowski — Direct/Cross

Christi Dembrowski's direct and cross examination — Depp's sister testifies on the relationship, then is challenged with her own texts about his substance use.

→
Procedural
Jury Entry and Motion in Limine
30 lines

Judge confirms jury readiness, counsel agree on Motion in Limine order, jury enters the courtroom, and first witness Christi Dembrowski is called to testify.

Direct
Direct Examination of Christi Dembrowski Christi Dembrowski Benjamin Chew
795 lines

Depp's sister and personal manager testifies about a childhood marked by their mother's abuse, her observations of the Depp-Heard relationship, and learning of Heard's divorce filing at the funeral home after their mother's death.

Cross
Cross Examination of Christi Dembrowski Christi Dembrowski J. Benjamin Rottenborn
579 lines

Rottenborn uses 2013–2014 text messages to contradict Christi Dembrowski's denials, showing she knew of Depp's substance abuse and expressed concern to Heard in writing.

Highlights

← Day 02022 Defamation TrialDay 2 →