Day 2 - April 13, 2022
Christi Dembrowski's cross concludes with her own texts and Dr. Kipper's email as impeachment; Baruch testifies to no visible injuries on Heard post-May 21; ECB manager Patterson authenticates 87 surveillance clips.
Full day summary
8:03:281. Christi Dembrowski — Cross/Redirect
Rottenborn's cross wraps with exhibit-based impeachment; Chew's redirect is largely blocked by sustained hearsay objections.
Highlights
Cross Examination of Christi Dembrowski (Continued)Rottenborn uses Dr. Kipper's August 2014 email and Christi's own texts to Amber to establish that Depp's substance abuse concerns were raised by sources other than Heard, including Christi's coordination of press management around the Australia finger injury.Cross Examination of Christi Dembrowski (Continued)“I love him so much, but he needs help, and I don't have all the information to help alone.”— J. Benjamin RottenbornRottenborn reads Christi's own 2014 text to Amber aloud, placing her admission that Depp needed help into the record against her minimizing direct testimony.
2. Isaac Baruch — Direct/Cross
Isaac Baruch direct and cross — Depp's ECB neighbor testifies he saw no injuries on Heard after May 21; cross exposes financial ties to Depp and makeup expertise gaps.
Highlights
Direct Examination of Isaac BaruchBaruch testifies that despite Heard's own May 22 verbal allegation of violence, his close-range inspections of her face across May 22–25 revealed no cuts, bruises, swelling, or redness.Direct Examination of Isaac Baruch“I don't see a cut, a bruise, swelling, redness. It's just Amber's face that she's going like this (indicating) and showing me.”— Isaac BaruchBaruch's core May 22 inspection finding — no visible injury — directly contradicts Heard's abuse allegations and the photographs she later presented to court.Cross Examination of Isaac BaruchBredehoft limits Baruch's 'no injuries' testimony by exposing his ignorance of Heard's makeup routine and his financial dependence on Depp, then introduces October 2016 texts in which Depp called Heard a 'cunt' and wished her dead.Cross Examination of Isaac Baruch“He says that cunt ruined such a fucking cool life we had for a while.”— Isaac BaruchBaruch reads Depp's October 2016 text aloud under cross, introducing Depp's own language about Heard into the record and undercutting the character portrait drawn by Depp's witnesses.
3. Brandon Patterson — Direct/Cross
ECB general manager Brandon Patterson authenticates surveillance footage from May 2016 and acknowledges that a "fake punch" clip was never preserved.
Highlights
Direct Examination of Brandon PattersonPatterson authenticates 87 ECB surveillance clips as business records and revises his characterization of Depp in elevator footage from 'animated' to 'upset about something' after audio is restored.Cross-Examination of Brandon PattersonPatterson confirms that mezzanine footage showing someone 'fake punching' Heard existed at the time of his handwritten note on the Waldman declaration but was never requested by either side and has since been overwritten.Cross-Examination of Brandon Patterson“The footage was never requested.”— Brandon PattersonPatterson confirms that the mezzanine fake-punch footage — the only evidence of that incident — was not selectively withheld but simply never requested by either side before it was overwritten.