Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewRebecca LecarozAshlee StemlandCamille VasquezElaine BredehoftJ. Benjamin RottenbornIsaac BaruchChristi DembrowskiBrandon PattersoncrossredirectdirectDay 2 - April 13, 2022Christi Dembrowski's cross concludes with her own texts and Dr. Kipper's email as impeachment; Baruch testifies to no visible injuries on Heard post-May 21; ECB manager Patterson authenticates 87 surveillance clips.
← Day 12022 Defamation TrialDay 3 →

Day 2 - April 13, 2022

Dembrowski Cross, Isaac Baruch and Building Surveillance

Judge Penney Azcarate
10Proceedings
3Pages
3Witnesses
2,972Lines
Day 2 of 27
Appearing:

Christi Dembrowski's cross concludes with her own texts and Dr. Kipper's email as impeachment; Baruch testifies to no visible injuries on Heard post-May 21; ECB manager Patterson authenticates 87 surveillance clips.

Full day summary

Day 2 concluded Christi Dembrowski's impeachment cross, with Rottenborn using Dr. Kipper's August 2014 email and Christi's own May 2014 texts to Amber — including "he needs help" — to establish that concerns about Depp's substance abuse originated independently of Heard. Hearsay objections limited Chew's redirect; Dembrowski's personal characterization of Heard remained, while the court struck the last sentence about what others had told her. Isaac Baruch, Depp's friend since 1980 and Eastern Columbia Building neighbor, then testified he inspected Heard's face on May 22 and observed no injuries, cuts, bruises, or swelling across multiple close-range encounters through May 25. On cross, Bredehoft challenged Baruch by establishing he had no knowledge of Heard's makeup routine, exposed his financial ties to Depp, and introduced October 2016 texts in which Depp called Heard a "cunt" and wished her dead. ECB general manager Brandon Patterson closed the day by authenticating 87 surveillance clips from May 2016, retaining his description of Depp as "animated" and adding "upset about something" once audio was restored, and confirming that mezzanine footage of someone "fake punching" Heard was never requested by either side and no longer exists.

Video thumbnail8:03:28
Watch →

1. Christi Dembrowski — Cross/Redirect

Rottenborn's cross wraps with exhibit-based impeachment; Chew's redirect is largely blocked by sustained hearsay objections.

→
colloquy
Exhibit Redactions and Jury Protocols
48 lines

Court addresses exhibit redactions for 214 and 210, clarifies jury contact protocols regarding juror gestures toward defendant, and prepares to resume Ms. Dembrowski's cross-examination.

Cross
Cross Examination of Christi Dembrowski (Continued) Christi Dembrowski J. Benjamin Rottenborn
505 lines

Rottenborn uses Dr. Kipper's email and Christi's own texts to establish that concerns about Depp's substance abuse and on-set conduct came from sources beyond Amber Heard.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Christi Dembrowski Christi Dembrowski Benjamin Chew
52 lines

Chew's brief redirect is largely blocked by sustained hearsay objections, leaving only Christi's personal observations about Heard's presentation style intact.

Highlights

2. Isaac Baruch — Direct/Cross

Isaac Baruch direct and cross — Depp's ECB neighbor testifies he saw no injuries on Heard after May 21; cross exposes financial ties to Depp and makeup expertise gaps.

→
Procedural
Witness Called: Isaac Baruch
10 lines

The court calls Isaac Baruch, Depp's neighbor at the Eastern Columbia Building, as a witness for the plaintiff.

Direct
Direct Examination of Isaac Baruch Isaac Baruch Rebecca Lecaroz
518 lines

Depp's longtime friend and Eastern Columbia Building neighbor testifies he observed no injuries on Heard's face during multiple close-range encounters on May 22–25, 2016.

Cross
Cross Examination of Isaac Baruch Isaac Baruch Elaine Bredehoft
658 lines

Bredehoft challenges Baruch's injury observations through makeup expertise gaps, reveals his financial dependence on Depp, and introduces texts where Depp calls Heard a "cunt."

Highlights

3. Brandon Patterson — Direct/Cross

ECB general manager Brandon Patterson authenticates surveillance footage from May 2016 and acknowledges that a "fake punch" clip was never preserved.

→
colloquy
Video Deposition and Surveillance Exhibits
96 lines

Court procedures for presenting Brandon Patterson's video deposition with agreed-upon selections from 87 Eastern Columbia Building surveillance video exhibits.

Direct
Direct Examination of Brandon Patterson Brandon Patterson Ashlee Stemland
844 lines

ECB general manager Patterson authenticates 87 security video clips from May 2016, confirms chain of custody, and describes Depp as "animated" then "upset" in elevator footage.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Brandon Patterson Brandon Patterson Camille Vasquez
228 lines

Vasquez authenticated 17 ECB surveillance clips as business records; Stemland then elicited that footage of a "fake punch" near Heard was never requested by any attorney and no longer exists.

Procedural
Jury Recess and Trial Schedule Management
13 lines

Judge thanks jury for staying late, reiterates the Memorial Day completion deadline, warns that trial must accelerate to finish, and confirms no remote witnesses scheduled for tomorrow.

Highlights

← Day 12022 Defamation TrialDay 3 →