Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewSamuel MonizCamille VasquezAdam NadelhaftJ. Benjamin RottenbornLaurel AndersonGina DeutersKate JamesDavid KipperdirectcrossredirectrecrosscolloquyDay 3 - April 14, 2022Day 3 concludes Kate James's testimony with a UK trial impeachment, features couples therapist Laurel Anderson's mutual-abuse characterization, sees Gina Deuters' testimony stricken for a witness-rule violation, and opens Dr. Kipper's deposition.
← Day 22022 Defamation TrialDay 4 →

Day 3 - April 14, 2022

Kate James, Laurel Anderson and Dr. Kipper's Deposition

Judge Penney Azcarate
14Proceedings
4Pages
4Witnesses
2,709Lines
Day 3 of 27
Appearing:

Day 3 concludes Kate James's testimony with a UK trial impeachment, features couples therapist Laurel Anderson's mutual-abuse characterization, sees Gina Deuters' testimony stricken for a witness-rule violation, and opens Dr. Kipper's deposition.

Full day summary

Day 3 completed Kate James's cross-examination with Rottenborn drawing the admission that her UK trial confirmation was "just being agreeable" rather than truthful — the sharpest credibility strike of the examination. Couples therapist Laurel Anderson then delivered the day's most legally significant testimony, describing Heard's self-reported habit of initiating physical confrontations as "a point of pride" and characterizing the relationship as mutual abuse; authenticated therapy notes showed Heard asking whether filing a police report first would give her a legal advantage. Gina Deuters, Depp's longtime friend, was stricken mid-examination after Judge Azcarate learned she had watched trial clips online in violation of the witness sequestration rule, with the jury instructed to disregard her testimony entirely. A further procedural incident produced a new standing rule barring all non-legal-team members from the front row after Depp's counsel alleged that journalist Eve Barlow had passed misleading, misdated materials to Heard's team. The day closed with the start of Dr. David Kipper's video deposition, which included his firsthand description of the Australia house on March 7, 2015 — in disarray, with what appeared to be blood on the wall.

Video thumbnail7:31:49
Watch →

1. Kate James — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Kate James, Heard's former personal assistant, completes her full examination cycle — credibility challenged on direct and redirect, zero injury observations elicited on cross.

→
colloquy
Exhibit Redaction and Witness Scheduling
61 lines

Discussion of exhibit redaction requirements and clarification of the 48-hour witness notification rule between counsel.

Direct
Direct Examination of Kate James Kate James J. Benjamin Rottenborn
523 lines

Heard's counsel questions ex-personal assistant on Waldman contacts, absence of observed violence, and impeaches her with contradictory UK trial testimony about a Depp text.

Cross
Cross Examination of Kate James Kate James Camille Vasquez
322 lines

Vasquez elicits James's account of three years as Heard's assistant: no injuries observed, Depp described as peaceful, and Heard's verbal abuse and substance use detailed.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Kate James Kate James J. Benjamin Rottenborn
17 lines

On redirect, Rottenborn asked James about Heard's insecurity, Depp's substance use, and whether insecurity or feeling 'smothered' could justify abuse. James declined to answer the final questions.

Highlights

2. Laurel Anderson — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross

Couples therapist Laurel Anderson's complete testimony cycle — direct through recross — covering her 2015 session notes and Heard's self-reported initiation of violence.

→
Procedural
Morning Recess and Witness Readiness
18 lines

Court takes morning recess and midday break, then resumes to call Dr. Laurel Anderson as the next witness via video.

Direct
Laurel Anderson — Direct Examination Laurel Anderson Adam Nadelhaft
162 lines

Couples therapist Anderson recounts 2015 sessions, describing Heard's self-reported initiation of physical violence and a dynamic she characterized as mutual abuse.

Cross
Cross Examination of Laurel Anderson Laurel Anderson Benjamin Chew
338 lines

Chew's cross walks Anderson through her therapy notes, surfacing Heard's admissions of initiating physical violence and strategizing about filing a police report for legal advantage.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Laurel Anderson Laurel Anderson Adam Nadelhaft
27 lines

Nadelhaft redirects Anderson to clarify bruise observations, contextualize Depp's therapy note language, and establish the finger injury was first disclosed on June 18, 2016.

Recross
Recross Examination of Laurel Anderson Laurel Anderson Benjamin Chew
3 lines

Chew's single-question recross confirms Depp was absent when Heard described incidents of his violence in solo therapy sessions.

Highlights

3. Gina Deuters — Direct

Gina Deuters testifies on Depp's behavior around substances and Heard's demeanor at dinner, before her testimony is stricken for a sequestration violation.

→
Procedural
Lunch Recess and Exhibit Redactions
56 lines

Judge confirms lunch break and resolves pending exhibit redactions with counsel before jury returns for afternoon testimony.

Direct
Direct Examination of Gina Deuters Gina Deuters Samuel Moniz
262 lines

Depp friend Gina Deuters testifies about his substance use and her observations of Heard's behavior, before a sidebar over her social media posts interrupts the examination.

colloquy
Witness Struck, Front Row Rule Set After Eve Barlow Incident
123 lines

Judge Azcarate strikes Gina Deuters' testimony after she admits watching trial clips, then bars non-legal-team from front row following Eve Barlow's note-passing.

Highlights

← Day 22022 Defamation TrialDay 4 →