Skip to content
2022 Defamation Trialtrial-daytrial-dayBenjamin ChewWayne DennisonSamuel MonizAshlee StemlandAlan BlausteinElaine BredehoftMichelle KaplanAdam NadelhaftJ. Benjamin RottenbornEllen BarkinEric GeorgeTracey JacobsJessica KovacevicJoel MandelMichele MulrooneyTina NewmanMarie SadanagaRon SchnellAdam WaldmanBruce Witkincolloquydirectcrossredirectvoir_direrecrossDay 19 - May 19, 2022Heard's witness bloc documented Depp's career decline and substance abuse before the op-ed, Adam Waldman's "hoax" statements anchored the counterclaim, and social media expert Ron Schnell quantified Twitter harm while facing causation challenges on cross.
← Day 182022 Defamation TrialDay 20 →

Day 19 - May 19, 2022

Career Testimony, Adam Waldman and Social Media Evidence

Judge Penney Azcarate
32Proceedings
12Pages
12Witnesses
2,927Lines
Day 19 of 27
Appearing:

Heard's witness bloc documented Depp's career decline and substance abuse before the op-ed, Adam Waldman's "hoax" statements anchored the counterclaim, and social media expert Ron Schnell quantified Twitter harm while facing causation challenges on cross.

Full day summary

Day 19 was dominated by Heard's witnesses building the counterclaim and pre-op-ed reputation defense in parallel. Former agent Tracey Jacobs and business manager Joel Mandel both testified that Depp's career decline and financial deterioration preceded Heard's 2018 op-ed and stemmed from his own conduct and substance abuse. Adam Waldman confirmed making "hoax" and "ambush" statements to the Daily Mail while invoking privilege on authorization, and Rottenborn exposed his claimed LAPD perjury investigation as self-initiated and unverifiable. Social media expert Ron Schnell presented Twitter analysis showing 2.38 million negative hashtags against Heard correlated with Waldman's statements, but cross-examination established the hashtags predated Waldman and his analysis showed only correlation, not causation. Psychiatrist Alan Blaustein's 2014–2015 session notes documented Depp's expressed anger toward Heard and a "violence/rage" self-reference, and attorney Eric George confirmed Heard followed all legal advice before publishing the op-ed.

Video thumbnail8:50:01
Watch →

1. Bruce Witkin — Direct

Judge warns both sides over courthouse photography and a TikTok posting; Heard's team then calls Bruce Witkin, Depp's 40-year friend and ex-brother-in-law.

→
colloquy
Preliminary Matters — Alpaca Photo, TikTok Incident, Rebuttal Ruling
93 lines

Judge reprimands Chew for violating her photography order near the courthouse, discloses a TikTok balcony incident involving courthouse staff's children, and limits Bercovici to rebuttal.

Direct
Direct Examination of Bruce Witkin Bruce Witkin Ashlee Stemland
241 lines

Depp's 40-year friend and ex-brother-in-law testified for the defense about Depp's drug use, a bruise on Heard's arm, and their estrangement after his prior deposition testimony.

Highlights

3. Joel Mandel — Direct

Depp's former business manager testifies on direct about post-2010 substance use patterns and the financial collapse that ended their professional relationship.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Joel Mandel Joel Mandel Elaine Bredehoft
125 lines

Depp's former business manager Joel Mandel testifies by deposition about Depp's financial decline, substance abuse, and directly refutes Depp's claim that TMG failed to file his taxes.

colloquy
Sidebar re: Waldman Counterclaim Exhibits
40 lines

Sidebar on admission of Waldman counterclaim statement exhibits, with arguments regarding relevance to damages and reporter knowledge.

4. Adam Waldman — Direct/Cross

Waldman's full examination: Bredehoft and Rottenborn probe his "hoax" press statements, repeatedly blocked by privilege; Chew's cross frames him as an independent attorney.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Adam Waldman Adam Waldman Elaine Bredehoft
482 lines

Heard's counsel examines Depp's attorney Waldman about Daily Mail statements calling Heard's allegations a hoax, as Chew repeatedly invokes attorney-client privilege to block answers.

Direct
Direct Examination of Adam Waldman (Continued) Adam Waldman J. Benjamin Rottenborn
79 lines

Rottenborn questions Waldman about his May 21 witness list, contacts with social media personalities, and the basis for his public claim of an LAPD perjury investigation.

Cross
Cross Examination of Adam Waldman Adam Waldman Benjamin Chew
28 lines

Brief cross by Depp's counsel establishing Waldman as an independent attorney who owns Endeavor Law Firm and is not Depp's employee.

Highlights

5. Marie Sadanaga — Direct/Cross/Redirect

LAPD DV coordinator Marie Sadanaga testifies on mandatory incident-report protocols, followed by a post-lunch sidebar on expert-witness scope.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Marie Sadanaga Marie Sadanaga Elaine Bredehoft
55 lines

LAPD DV coordinator Marie Sadanaga explains department protocols, including mandatory documentation requirements and the significance of 'verbal dispute' language used in May 2016.

Cross
Cross-Examination of Marie Sadanaga Marie Sadanaga Samuel Moniz
20 lines

Moniz elicits that officers cannot force uncooperative victims to speak, but visible injuries allow independent probable cause determination regardless of victim cooperation.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Marie Sadanaga Marie Sadanaga Elaine Bredehoft
17 lines

Bredehoft clarifies on redirect that officers must investigate visible injury at DV scenes and document incidents for future reference regardless of victim cooperation.

colloquy
Sidebar: Bercovici Rebuttal-Expert Designation
49 lines

Post-lunch sidebar in which Heard's team argued Bercovici should testify beyond rebutting Frost; Judge Azcarate upheld her prior ruling that he is a rebuttal expert only.

6. Ron Schnell — Direct/Redirect/Recross/Voir Dire

Heard's social media expert Ron Schnell: full testimony arc from voir dire qualification through redirect, covering Twitter API data on anti-Heard hashtag volume.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Ron Schnell Ron Schnell Adam Nadelhaft
103 lines

Heard's counsel walks Ron Schnell through his computer science credentials and social media forensic expertise before tendering him as an expert; Depp's team requests voir dire.

Voir Dire
Voir Dire Examination of Ron Schnell Ron Schnell Wayne Dennison
11 lines

Dennison's opening voir dire question about Schnell's tweet analysis is cut off when the court sustains an objection limiting voir dire to qualifications only.

colloquy
Expert Qualification — Social Media Forensic Analysis
21 lines

At sidebar, Judge Azcarate clarified that voir dire is for expert qualification only; Dennison conceded no objection, and the court admitted Heard's social media expert in open court.

Direct
Direct Examination of Ron Schnell Ron Schnell Adam Nadelhaft
165 lines

Heard's expert Ron Schnell presents Twitter API analysis showing 2.38 million negative hashtag uses against Heard, with spikes correlating to Waldman's alleged defamatory statements.

Recross
Recross Examination of Ron Schnell Ron Schnell Wayne Dennison
154 lines

Dennison questioned Schnell about hashtags that predated Waldman's statements and whether the Twitter data showed causation rather than correlation.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Ron Schnell Ron Schnell Adam Nadelhaft
31 lines

Nadelhaft's redirect reaffirms Schnell's core findings: all sampled "justice for Johnny Depp" tweets were negative toward Heard, 25%+ cited Waldman, and negative volume doubled after April 2020.

Highlights

7. Michele Mulrooney — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Deposition testimony from Heard's former postnuptial attorney covering direct, cross, and redirect on Depp's 2015 call that ended negotiations.

→
Procedural
Sidebar: Deposition Video and Trial Scheduling
58 lines

Sidebar on deposition video compliance and trial scheduling as Heard's team addresses improperly prepared videos containing sustained objections before closing arguments.

Direct
Direct Examination of Michele Mulrooney Michele Mulrooney Elaine Bredehoft
83 lines

Estate planning attorney Michele Mulrooney testifies via deposition that a 2015 postnuptial negotiation for Heard ended abruptly when Depp called and fired her, calling her a "bitch."

Cross
Cross Examination of Michele Mulrooney Michele Mulrooney Benjamin Chew
21 lines

Chew established that Depp lacked authority to fire Mulrooney; she testified that her representation of Heard ended within a few days of Depp's call.

Redirect
Redirect Examination of Michele Mulrooney Michele Mulrooney Elaine Bredehoft
5 lines

Bredehoft's two-question redirect confirms no further postnuptial communications followed Depp's call, and that Mulrooney had no doubt Depp was the caller.

8. Tina Newman — Direct

Disney's corporate designee takes the stand on Day 19, addressing whether any internal documents tied Heard's op-ed to Depp's casting fate.

→
Direct
Direct Examination of Tina Newman Tina Newman Elaine Bredehoft
114 lines

Disney's corporate designee says she is unaware of Disney documents containing Heard's op-ed or a decision-maker citing it for Depp's casting; those decisions were above her authority, and she could not speak for her superiors.

← Day 182022 Defamation TrialDay 20 →