Day 19 - May 19, 2022
Heard's witness bloc documented Depp's career decline and substance abuse before the op-ed, Adam Waldman's "hoax" statements anchored the counterclaim, and social media expert Ron Schnell quantified Twitter harm while facing causation challenges on cross.
Full day summary
8:50:011. Bruce Witkin — Direct
Judge warns both sides over courthouse photography and a TikTok posting; Heard's team then calls Bruce Witkin, Depp's 40-year friend and ex-brother-in-law.
Highlights
Preliminary Matters — Alpaca Photo, TikTok Incident, Rebuttal RulingJudge Azcarate reprimanded Benjamin Chew for violating her no-photography order with an alpaca photo and disclosed a separate TikTok incident in which courthouse staff children filmed client arrivals from a balcony, warning of sanctions for future violations.Direct Examination of Bruce WitkinDepp's 40-year friend Bruce Witkin testified to observing a bruise on Heard's upper arm consistent with a grab mark, offering eyewitness corroboration of physical force with no personal stake in her defense.Direct Examination of Bruce Witkin“It looked similar to that, but it didn't look like a -- it looked like a grab, not a punch, like somebody grabbed her arm.”— Bruce WitkinEyewitness description of a bruise on Heard's arm consistent with physical force, offered by a witness with no personal stake in her defense and estranged from Depp precisely because of his truthful prior testimony.
4. Adam Waldman — Direct/Cross
Waldman's full examination: Bredehoft and Rottenborn probe his "hoax" press statements, repeatedly blocked by privilege; Chew's cross frames him as an independent attorney.
Highlights
Direct Examination of Adam Waldman“The part with the quote marks, I believe I said that, yes.”— Adam WaldmanWaldman's on-record confirmation that he made the 'ambush, a hoax' statement to the Daily Mail — the factual cornerstone of Heard's counterclaim.Direct Examination of Adam Waldman (Continued)Rottenborn exposed that Waldman's public claim of an LAPD perjury investigation into Heard was self-initiated — Waldman had filed the complaint himself and could not produce contact information for the anonymous desk officer he cited.
10. Alan Blaustein — Direct
Depp's former psychiatrist authenticates session notes from late 2014 documenting substance use and expressed anger toward Heard, introduced on direct.
Highlights
Direct Examination of Alan BlausteinPsychiatrist Alan Blaustein read session notes from Depp's own initial consultation documenting a 'violence/rage' self-reference and Depp's comparison of Heard to his 'mother and psychotic sister,' placing his expressed anger toward her on record before the Australia trip.Direct Examination of Alan Blaustein“There was violence/rage that we had over a couple years.”— Alan BlausteinBlaustein reads session notes he attributes to Depp's own words at initial consultation, placing a self-described pattern of violence and rage on record through Depp's own psychiatrist in a proceeding called by the plaintiff.